Theories📚 Flashcards
Paul Grice (1975) (context and identity)👩🏼
Came up with maxims:
- Quantity
- Relevance
- Manner
- Quality
Irving Goffman (1955) (context and identity)👩🏼
Came up with concept of face
Brown and Levinson (1987) (context and identity)👩🏼
Developed Goffman’s theory into positive and negative politeness
Giles (context and identity)👩🏼
Accommodation theory
Convergence
Divergence
Fairclough (power)👩🏼
- We unconsciously select an appropriate register which reflects our status
- Language helps us create hierarchy of power relationships
- Most conversations have a power struggle
Aristotle (identity)👩🏼
Ethos, pathos, logos
Peter Trudgill (gender and identity)👩🏼
Covert and overt prestige - said women are more likely to use overt prestige
Often supports Lakoff’s model
Pateman (power)👩🏼
Oppressive and repressive discourse strategies
Julia Stanley - 1977 (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Negative semantic space for women
* Women carry a negative association with various societal roles
Muriel Schulz - semantic derogation - 1975 (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Terms related to women become pejorative over time
* She examined pairs of words, such as dog and bitch and master and mistress
The Bodine theory - hegemony (gender and identity)👩🏼
- We live in an androcentric society where many words and figures of speech are slanted towards the superiority of men over women
- Men are seen as dominant over women
Miller and swift (gender and identity)👩🏼
Women are often portrayed as emotional and irrational
De Klerk (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Linked expletive use to exerting a masculine identity (gender)
- Did not say it was a feature of either sex
- Helps to exert power
The deficit model - Robin Lakoff (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Language used by and about men is the norm and women’s language is judged
- Women’s language is seen as deficient
- Men use more powerful language while women use more tentative language
- One finding - women used specialised lexis for colours and men used specialised lexis for sports
- Women hedge, speak in italics, use empty adjectives, use hyper correct grammar, wh-imperatives etc. See notes for more
Behaviourist theory - B.F. Skinner (child language)👶🏼
Imitations and reinforcements
•Children learn by a ‘trial and error method’ and through imitating adults
•Their behaviour is then reinforced by negative or positive feedback from the caregiver
•This is known as operant conditioning
The dominance model (1975) - West and Zimmerman (founded it) and Dale Spender (she supports it) (gender and identity)👩🏼
- In mixed sex conversations, women are dominated by men
- Women do not assert themselves in interactions - if she does, she must hedge to suppress the effect and respect for the laid down societal norms
- Men dominate by being more verbose and initiating topics more successfully
- Men often interrupt women
- This way of ‘doing power’ indicates women’s language is weak and powerless
- Found that women use no overlaps with men, but frequently with other women
Geoffrey Beattie - contradicts dominance model (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Said West and Zimmerman’s study would only have taken one very voluble man to impact results
- Interruptions aren’t necessarily a sign of dominance
Dale Spender - supports the dominance model (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Language is biased towards males - ‘man made language’
- Challenges the view that women gossip - men are more likely to talk, women are more likely to listen
- Marked and unmarked terms
O’Barr and Atkins - contradicts dominance model and deficit model (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Analysed courtroom discourse and found female lawyers to be assertive and often interrupt
- Found that witnesses of both sexes would use Lakoff’s weak ‘female’ language - these weak language traits are actually a “powerless language” rather than a “female language”
- Men are more humorous
Chomsky - Nativist theory (child language)👶🏼
- Children have an inbuilt capacity to acquire language - ‘Language Acquisition Device’ (LAD)
- Suggests that as children learn language, they create unique utterances like ‘her not hungry’ - child is experimenting with morphology
- Came up with term virtuous error for non standard forms
Bruner - Social Interactionist Theory (Child language)👶🏼
•Stresses the fundamental role of social interaction in the development of a child’s language acquisition
•Coined the acronym LASS (Language Acquisition Support System) - child’s interaction with others and how a caregivers interaction can develop a child’s language
E.g. child directed speech, accommodation, interrogatives, shared knowledge
•Could say caregivers are teaching the child the ‘art of conversation’
Deborah Tanner - The difference model (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Coined the term genderlect to describe the way that the conversations of men and women is not right and wrong, superior and inferior - just different
- SEE NOTES FOR MORE DETAIL
- Support vs status, advice vs understanding, information vs feelings, orders vs proposals, conflict vs compromise, independence vs intimacy
Baker (2010) (gender and identity)👩🏼
- The honorific Ms still has a long way to come before it’s considered the favourable female gendered title, suggesting it has marked connotations - Ms created by feminists but has stigma
- The noun girl is more likely to be used compared to the noun boy when referring to adults
Pamela Fishman (1980) (gender and identity)👩🏼
- Supports difference model
- Women carry out the ‘interactional shiftwork’
- This suggests women are more supportive in conversation and will engage in more turn-taking, tag questions, minimal responses and forms of back-channelling