Schizophrenia Flashcards
Diagnoses/classification of schizophrenia (inter-rater reliability) against
CHENIAUX
- 1 psychiatrist made 2x as many diagnoses (70 vs 37) due to dif interpretations of manual.
- Differences in opinions of serve tofu of delusions made difference.
Diagnoses/classification of schizophrenia (diagnostic congruence between manuals) against
CHENIAUX
- Nearly 2x as many diagnosis with ICD than DSM due to different criteria.
- Differences in symptoms required and duration - 1 negative symptom and continuous disturbance for 6 months needed in DSM-5.
Diagnoses/classification of schizophrenia (co-morbidity) against
BUCKLEY
Of those with schizophrenia:
- 50% had depression
- 47% had substance abuse
- 29% had PTSD
- 23% had OCD
Family dysfunction support
READ - general
Reviewed 46 studies of child abuse and schizophrenia 69% of female inpatients physically/sexually abused in childhood
KAVANAGH - EE
Mean relapse rate for those returning to high EE families 48% vs 21% for low.
Dysfunctional information processing support
STIRLING
- Compared 30 schizophrenics with 18 controls on range of cognitive tasks.
- In Stroop test had to suppress impulse to read word and say colour instead (= central control).
- Schizophrenics took twice as long
Genetic basis support
GOTTESMAN
Genetic similarity related to increased concordance rate:
- 48% MZs
- 17% DZs
- 13% children
- 9% siblings
- 6% parents
TIENARI
- Adoption study of 19,000 children and mothers.
- Those with schizophrenic biological mother at higher risk (7.6%) than controls (1.5%) when in non-schizophrenic adoptive families.
Neural correlates (negative symptoms) support
JUCKEL
- Participants unmedicated.
- Lower activity in ventral striatum when presented with reward indicating cues.
- Negative correlation between activity and severity of symptoms.
Neural correlates (positive symptoms) support
ALLEN
- Compared brains of those experiencing auditory hallucinations and control.
- Hallucinations group made more errors in distinguishing their own voice from others’ in recording.
Drug therapy (typical) support
THORNLEY
Procedure:
- Reviewed studies comparing chlorpromazine and placebo.
- 13 trials, 1121 patients overall.
Findings:
- Chlorpromazine groups showed improved symptoms and better functioning.
- Data from 512 patients showed reduced relapse.
Drug therapy (atypical) support
MELTZER
- Review showed clozapine more effective than chlorpromazine and other atypical antipsychotics.
- Effective in 30-50% of cases where typical antipsychotics haven’t been.
CBT support
JAUHAUR
Meta-analysis of data from randomised trials.
-0.33 in 34 studies on overall symptoms
-0.25 in 33 studies on positive symptoms
-0.13 in 34 studies on negative symptoms.
Significant but small effect.
Family therapy support
PHAROAH
- Review evidence for effectiveness of family therapy in 53 randomly allocated (Chinese weren’t) trials.
- Moderate evidence for:
Decreased hospital admission over a year.
Decreased frequency of relapse.
Increased compliance with medication.
Improved levels of social impairment and levels of EE.
Token economies support
MCMONAGLE AND SULTANA
- Reviewed evidence for effectiveness of token economies in 3 randomly allocated trials with a total of 110 participants.
- Only 1 of the 3 studies showed improvement in symptoms.
- None useful information about behaviour change.
Diathesis-stress support
TIENARI
Procedure:
- Followed up 19,000 adoptees with schizophrenic biological mothers.
- Compared to control group of adopted children with no genetic risk.
- Adoptive parents assessed for child-rearing styles.
Findings:
- Parenting styles of high levels of criticism and conflict and low levels of empathy associated with increased risk for children with high genetic risk.
- Low genetic risk and low c/c family = 3.5%
- Low genetic risk and high c/c family = 7%
- High genetic risk and low c/c family = 7.5%
- High genetic risk and high c/c family = 34%
Combination therapy support
TARRIER
- 315 patients randomly allocated to medication/CBT, medication/counselling or medication alone (control).
- Patients in combination groups experienced more symptom improvement than control.
- No difference in hospital readmission.