Research and Program Evaluation II Flashcards
Positivism
An objective truth exists and can only be understood if directly observable. Truth must be measurable
Post-positivism
Truth can only be approximated bc of inherent errors present when measuring reality
Constructivisim
There are multiple realities or perspectives for any given phenomenon
Critical/ideological paradigm
Researchers taking a proactive role and confronting the social structure and conditions facing oppressed or underprivileged groups
Nuremberg Code
Stemmed from Nazi Medical War Crimbes
Milgram Obedience study
Shocks
Belmont Report
Informed consent, right to withdraw, guidelines for use of deception. Stemmed from Tuskegee syphilis study
Institutional Review Board (IRB)
any institution receiving federal funding must go through IRB to conduct research with humans
Willowbrook Study
School for children with mental disabilities, parents who wanted to enroll signed a form to allow their children to be injected with hepatitis. Parents never told they could decline injections.
Jewish Chronic Disease Hospital Study
Healthy and unhealthy patients injected with cancer cells . participants never gave informed consent and weren’t told they were being injected w/ cancer
HIPAA
privacy rights of participants
Research hypothesis (2 types)
testable, concise statement involving the expected relationship between 2 or more variables.
- Nondirectional: Eg: There is a significant relationship btwn amount of sleep and career satisfaction
- Directional: There is a significant positive relationship between . . .
Null hypothesis
Statement that there is no relationship
Alternative hypothesis
Developed in order to be eliminated and addresses the question “what else could be causing the results?”
Significance level
Threshold for rejecting the null hypothesis, with values associated with alpha (typically .001, .01, .05)
Statistical significance
Cutoff point (critical value)
P value
likelihood of obtaining a result at least as extreme as the one observed assuming the null hypothesis is true
Type I Error
(alpha) Occurs when a decision is made to reject a null hypothesis when in fact that null hypothesis is true
Type II Error
(Beta) Occurs when a decision is made to retain the null hypothesis that should have been rejected bc it’s actually false
Power
Likelihood of detecting a significant relationship between variables when one is really there
Probability sampling
Sampling a known population
Non probability sampling
More common in counseling research. Involves accessing samples of convenience
Simple random sampling (probability sampling)
Every member of population has equal chance of being selected
Systematic sampling (probability sampling)
Every nth element is chosen
Stratified random sampling (probability sampling)
Population divided into subgroups based on important characteristics (gender, race, etc) and counselor draws randomly from subgroups
Cluster sampling (probability sampling)
Counselor identifies existing subgroups and not individual participants.
Multi-stage sampling (probability sampling)
2 stage (randomly select 60 schools then 10 classes from each school) 3 stage (select 200 school districts, 20 schools, 10 classes) , etc.
Convenience sampling (nonprob sampling)
Most common method. Counselor selects an easily accessible population that most likely doesn’t represent the pop of interest
Purposeful sampling (nonprob sampling)
Counselor selects sample from a population based on who will be most informative about a topic of interest. Participants selected bc they represent needed characteristics
Quota sampling (nonprob sampling)
Counselor draws needed number of participants with the needed characteristic (gender, race) from convenience sample
Random selection
Select participants from a population so that every member of the population has an equal chance of being selected
Random assignment
Randomly assigning participants to different groups, such as treatment or control group
Internal validity
Changes in the DV are due to the effects of the IVs
History (internal validity)
Extraneous incidents occur during research. Within or outside the study
Selection (internal validity)
Group differences exist before the intervention due to lack of random assignment
Statistical regression (internal validity)
Scores of participants who were selected because of their extreme score on a dependent variable (eg: extremely depressed, low achievement) are affected Those with extremely high or low scores will regress toward the mean
Testing (internal validity)
Test itself has an impact on individuals, especially when pretests are invovled. Practice effects (memory effects)
Instrumentation (internal validity)
Changes in the instrument affect results (computerized, paper and pencil, etc)
Attrition (internal validity)
Participants drop out of a research study
Maturation (internal validity)
Changes in a participant over time affect the DV
Diffusion of treatment (internal validity)
Effects of an intervention are felt by those in another group
Experimenter effects (internal validity)
Bias of the investigator influences participant responses. Halo effect (counselors subjective, usually positive perceptions of participant are genearlized to other traits) , Hawthorne effect (presence of investigator affects participant responses)
Subject effects (internal validity)
Participants change their behaviors or attitudes based on their understanding of their role as participants. Participants will pick up cues (demand characteristics) from the researcher, or research setting, that motivate them
External validity (2 types)
Ability to generalize the results of a study to a larger group
- Population external validity: involves the population to which one can generalize
- Ecological external validity: involves the conditions or settings to which one can generalize
Novelty effect (external validity)
New treatment produces positive results just because it is new to participants
Experimenter effect (external validity)
halo and hawthorne
History by treatment effect (external validity)
experiment is conducted in a particular time period replete with contextual factors that can’t be duplicated easily in another setting
Measurement of the dependent variable (external validity)
Effectiveness of a program may depend on the type of measurement used in the study
Time of measurement by treatment effect (external validity)
Timing of the administration of a posttest may influence results
Quantitative Research
Captures relationship between 2 things that can be measured numerically
Qualitative Research
Attempts to answer questions about HOW a behavior or phenomenon occurs
Mixed Method Research (2 types)
Blends or mixes qualities from quant and qual research
- Concurrent: quant and qual are collected at same time (aka triangulation)
- Sequential design: either quant or qual data is collected first. Exploratory: qual first. Explanatory: quan first
Single-Subject research designs (SSRD)
Measure how either receiving treatment or not receiving treatment affects a single subject or group of subjects
Descriptive Research
Used to describe a phenomenon and does not involve intervention (treatment). What is and how often something occurs. Usually done as precursor or in conjunction with other research methods
Longitudinal Research
Data collection for a particular group over time
Cross-sectional research
Examines different groups or cohorts at a particular point in time, with differences in experience being compared
Survey Research
Method of collecting quant and qual data
Action research
Research that is typically carried out by professional counselors in an effort to improve their own practice/efficiency
Pilot study
Smaller than full scale study and is designed to assess feasibility of expanding a study to a much larger scale
Nonexperimental Research designs
Quant. Exploratory and descriptive. No intervention involved, no variables or conditions manipulated. Goal is to observe and outline properties of variable.
Experimental research designs
Involves intervention (counselor manipulates conditions and variables). Assess cause and effect relationships
Descriptive design (nonexperimental research design)
Thoroughly describing a variable at one time (simple descriptive) or over time (longitudinal design).