Research Methods part 2 Flashcards
What is a laboratory experiment?
an experiment carried out in a controlled setting,
What is a field experiment
a controlled experiment conducted outside a laboratory, the iv is still manipulated by the experimenter therefore casual relationships can be demonstrated
advantages and disadvantages of laboratory experiments
+ high internal validity as they have good control over all variables - the change in the DV is more likely due to the manipulation of the IV
- low ecological validity as participants are aware they are being studied so will behave differently and the tasks are more artificial
advantages and disadvantages of field experiments
- lower internal validity - more difficult to control extraneous variables and confounding variables
+ higher external validity as they have more mundane realism
+ participants are unaware that they are being studied therefore there behaviour is more natural and they are less likely to respond from cues from the investigator
What is a natural experiment
a research method in to which experimenter has not manipulated the iv directly, the IV would vary whether or not the researcher was interested and they would record the results of the dv
What is a Quasi-experiment?
studies that are almost experiments but the independent variable is not something that varies at all but a condition that exists, the researcher records the effect on the dv
give an example of a Quasi-experiment?
gender differences
age
what are the advantages and disadvantages of a natural experiment
+ allows research where the iv cant be manipulated for ethical or practical reasons
+ allows researches to study real problems such as the effects of a disaster on health
- cannot demonstrate casual relationships because IV is not directly manipulated
- random allocation not possible therefore there may be confounding variables that cannot be controlled lowering internal validity
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a quasi-experiment?
+ allows comparisons between types of people
- can only be used where conditions vary naturally
- participants may be aware that they are being studied thus reducing internal validity
- the dependent variable may be an artificial task reducing ecological value
what is an opportunity sample method and what are the strengths and weaknesses
this is when you recruit people who are the most convinenet or most available
+ easiest as takes less time to find the participants
- biased as sample drawn from small part of the population
what is an random sample sample method and what are the strengths and weaknesses
producing a sample of participants by using random techniques
+ unbiased all members of target population have a chance of getting selected
- need to have a list of all memebers of the population then contact them this could take time
what is an stratified sample method and what are the strengths and weaknesses
subgroups within a population are identified, the participants are chosen from each of the strata in proportion to their occurrence in the population, the selection from the strata is done using a random technique
+ more representative
- time consuming to identify all the groups
what is an systematic sample method and what are the strengths and weaknesses
a predetermined system to select participants such as selecting every 2nd person, the numerical interval is applied consistently
+ unbiased as participants selected using an objective system
- not truly unbiased unless you select a number using a random, method and start with this person
what is an volunteer sample method and what are the strengths and weaknesses
advertise in a newspapaer or on the noticeboard
+ gives access to a variety to participants
- sample is biased as participants are more likely to be highly motivated and have extra time on their hands
describe the lottery method
- obtain a list of all the people in the population
- put all the names in a lottery barrel
- select the number of names required
describe the random number table
- every member of the population is given a number
2, the starting position in the table is determined blindly be placing you finger anywhere - if the population is less than 100 you only need 2 digit numbers so read table 2 digits at a time
describe random number generators
- every member of the population has a number
2. use calculator or electronic hat
what is a sample bias
in fact that even though all samples try to reduce bias they are eventually all disorted
what is a volunteer bias
a form of sampling bias because volunteer participants have special characteristics such as being highly motivated
what are the ethical issues
- informed consent
- deception
- right to withdraw
- protection from physical and psychological harm
- confidentiality
- privacy
described informed consent
- means revealing true aims of the study, causes demand characteristics as they may guess the aim of the study
- should be told what they will be required to do in the study so that they can make an informed decision about whether they wish to participate
- does not mean they can completely let themselves in
describe decpetion
- necessary to deceive participants about true aim otherwise they may alter there own behaviour making the study meaningless
- deception is unethical
- should not deception unless necessary
- can lead to people to see psychologists as untrustworthy
right to withdraw
- participants do leave the trial and it can cause bias and effect the outcome of the study, it is more bias because those who have been stayed are likely to be more obedient
- right to withdraw is important as if the participant begins to feel uncomfortable and distressed they should be able to withdraw
- actual experience may be different to what they consented to
- withdraw is compromised by payment or reward
protection from physical and psychological harm
- questions may involve a degree of distress to participants
- difficult to predict the outcome of certain procedures therefore guarantees protection from harm
- nothing should happen to them that causes harm
- physical - getting them to drink or smoke
- psychological - making them feel inadequate or embarrassing
- considered ok if the participants would effect them in real life
confidentiality
- may be difficult when wishing to publish the findings
- it may be obvious who has been involved in the study for example the study took place with patients in a particular hospitals
- data protection act makes confidentiality a legal right, only acceptable if published in a way that does not identify the participants
privacy
- may be difficult to avoid invasion of privacy when studying participants without their awareness
- people do not expect to be observed by others in certain situations - sitting at home compared to sitting on a bench in a park
Name types of observation
- naturalistic and controlled observation
- overt and covert observation
- participant and non-participant observation
Describe naturalistic observation
in a situation where everything has been left to normal,
e.g. watching an infant in a natural environment
Describe controlled observation
some variables in the environment are regulated by the researcher it reduces the naturalness of the environment and the naturalness of the behaviour being studied
- make take place in a laboratory
- controlled observation allows the researcher to investigate the effects of certain behaviour
Describe Overt observation
- this is when the person is aware that they are being watched
- both naturalistic and controlled observation
- try to be unobtrusive as possible - use one way mirrors to make it as natural as possible
Describe a covert observation
- participants do not have any knowledge of being observer they may be informed afterwards
Describe participant observation
- observer is part of the group being observed, this may happen in both covert and overt
Describe non participant observation
- this is merely watching or listening to the behaviour of others and acts as a non-participant, the observer from a distance des not interact with the people being observed
Evaluate natural and controlled observation
Naturalistic
- gives us a realist picture of natural spontaneous behaviour therefore it is likely to be high in ecological validity
- little control of other things - situational variables
Controlled
- an observer can focus on particular aspects of behaviour but control comes at the cost of the environment may not behave similarly