SOCIAL INFLUENCE Flashcards
Explanations for obedience
What are the explanations for obedience?
Agentic state
Legitimacy of authority
Explanations for obedience
What is the agentic state?
When we act as an agent of someone in authority
We find it easier to deny personal responsibility for our actions
Thus protecting our self image
Explanations for obedience
When does the agentic shift occur?
When confronted with an authority figure
Explanations for obedience
What is the autonomous state?
Direct OWN behaviour
Take responsibility
Explanations for obedience
What are binding factors?
Even if they feel the actions are wrong, they are unable to stop
Stopping would lead to worse consequences
Explanations for obedience
Strengths of the agentic state as an explanation for obedience
Research support
Milgrim
Ppts in shock experiment acted as an agent of the lab assistant who encouraged them to shock the learners
Explanations for obedience
Strengths of the agentic state as an explanation for obedience
Real- life application
Doctors at Auschwitz
Explanations for obedience
Limitations of the agentic state as an explanation for obedience
Culture bias
Collectivist cultures are taught to obey authority
Agentic state wouldn’t be as relevant in individualistic cultures
Explanations for obedience
Limitations of the agentic state as an explanation for obedience
Features of science
Relies on self reporting
NOT objective, reliable or empirical
Explanations for obedience
What is legitimacy of authority as an explanation for obedience?
We are more likely to obey people we perceive have authority
Authority is justified by position of power within a social hierarchy
Explanations for obedience
What factor makes an authority figure seem legitimate?
Authority figure needs to be inside a certain institution
e.g. lab or university
Explanations for obedience
Strengths of legitimacy of authority as an explanation for obedience
Research support
Milgrim
Situational variables like uniform (casual) and location (run down office) increased obedience
In both repeat tests, 48% shocked to 450v in comparison to 65% in the original tests
Explanations for obedience
Strengths of legitimacy of authority as an explanation for obedience
Real- life application
Doctors at Auschwitz
Explanations for obedience
Limitations of legitimacy of authority as an explanation for obedience
Culture bias
Collectivist cultures are taught to obey authority
Agentic state wouldn’t be as relevant in individualistic cultures
Explanations for obedience
Procedure of Milgrims original shock experiment
40 male American ppts
Learners (confeds) to answer Qs about word lists to test of punishment increases learning
Teacher (ppt) told to shock incorrect answers
Increasing voltage by 15v each time
15- 450v with buttons labelled with severity of shock
Lab assistant (confed) prompted ppt
Explanations for obedience
Findings of Milgrims original shock experiment
100% to 300v
65% to 450v
Due to agentic state
Explanations for obedience
What were the 3 situational variables Milgrim tested?
Proximity
Uniform
Location
Explanations for obedience
Original vs repeat shock tests for proximity
Prodedures
org. teacher and learner in different rooms
rep. teacher and learner in same room
Explanations for obedience
Original vs repeat shock tests for proximity
Findings
Obedience decreased
Explanations for obedience
Original vs repeat shock tests for uniform
Procedures
org. lab assistant wore grey lab coat
rep. lab assistant called out of room and replaced by replaced by someone wearing casual clothes
Explanations for obedience
Original vs repeat shock tests for uniform
Findings
Obedience decreased
48% shocked to 450v
Explanations for obedience
Original vs repeat shock tests for location
Procedures
org. Yale Lab Uni
rep. Run down office block
Explanations for obedience
Original vs repeat shock tests for uniform
Findings
Obedience decreased
48% shocked to 450v
Explanations for obedience
Strengths of situational variables as an explanation for obedience
Research support for uniform
Bush- dressed in 3 costumes and asked the public for parking money
police- 72%
businessman- 48%
begger- 52%
Explanations for obedience
Strengths of situational variables as an explanation for obedience
Real- life application
Attitude towards war crimes
Less blame
Explanations for obedience
Limitations of situational variables as an explanation for obedience
Small sample
Org. 40 ppts
Not generalisable
Explanations for obedience
Limitations of situational variables as an explanation for obedience
Culture bias
American ppts
No generalisable
Explanations for obedience
Limitations of situational variables as an explanation for obedience
Ethics
Deception
NO informed consent
Psychological harm