social influence Flashcards
aim of aschs study
conformity due to group pressure
results of aschs study
36.8% agreed and gave wrong answer
25% never gave wrong answer
conclusion of aschs study
people influenced by group pressure
also high level independence
participants went against group opinion
resisting pressure to conform
weakness of aschs study
relevant to 1950s america
conformist times
mccarthyism so scared to behave differently
asch effect only applicable in some situations
weakness of aschs study
artificial task and situation
doesn’t reflect everyday situations as it’s with strangers
trivial task
may not be generalised to situations where not conforming consequences are more important
weakness of aschs study
reflective of individualist cultures eg in america and uk
some cultures focus much more on community eg putting family in consideration when choosing a partner
conformity in collective cultures increased
more oriented to group needs
dispositional factors to conformity
about you
your disposition
social factors to conformity
features of surrounding areas hat make you feel stronger pressure
depends on group around you
social factor: group size
more people greater pressure up to a point
2 confederates 13.6%
3 confederates 31.8%
adding confederates made little difference
weakness of social factor: group size
diff effects based on task eg music preferences
group side does matter as there’s no right answer
social factor: anonymity
conformity lower
weakness of anonymity
study was with strangers
anonymity effect changes if group of individuals are friends
people conform more
task difficulty
harder it is uncertainty of answer increases
people feel less confident and look for others for right answer
weakness of task difficulty
may not be true for everyone
greater expertise may be less affected by task difficulty
personality
locus of control
external means they do not control things that happen to them
on a continuum
burger and cooper 1979: asked to rate cartoons of funniness
with confederate shouting ratings
internal control less likely to conform than external
weakness of personality
locus of control no effect on conformity in familiar situations
more affected by how you behaved in past
shows that personality is affected by other factors
expertise
increases confidence in opinions and knowledge
lucas et al 2006 : those who rated themselves better at maths were less likely to conform
weakness of expertise
simplistic as it only focuses on one single factor
being an expert may not be sufficient eg you might want to be liked
obedience
a type of social factor that causes a person to act in response to a direct order from authority figurr
agency theory
acting as an agent for authority figure because they assume its their responsibility
agentic state
acting on behalf of someone
no responsibility
autonomous state
behave according to own principles
responsible for own actions
agentic shift
change from autonomous to agentic state
when a person perceives someone else as an authority figure
social hierachy in agency theory
people progressively more authority
agreed by society
allows society to function smoothly
strong social norm in cultured