Problem Solving Flashcards
what is problem solving according to Mayer 1990
cognitive processing directed at transforming a given situation into a goal situation when no obvious method of solution is available to the problem-solver
what type of processing does problem solving involve
cognitive not automatic
what type of activity does problem solving involve
directed or purposeful
how is problem solving personal
only exists when someone lacks the relevant knowledge to produce an immediate solution
how is problem solving studied
using simple laboratory based problems
- find basic principles
- generalise to more complex settings
what is a well-defined problem
all necessary information available
- have an optimal strategy and one right answer - used in most lab based tasks
what info is provided in a well-defined problem
- initial state of problem
- goal-state
- permissible moves (legal operators)
- operator restrictions (constraints)
whats an ill-defined problem
lack of clarity at outset
-know what the goal is, but nothing in the problem describes how to accomplish the goal
what are knowledge-rich problems
can only be solved by individuals possessing a considerable amount of specific knowledge
- most research on expertise involves these types of problems
eg of knowledge-rich problems
medics
what are knowledge-lean problems
doesnt require the possession of specific knowledge
-most traditional research requires these types of problems
eg of knowledge-lean problems
the monty hall problem
fallibility as problem solvers - the monty hall problem
85% make wrong decision (stick) - why?
de nays & verschueren 2006 - the monty hall problem
- demands made on the central executive
* 22% correct fell to 8% when performed with concurrent CE task
burns & weith 2004 - Problem representation - the monty hall problem
assume hosts choice randon (it isnt - he always choses a goat)
Thorndike 1898 - early approaches to PS
behaviourist approach
operant conditioning - law of effect - Thorndike
- hungry cat in cage
- food outside cage
- initially ran around cage, attacked bard, only slowly increased speed of escape
how was the law of effect termed - thorndike - operant conditioning - hungry cats in cage
trial and error learning
- reproduction of previously learning responses
Kohler 1925 - Gestalt Approach - apes - reproductive vs productive thinking
- apes show productive thinking
- cage sticks too short to reach banana outside
- eventually restructure: join 2 sticks together to form longer one and obtain banana
what is the reproductive vs productive thinking - gestalt approach
applying existing strategy vs restructuring problem to come up with novel solution
what are insight problems - gestalt approach
require problem to be seen in a novel way, different to how seen initially
-restructure your initial problem representation to solve
how can restructuring be aided
by highlighting relevant objects
Battersby, Teuber & Bender 1953 - insight
- restricted group - told to use certain objects
- unrestricted group - use any object in room
- restricted average 2.5 mins - unrestricted 15 mins
why was Ollinger et als nine-dot problem difficult
perceptual organisation of problem causes people to make inappropriate assumptions
what is the assumption that people make in Ollinger et als nine-dot problem
the 4 lines must lie within the square
whats the first stage of Opportunistic Assimilation - insight
fail to solve problem, ‘failure indices’ stored in LTM
whats the second stage of opportunistic assimilation - insight
enter incubation stage - not consciously worked on
whats the third stage of opportunistic assimilation - insight
‘failure indices’ lead to unconscious processing
whats the fourth stage of opportunistic assimilation - insight
previously ignored information now receives attention
whats the fifth stage of opportunistic assimilation - insight
potential for solution found? - move from incubation to insight stage
whats the items and order of items in opportunistic assimilation
- Fail to solve problem, ‘failure indices’ stored in LTM
- Enter incubation stage – not consciously worked on
- ‘Failure indices’ lead to unconscious processing
- Previously ignored information now receives attention
- Potential solution found?
move from incubation to insight stage
whats incubation important for
insightful problem solving