Religion, Technology And a New Approach Flashcards
What was Marcel Duchamps view on art
I’m an artist, whatever I do is art. even a urinal/fountain
What are the two major approaches to historiography
internal and external
Define the internal approach to historiography
old approach. Scientists make discoveries without being influenced by social/external factors
Define the external approach to historiography
new approach. External social factors shape development of science/technology, no inborn genius or independent idea
What approach did Thomas Kuhn have towards the origins of modern science/technology? what book did he write?
- Internal approach
- Argued of no single revolution, small revolutions or “paradigm shifts”
- “The structure of scientific revolutions”
What was thomas kuhns order of flow of paradigm shifts
established science - normal science (puzzle solving process) - novelty/anomaly - crisis in established science - emergence of new paradigm - new normal science
What are two issues with Thomas Kuhn’s order of flow of paradigm shifts
- works for early part of scientific revolution, but no later
- Two established sciences can coexist even if they contradict (newton vs Einstein)
What approach did Robert Merton have towards the origins of modern science/technology? what work did he write?
- External approach
- scientific revolution caused by religion
- “puritanism and the Rise of Modern Science”
What did Robert Merton argue regarding protestantism and catholicism and science?
- protestants used science to make profits, catholics did not
- in protestantism being wealthy was valued
- in catholicism being poor was valued, jesus was poor
What approach did Edgar Zilsel have towards the origins of modern science/tech. what word did he write?
- External
- S.R started by craftsmen, like John Harrison
- ” the social origins of modern science”
What did Edgar Zilsel argue about craftsmen and the SR
Craftsmen started the SR
- Theory - how machines work
- experimentation - trial and error observation
- actual work/interaction with devices
What approach did Harold A. Innis have towards the origins of modern science and tech. what work did he write?
External
SR free access to knowledge/comms
“empire and communications”
What did Harold A innis argue was the catalys for access to knowledge and communication
Gutenberg printing press
Who were th “gate keepers” according to Harold A innis? why?
The catholic church. the would allow or disallow publications of texts
What approach did Herbert Butterfield have towards the origins of modern science and tech. what work did he write?
- internal
- said that medieval ages were falsely labeled as periods of decline
- “the origins of modern science”