Quasi Experiments 7.3 Flashcards
Drawing causal conclusions
- To demonstrate causality you need to be able to show that differences in a DV are driven only by the different levels of the IV
- A design free of confounds
- Comparing equivalent groups
Quasi-experimental design types
- Pre-experiments
- Nonequivalent group designs
- Interrupted time series designs
One-shot case study / one-shot posttest only
•A single group is measured after a treatment or intervention
•Behavior compared to hypothetical control group that didn’t receive treatment
ex:•Measure a person’s mobility after an accident
One-group pre- and posttest design
•Measure the DV once before and once after
the treatment
•A within subjects design
•Many temporal confounds possible
Nonequivalent groups designs
•Similar to true experimental designs
except the “IV” is a subject variable
Nonequivalent groups without pretest
•Also called static group comparison •Measured only after the event of interest (no pretest) •Often used when researchers want to know how an event influenced people on a DV, but they did not know an event would occur or there was no way to obtain pretest data
Example:
Measure anxiety in individuals who experienced a
natural disaster
Interrupted time series designs
Basic Interrupted time-series design: analysis of single interrupted time
series data that is hypothesized to be affected by an intervention
(Basic) Interrupted time series design
Take multiple measurements before and after a treatment/intervention - observing trends in a time series more informative than just pretest-posttest scores
Interrupted time-series with non-equivalent
groups (multiple interrupted time series)
Like an interrupted time series, but it includes a non-equivalent control
group to provide more context for understanding the data.
Interrupted time-series with switching
replications
•The same treatment or program is implemented in two different
locations but at two different points in time.
•No control group
•It has the benefit of a built-in replication
Review of different types of quasi experiments
- Pre-experiments
- One-shot case study / one-shot posttest only
- One-group pretest-posttest
- Nonequivalent group designs
- With pretest
- Without pretest
•Time series
•Interrupted time series
•Interrupted time-series design with non-equivalent groups (multiple time-
series)
•Interrupted time series with switching replications