Psychological Explanations: Psychdynamic Explanations Flashcards
Freud’s psychodynamic theory is an example of the
Psychodynamic approach
Freud proposed that the
Superego is guided by the morality principle and leads to feelings of guilt for wrongdoing and feelings of pride for moral behaviour
Blackburn Date
1993
Blackburn argued that if the ego is somehow inadequate then the id is given
Free rein and it is not properly controlled
The id is governed by
The pleasure principle
An uncontrolled id means
Criminal behaviour is inevitable
There are three types of ‘inadequate’ superego
Weak
Deviant
Over harsh
Weak superego - During the phallic stage
The superego is formed in response to the Oedipus complex
Weak superego - If the same sex parent is absent during the phallic stage
The child cannot internalise a fully-formed superego as there is no opportunity for identification
Deviant superego - the child internalises the
Same-sex parents moral attitudes to form their superego
Deviant superego - if these internalised moral attitudes are deviant
These would lead to a deviant superego and to offending behaviour later in life
Over-harsh superego - an excessively punitive or overly harsh superego means
The individual is crippled by guilt and anxiety
The superego has
Strict rules and it’s unforgiving
Over-harsh superego - this may unconsciously drive the individual to
Perform criminal acts in order to satisfy the superegos overwhelming need for punishment
Bowlby Date
1944
Bowlby argued that a warm, continuous relationship with a mother-figure was
Crucial to future relationships, well being and development
A loss of attachment during infancy could lead to
Affectionless psychopathy and an increased likelihood of delinquency
Bowlby study of 44 juvenile thieves date
1944
How many thieves did Bowlby class as psychopaths?
14
How many of the 14 psychopaths had experienced prolonged separation from their mothers during infancy?
12
Psychodynamic theory assumes
Girls develop weaker superegos than boys
Why do girls develop weaker superegos compared to boys?
Girls do not experience the castration anxiety associated with the Oedipus complex so have less need to identify with their mothers
Because women don’t experience castration anxiety
In theory women should be more prone to criminal behaviour
are women more likely to be criminals compared to men?
no
how many men are in prison in england?
79,361
how many women are in prison in england?
3,893
there is little evidence that children raised withouta same-sex parent were less
law-abiding as adults
if children raised by deviant parents go on to commit crimes themsevles
this could be due to the influence of genetics or socialisation rather than a deviant superego
it is implausable that criminality reflects an unconscious desire for
punishment - offenders go to great lengths to conceal their actions to avoid punishment
the many unconscious concepts within Freudian theory mean that
applications to crime are not open to empirical testing
without empirical evidence
we can only judge concepts like the superego on face value