Research Methods Flashcards
What are the aims of a study
General statements of what the researcher intends to investigate
What is a hypothesis
A statement of what the researcher believes to be true. Clearly states the relationship between variables as stated by theory
What is a theory
A collection of general principles used to explain specific observations and facts
What is a directional hypothesis
States whether changes are greater or lesser positive or negative etc
What is a non directional hypothesis
Doesn’t state the direction of a study
What is the IV
The variable manipulated by the investigator
What is the Dv
The variable that is measured by the researcher
Why are all other variables beside the IV have to remain constant in a properly run experiment
So the researcher can be confident that the cause of the effect on the DV was the IV alone
What are two levels of the IV
Control condition
Experimental condition
What is operationalisation
Clearly defining variables in terms of how they cns be measured
What is an extraneous variable
Is any variable other than the IV that may have an effect on the DV. These are often nuisances that do not vary systematically with the IV but may dampen any effect such as the lighting in the lab
Example of extraneous variables
Participant variables such as intelligence
Situational variables such as distractions
What is a confounding variable
Any variable other than the IV that has affected the DV. They do change systematically with the IV so it is hard to tell if any observations come from the IV or the CV.
What are demand characteristics
Refers to any cue from the researcher or research situation that may reveal the aim of the study
What are the two demand characteristics
‘Please-U effect’
‘Screw-U effect’
What are investigator effects
Any effect of the investigators behaviour on the research outcome
What are two sources of bias
Demand characteristics
Investigator effect
What are two ways of controlling bias
Randomisation
Standardisation
What is randomisation
Refers to the use of chance when designing investigations to control the effect of bias
What is standardisation
Using the exact same formalised procedures for all participants in a research study
What are the three types of experimental design
Independent group design
Repeated measures design
Matched pairs design
What is an independent group design
One group of people do condition A another group do condition B.
Random allocation is used to assign participants to groups like drawing names out of a hat
What is a control group
A group of participants in an independent group design who receive no treatment. They act as a comparison
Strength of independent groups design
In repeated measures, order effects can occur because the same person is tested again and may do better the second time around because they know what to expect or worse because they are tired. This acts as a CV and independent groups design avoids it
What are order effects
In repeated measures design a CV arising from the order in which conditions are presented e.g a practice effect or boredom effect
Limitation of independent groups design
More participants needed than repeated measures design. They need twice as many. This means that time spent recruiting participants makes the study more expensive
Quick strength and weakness of independent group design
/ harder to guess the aim of the study
Participant variables may act as extraneous variables as everybody is different
What is a repeated measures design
Each participant does all conditions.
Order in which paritipacsnts are tested should be varied to reduce order effects.
How does repeated measures designs order effect get dealt with
Counterbalancing - half participants do condition 1 first the other do condition 2
Strength of repeated measures design
Controls participant variables. Each person acts as their own control because the person in both conditions has the same characteristics. This controls an important EV (participant variables£
Weakness of repeated measures design
Participants may do better or worse because they are doing a similar task twice. Order effects. These act as an Ev and should be compensated through counterbalancing
Quick strength and limitation of repeated measures design
Fewer participants needed than for independent groups design.
Participants may guess the aim of the study.
What is matched pairs design
Two groups of participants which acts as a compromise between independent groups and related measures as two groups are used but they are related to other by being paired.
These pairs are put into separate groups.
Strength of matched pairs design
No problem with order effects. Used two seperste groups of participants and therefore there can be no order effects nor will participants guess the aim. Enhanced the validity
Weakness of matched pairs design
Matching pairs takes time. It is a lengthy process to test participants and match them up. This increases the time taken and the costs. Matching is also not perfect
Quick strength and weakness of matched pairs design
Participant variables are partly controlled.
More participants needed than for repeated measures design
What are the four types of experiments
Labatory
Field
Natural
Quasi
What are lab experiments
Special environment where behaviour can be investigated under controlled conditions. They control EVS making it easy to control the IV. Only by controlling EVS/CVS csn we claim they the change in the IV was due to the DV
Strength and weakness of Lab experiments
EVS can be controlled and the effect on the DVs diminished. Means the experimenter can be confident in drawing a causal conclusion (high internal validity).
Lab experiments are artificial and not like everyday life. Participants know they are being observed and may behave differently meaning behaviour cannot always be generalised beyond the research setting (low external validity)
What are field experiments
Conducted in the environment where behaviour would normally occur but means there is less control compared a lab setting. IVs still controlled but less control over Ev as a result of a natural setting
Strength and weakness of field experiments
Participants are not usually aware they are being studied. Means they are likely to behave normally. Means it can be generalised. (Good external validity)
Participants are not given the opportunity to provide informed consent because they would be aware of being studied and are not always debriefed. Possible invasion of privacy raising ethical issues
What is a natural experiment
Experimenter doesn’t manipulate the IV it is a natural one such as in the study of Romanisn orphans the children were adopted without the researcher getting involved.
DV may be assessed in natural environment or in a lab.
Strength and weakness of natural experiment
In some cases it is the only ethical way research can be done. For instance in the Romanian study it would be unfair to deliberately make children experience late adoption for an experiment.
Natural events occur very rarely. Reduced the opportunity for research limiting scope for generalising findings
What is a quasi experiment
The IV is not able to be manipulated because it is a pre-existing condition such as age or gender. Participants cannot be randomly allocated to experimental conditions.
Strength and weakness of quasi experiments
Comparisons can be made regarding behaviour. Often in quasi experiments the IV is a pre-existing difference between groups of people like autism. Means comparisons can be made between people and the different behaviours they demonstrate
Random allocation to conditions is not possible. This is due to the IV being pre-existing. Means resrcger is less sure whether the IV affected the DV because other participant variables may be responsible.
What are the different sampling methods
Opportunity Volunteers Random Systematic Stratified
What does sampling mean
Selecting participants
What is the target population
Refers to the large group of people from which the sample will be drawn
What is a representative sample
One that is typical of the target population and is not biased
What do biased samples limit
The extent to which generalisations can be made
Why are most samples inevitably bias
Certain groups, ages, genders are over/under represented
What is an opportunity sample
Made up of people who are simply most available like the ones who are nearest. You just ask them to take part
Strength and weakness of opportunity sample
Quickest method to use.
Inevitably biased - unrepresentative of target population so can’t be generalised. Research bias ( may avoid some people)
What is a volunteer sample
Ask for self selecting people to take part. Might be in a news paper ad or on a notice board asking for participants
Strength and weakness of volunteer sample
Guarantees willing participants so will be willing to put more thought into the study than someone on the street.
Likely to be biased ( volunteer bias) as volunteers are likely to have a certain ‘profile’ one who is keen and helpful limiting generalisation
What is random sampling
Equal chances of selection for every member of the target population which isn’t true for opportunity or volunteer sample. Could be chosen using the lottery method where all members of population are placed in a hat and approapraite number is drawn out. Or random number tables
Strength and weakness of random sampling
Potentially unbiased as there is no infleunce over who is chosen. In reality some decline and then the remaining sample had a kind of volunteer bias - only those willing are left.
Representative sample not guaranteed.
What is systematic sampling
System is used to make a pattern which means that every men ever if the target population has an equal chance of being selected. List of all members of population is used and everything 5th or 40th etc person is used
Strength and weakness of systematic sampling
Unbiased as it’s an objective system and can be regarded as random sample if first item is selected randomly.
Takes more time and effort than other methods as a complete list of the target population has to be made much like random sampling
What is a stratified sample
Most commonly used in large scale questionnaire research. Contains participants who are selected according to their frequency in the target population. Strata are identified such as gender and the relative percentages for these are obtained and should be reflected in the sample obtained. Not a matter of equal representation in all subgroups but equal to their frequency in the target population
Strength and weakness of stratified sampling
More representative of the target population than other methods. Means generalisation of findings can become possible.
It’s not perfect. Identified strata cannot reflect all the ways that people are different within a target population so a completely representative sample is not possible
What are four ethical issues
Informed consent
Deception
Protection from harm
Privacy and confidentiality
When do ethical issues aris e
When’s conflict exists between participants rights and the researchers need to fins valuable and meaningful findings
What is the name of a code of ethical
BPS code of ethics
What is the BPS code of ethics
Quasi-legal document produced by the British Psychological Society that instructs psychologists in the UK about what behaviour is and is not acceptable when dealing with participants
What four principles does the BPS code of ethics include
Respect - appreciate the rights of others
Competence - be aware of own limits
Responsibility - avoiding harming clients or participants
Integrity - be honest and accurate
What does informed consent involve
Making participants aware of the aims, procedures, rights including right to withdraw and also what the data will be used for.
For participants under 16 what is required
Parental consent
Why does full informed consent present a dilemma
It may reveal the study’s aims and affect participant behaviour reducing validity
What are three alternatives addressing the problem of informed consent
Presumptive consent
Prior general consent
Retrospective consent
What is presumptive consent
Without getting consent from the participant themselves a sinister group of people are asked if the study is acceptable. If group agrees the original participants is ‘presumed’
What is prior general consent
Participants give permission to take part in a number of different studies including one that will involve deception
What is retrospective consent
At end of study during debriefing participants are asked for consent having already taken part in the study
What is deception
Deliberately misleading or withholding information from participants at any stage of the investigation
How can deception occur
By omission: participants may be given some information about what they will be required to do in the study but other information is withheld
False information: participants told something different to the true aim
From the researchers point of view what is deception
Harmless and necessary to conduct a valid study
What can deception be compensated by
Adequate debriefing
What four things does debriefing involve
True aim of the study
Any details not given during the study such as other experimental conditions
What data will be used for
Given the right to withhold their information if desired - important in retrospective consent
How do participants get protects from harm
The risk to participants should be no greater than in everyday life.
From the researchers point of view what is the level of potential harm
Difficult to predict, researchers may only become aware of how participants react when they are in research situations
How to deal with the issue of protection from harm
Debriefing - participant should be reassured their behaviour was typical if they feel embarrassed or anxious.
Counselling - if participants have been subject to stress or embarrassment researcher should provide it
When is it particularly important that ethical issues are dealt with
When the participants in the investigation are children. They are vulnerable and must receive special care and make sure their participation is brief as they get tired
What does privacy refer to
A persons right to control information about themselves
What is the distinction between privacy and confidentiality
We have the right to privacy, if this is invaded confidentiality/anonymity should be respected
From researchers point of view why is it difficult to know what counts as ‘public’
Some people do not wish to be observed even in public
Ways of dealing with issues in privacy
Use presumptive consent as others regard it as acceptable
Ways of dealing confidentiality issues
Use numbers instead of names or false names and don’t share the personal data with other researchers
What is the responsibility of ethical committees
To weigh up the costs and benefits of research proposals to decide whether the study should go ahead - cost- benefit analysis
What is the cost benefit analysis
Making a decision by weighing up costs like harm to the participant against gains like value of the respect
What is a pilot study
Small scale trial run of a research designed before doing the real thing
Why are pilot studies conducted
In order to find out if certain things don’t work, so you can correct them before spending time and money on the real thing
What is a pilot study trying to do
Helps the researcher Test the procedures and refine them if necessary - it’s not about getting the right results
What is a single blind study
The participant is prevented from knowing the aims so deception is involved. This is done to prevent the participants expectations affecting the participants performance
What is a double blind study
The participant and the researcher are blind to the aims of the study. A study is conducted by someone other than the main researcher to prevent investigator effects affecting someone’s performance
What is a control group
Used in experimental studies for he purpose of setting a comparison or a base line
What do control groups help to establish
Cause and effect as if the behaviour of the experimental group is different to the control group the researcher can conclude it is the effort of the IV
What are the three types of observation
Naturalist and controlled
Covert and overt
Participant and non participant
What do observations provide psychologists with
A way of seeing or listening to what people do without having to ask them
Strength of observations
Can capture unexpected behaviour. What people say they do is quite different form what they actually do so observations don’t allow for dishonesty. They are useful as they give insight into behaviour
Limitation of observation
Risk of observer bias. When collecting data for observation it may be difficult to be objective because the researchers interpretation of the situation may be affected by expectations. Involving more than one resrcher can reduce possibility of observer bias affecting validity of results.
naturalistic vs controlled observation
Naturalistic- Takes place in the setting where the target behaviour would normally occur.
In a controlled observation there is some control of the environment and EVs.
Strength and weakness of controlled observations
Easily replicated. Repeatable due to standardised procedure. Means findings can be checked to see if they occur again.
Lower validity. Behaviour produced may be contrived and artificial as a result of the setting. Can’t be applied to everyday experience.
Strength and weakness of naturalistic observation
High external validity. Behaviour is studied in the normal context so it is more natural. Means findings can be generalised to everyday life.
Low control of EV. Makes it more difficult to judge any pattern of behaviour making it More difficult to draw conclusions
Covert vs overt observations
In covert observations the participants are unaware they are being studied but in overt observations participants are aware they are being studied and they’ve given consent
Strength and weakness of covert observation
Demand characteristics are less of a factor than in overt observations. Increases the validity of the findings.
Ethics of covert observations. People may not want their behaviour noting down. Means ethics of these studies may be questioned
Strength and weakness of overt observations
Ethically more acceptable because participants have given consent to being studied. Aware their behaviour is being studied and they also have the right to withdraw their participation.
Demand characteristics are a problem. Means behaviour is less spontaneous and bust risk than it perhaps would have even, threatening the validity of the findings.
What are participant observations
The observer is part of the group they are studying for instance a study of workers and management might be improved by having the research actually join the workforce to produce a first hand account
What is a non participant observation
The researcher remains seperate from those they are studying such as trying to observer the behaviour of school children
Strength and weakness of participant observation
Lead to useful insights. Increases validity.
Possible loss of objectivity. Researcher may come to identify too strongly with those they are studying and lose obecticity. Line between being a researcher and participant becomes blurred.
Strength and weakness of non participant observations
They are more objective as the researcher keeps an objective distance from their participant so their is less chance of them ‘going native’. More validity
Loss of insight. They are far too removed form the people and behaviour they are studying reducing validity
What are questionnaires
Pre-set list of written questions to assess thoughts/ feelings. They can be used to assess the dependant variable
Strength of questionnaire
Can be distributed to a large number of people so can gather lardge amounts of data. Can also be completed without the resrcher being involved reducing the effort making it cost-effective
Limitation of questionnaire
Responses may not always be truthful. Respondents may be keen to present themselves in a positive light and this may influence their answers. Social desirability bias.
What is social desirability bias.
Tendency for respondents to answer questions in such a way that presents them in a better light
What are interviews
Face-to-face interactions. Two types of interview: structured interview made up of a predetermined question list and unstructured interview which is a free flowing interaction whrrr the interviewee is encouraged to elaborate their answers. Semi structured interview is a mix between the two where the interviewer can ask follow up questions when needed
Example of a semi structured interview
A job interview
Strength of structured interviews
Easy to replicate. Standardised format reduced the differences between interviewers
Limitation of structure interview
Can’t elaborate. It is not possible for intervieweees to deviate form topic or elaborate leading to frustration.
Strength of unstructured interview
Greater flexibility. Interviewer can follow up points as they arrive so the interviewer can gain insight into the view of the interviewed
Limitation of unstructured interview
Analysis of data is much more difficult. A lot harder to replicate so the former means that diffferences in style and types of questions between interviewers are likely introducing bias
What are the two types of self report
Questionnaire and interview
What are the theee types of observational design
Unstructured or structure observations
Behavioural categories
Observational sampling methods
What is an unstructured observation
Resrcher writes down everything they see producing accounts that are rich in detail.
When are unstructured observations appropriate
Small- scale observations and involving few participants such as a couple
What are structured observations
Predetermined list of behaviours to quantify observations they use behavioural categories
Strength and weakness of unstructured observations
Rich and detailed data is collected giving researcher more insight into behaviour than data collected in structured way.
Risk of observer bias. they may only record behaviours that catch their eye and these may not be the most important or useful. Gives unrepresentative view of participants behaviour as a whole
Strength and weakness of structured observation
Data recording and alaydis are easier. Behavioural categories makes the data more straight forwards and systematic. Quantitative data.
Key detail may be lost. Reducing observational records to numbers may loose key information. Reduced validity of eventual findings
What are behavioural categories
Structures what is being observed. Behaviour is broken into operationalised behaviours. Important that the categories are as complete as possible and that no behaviours are left out
weaknesses of behavioural categories
May be difficult to make them clear and unambiguous. They must be measurable, self evident and not overlap. For instance the difference between smiling and grinning is difficult to discern
Another limation of behavioural categories
Danger of a ‘dustbin’ category is which many different behaviours are deposited because many behaviours go unrecorded