Russia AOS2 Perspectives Flashcards
Trotsky
Belief that a new society would be easy to create
‘What sort of diplomatic work will we be doing anyway? I shall order a few revolutionary decrees to the people, then shut up shop’.
He lacks a plan and mistakenly believes that it’ll be easy to rule Russia
the new regime had inexperienced leaders
Antonov-Ovseenko (a commision for military affairs)
Madness following initial fall of the Provisional government
‘The whole city was infested by the drinking madness’
Wine riots or ‘drink pogroms’ broke out across Petrograd following the ransacking of the wine cellars of the Winter Palace -> fighting on the streets, targeting of the wealthy + looting.
Bolsheviks hadn’t stopped intitial madness
Eventially Officials confiscated alcohol and poured it into the gutter and yet crowds gathered in the streets to drink the alcohol off the floor.
Trotsky
Approval to attacks on symbols and people of Wealth and privlege
There is nothing immoral in the proletariat finishing off a class that is collapsing – that is its right’.
Bolshevik view = popular violence had a purpose in terrorising + removing class enemies (bourgeoise) -> Bolsheviks gave explicit approval to attacks on symbols and people of wealth and privilege.
(lass warfare)
Lenin (to a group of workers)
Only wanting a destruction of property that could support the revolution
‘You are the power: do all you want to do, take all you want. We shall support you, but take care of production, see that production is useful’.
he wanted them to take out the class enemies but needed production to continue
the Bols didn’t call for complete law and order and were happy to see the old system crumble just not the things they needed
Lenin
Purpose of the new decrees
Lenin: ‘The purpose of a decree is to teach practical steps to the hundreds, thousands, and millions of people who heed the voice of the Soviet government. This is a trial in practical action’.
116 new decrees were introduced which was excitiing for people because it was tearing up the past
this included the land, press and workers controll decree
Lenin
On building a new world
‘Yes, we shall destroy everything and on the ruins we shall build our temple!’
116 reforms introduced
reforms that moved them towards the prolateriat dictatorship
Lenin’s declaration to the assembly after results of the C.A. election
‘The toiling masses have become convinced by their experience that bourgeoisie parliamentarianism is outdated; that it is completely incompatible with the construction of Socialism’
Trotsky on use of force to end C.A.
‘Lenin’s theoretical considerations went hand in hand with sharpshooters’
Lenin on use of force to end C.A.
‘Trust in the mood, but don’t forget your rifles.’
Lenin on successful seizure of power after C.A.
‘We will not exchange our rifles for a ballot.’
Victor Serge on public response to end of C.A.
‘The dissolution of the CA made a great sensation abroad. In Russia, it passed almost unnoticed.’
Lenin
Biggest threat to the Bols
Lenin remarked that peasant insurgents were ‘far more dangerous than all the Denikins, Yundeniches and Kolchaks put together’.
Lenin
Significance of the Soviet-Polish war
‘I thought it was wiser to come to terms with the enemy… the temporary sacrifice of a hard peace appeared to me preferable to a continuation of the war... We had to make peace.’
Breathing space for Bols.
Focus on Civil War / domestic issues rather than international affairs
Latsis (Cheka Deputy)
Regarding interrogations
‘First you must ask him to what class he belongs…determine the fate of the accused. That is the meaning of the Red Terror.’
Purpose of Red Terror is an excuse to eliminate class enermy and engage in class war with bourgeoise and privilleged.
Dzerzhinsky (Iron Felix, Leader of Cheka)
Organising Red Terror
‘We stand for organised terror… The Cheka is obliged to defend the revolution and conquer the enemy even if its sword does by chance sometimes fall on the heads of the innocent.’
Purpose of the Red Terror is to exterminate enemies and consolidate power through fear and terrifying the masses through the slaughter of innocents will discourage any opposition while delivering on promises of class war.
Latsis
Origins of the Red Terror
‘We are not waging war against individual persons. We are exterminating the bourgeoise as a class.’
Decree on Red Terror targets bourgeois
Zinoviev ordered execution of bourgeois hostages
Red Gazette promises blood of bourgeois in retalliation to assassination attempts despite SR involvement
Class enemy propoganda and delivery of promises
Chamberlain
Dzerzhinsky
‘an old revolutionary of the most impeachable idealism.’
Iron Felix believed whole-heartedly in defending the revolution and in exterminating enemies of the workers = bourgeois -> genuine belief
Harding
Dzerzhinsky
‘There was about him no hint of personal corruption or self-interested abuse of his powers’
Iron Felix was righteous in his beliefs and virtuous in his mind, believing he was defending the revolution to the best of his ability
When Trotsky asked who ordered the execution of the Tsars family how did Sverdlov reply?
Sverdlov replied, ‘We decided it here. Ilyich (Lenin) believed that we should not leave the Whites a live banner to rally around.’
they wanted to remove any possible opposition