Probate Practice Flashcards
Study aid designed for CILEx Unit 21 Probate Practice
s3(1) I(PFD)A 1975
Common guidelines (all applicants):
- financial needs and resources of App. and Bs
- moral obligations of D towards App. and Bs
- size and nature of the estate
- physical or mental disability on the part of the App. and Bs
- other relevant matters (e.g. lifetime provisions or conduct)
s. 1(1) I(PFD)A 1975
Categories of applicant:
- Surviving spouse
- Former spouse (providing no remarriage)
- Cohabitee (> 2 years immediately prior to death as H&W)
- Child of D (includes unborn, adopted and illegitimate)
- Treated as a child (e.g. step-child)
- Maintained person (wholly or partially maintained immediately prior to death without full valuable consideration)
s1(2) I(PFD)A 1975
Is the provision made in the will reasonable enough?
(a) Such provision for surviving spouse as should be reasonably afforded (not just for maintenance)
(b) Such provision for other applicants as required for their maintenance
Non-probate estate property
Property held as joint tenants Nominated property Insurance policies written in trust Discretionary trust Life interest trusts
Pre-22/3/06 WT or IV Trust
Deemed an ‘interest in possession’
Capital classed as an asset of the estate for IHT
Post-22/3/06 IV Trust
Deemed a ‘relevant property trust’
Capital NOT classed as an asset of the estate for IHT
Post-22/3/06 WT
Deemed an ‘immediate post-death interest’
Capital classed as an asset of the estate for IHT
Post-Death Variation (PDV)
Must be made within 2 years of death PRs may (with B's authority) execute a PDV
Business Property Relief (BPR)
Lifetime and death transfers
Qualification requirements:
- Shareholding (any amount for Ltd, controlling for PLC)
- Trading company (not purely investment)
- Held for minimum of 2 years (N.B. unless inherited from spouse who had held for more than 2 years)
Value of IHT relief:
100% if a private company
50% if a controlling interest in a PLC
50% for any land/property used by business but owned by deceased
Burden of IHT - lifetime gifts/failed PETs
Generally payable by donee unless will states otherwise (e.g. ‘to pay from residue any IHT arising by virtue of my death’)
Burden of IHT - IPDI/interest in possession
IHT liability is to be apportioned to the trustees (not PRs)
IHT taper relief
Lifetime transfer
For transfers made < 7 years ago:
- Apply exemptions
- Deduct from NRB
- Remainder is chargeable to IHT as per following scale:
a) 0-3 years from death: 40%
b) 3-4 years from death: 32%
c) 4-5 years from death: 24%
d) 5-6 years from death: 16%
e) 6-7 years from death: 8%
IHT annual gift exemption
£3000 per tax year (N.B. Can carry forward unused amount from previous tax year)
Deadline for payment of IHT
6 months from the end of the month in which the deceased died
Apportionment of IHT
[ASSET] / [TOTAL CH. ESTATE] x TOTAL TAX
Small gift exemption
Lifetime transfers
£250 to any one donee in any one tax year is totally exempt
N.B. If a larger gift is given, then the whole gift is chargeable
Gifts in consideration of marriage
Lifetime transfers
£5000 from a parent of party to the marriage
£2500 from other relations of party to the marriage
£1000 in all other cases
N.B. Only the excess is taxable if a larger gift is given
Spouse exemption
Lifetime/death transfers
Fully exempt from IHT
Charity exemption
Lifetime/death transfers
Fully exempt from IHT
N.B. If D dies after 5/4/12 and leaves > 10% of net estate to charity, then may claim a 4% reduction in IHT on remainder of estate
Transferable NRB entitlement
D’s NRB may be increased if:
- D died after 9/10/07
- D was a surviving spouse
- D’s spouse had not used their full NRB
Transferable NRB calculation
- Calculate percentage available for increase:
Unused NRB / NRB rate in force at time of death of D’s spouse x 100 = x%
- Increase D’s NRB rate by this percentage:
NRB rate in force at time of death of D x 1.x = New NRB threshold
Requirements for a valid will
- Testamentary capacity of T
- Intention to make will
- Observe formalities
Testamentary capacity of T
Two-fold test for testamentary capacity:
a) T must have legal capacity (i.e. over 18, unless privileged will)
b) T must have mental capacity (cf. Banks v Goodfellow/MCA 2005)
Banks v Goodfellow [1870]
T deemed to have mental capacity to make a will if:
a) T understood the nature of the effect and its effect (i.e. T was of sound mind)
b) T comprehended the extent of his property (i.e. T was of sound memory)
c) T recognised the claims to which he ought to have regard (i.e. T was of sound understanding)
s1(2) MCA 2005
A person is presumed to have capacity unless it is established otherwise
s2(1) MCA 2005
A person lacks capacity if, at the material time, he is unable to make a decision for himself because of an impairment of or disturbance in the functioning of the mind/brain
s3(1) MCA 2005
A person is unable to make a decision for himself if he is unable to understand the information relevant to the decision and to retain/use/weigh up that information to communicate his decision
Scammell v Farmer [2008]
Rules of MCA 2005 are a modern restatement of the common law test in Banks v Goodfellow [1870]
Parker v Felgate [1883]
Generally, testamentary capacity is required at the point of signing, unless it can be shown that:
- T had capacity at time of giving instructions to prepare will;
- will was prepared in accordance with those instructions; and
- T knew he was signing a will for which he had given instructions
Golden rule
Since a solicitor owes a DoC to the T and intended Bs, any doubt as to the T’s mental capacity or intention should give rise to a medical assessment and detailed file note
Intention of T
- T must know and approve the contents of his will at the date of execution (cf. Parker v Felgate [1883])
- Rebuttable presumption (on grounds of fraud, fear, mistake or undue influence) that a T with capacity has necessary intention, unless:
a) T is blind, illiterate or will signed on his behalf;
b) suspicious circumstances (e.g. benefitting drafter)
s9 WA 1837 - Formalities for execution
- Must be in writing (pencil is only deliberative)
- Must be signed by T (or by another in his presence and at his direction)
- Must intend to give effect to will by signing (mistakenly signing wrong will is invalid)
- T must sign/acknowledge signature in presence of two witnesses present simultaneously
- W should sign/acknowledge in T’s presence (but no need to do so in presence of other W)
Attestation clause
- Not strictly necessary, but if not included then the Registrar will request an affidavit of due execution
- Simplest wording is “Signed by T in our presence and then by us in his”
- Adaptation will be required for T with physical impediment, e.g. blind
- Strong evidence would be required to challenge due execution if an attestation clause is present (Sherrington v Sherrington [2005])
Execution arrangements
Solicitor should take reasonable steps to ensure due execution (written instructions alone are not likely to be sufficient) - e.g. a house visit or appointment at the office
IHT valuation rules
Generally, the open-market value is used as at the date of death, with some exceptions:
- Quoted securities (valued as per LSE official daily list for nearest date of transfer) - losses may be offset if sold by PRs within 12 months of death
- Land - losses may be offset if sold on the open market within 4 years of death
- Life assurance policies - Value for lifetime transfer is the surrender value or the total of premiums paid (whichever is the greater)
Revocation of a will
- By marriage, unless will made after 1/1/83 (s18 WA 1837) and it is clear from the will that T:
a) expected to marry a particular person; and
b) did not intend for will to be revoked by that marriage - By later will/codicil (either with express words of revocation or to the extent it is inconsistent)
- By sufficient act of destruction (e.g. burning, tearing) with intention to revoke, either:
a) by T; or
b) at direction of T in T’s presence
N.B. Revocation of a will does not automatically revive an earlier will
s21 WA 1837
- No alteration or obliteration made after execution shall be effective unless executed in the same manner as the will
- Rebuttable presumption that an unattested alteration is made after execution
Partial obliterations
If the original wording remains decipherable ‘by natural means’, the will is admitted to probate with an engrossment and the original wording is not revoked
Total obliterations
If the original wording is not decipherable, the will is admitted to probate with a blank space and is effective to revoke the original wording
Divorce, dissolution or nullity
- No revocation of will
2. Former spouses are deemed to have predeceased and any gifts to them pass as if they were not alive
Republication
Achieved either by:
- re-execution of the same document; or
- execution of a codicil referring to the earlier document
Republication of earlier will take effect from date of re-execution/execution of codicil
s22 WA 1837 - Revival
A will revoked otherwise than by destruction may be revived either by:
- re-execution of an earlier will; or
- execution of a codicil showing intention to revive earlier will
Revival of earlier will take effect from date of re-execution/execution of codicil
Incorporation of other documents
A document may become part of a will if it is:
- dispositive (i.e. list of legacies);
- clearly identified in the will; and
- already in existence at the date of execution of will
N.B. Such documents, if incorporated, will be admitted to probate (and thus public), so it is not a means of keeping terms of will secret
Survival time for spouse of intestate
28 days
Intestacy - Spouse only
Whole estate absolutely
Intestacy - Spouse and issue
Spouse:
- personal chattels (s.55(1)(x) AEA 1925)
- statutory legacy of £250k + interest, free of tax
- life interest in half of the residue
Issue:
- half residue absolutely (on statutory trusts)
- remainder interest in other half of residue
Intestacy - Spouse but no issue, yet parents/siblings (or their issue) of whole blood
Spouse:
- personal chattels (s.55(1)(x) AEA 1925)
- statutory legacy of £450k + interest, free of tax
- half of residue absolutely
Parents, if none, siblings (or their issue):
- other half of residue on statutory trusts
s.47 AEA 1925
Statutory trusts are trusts imposed by law where a class of beneficiary is entitled to a share of the estate under the intestacy rules.
Members of the class (incl. en venture sa mère) will share inheritance equally upon (the earlier):
a) reaching 18; or
b) marriage
Issue of any predeceased class member will inherit per stirpes upon (the earlier):
a) reaching 18; or
b) marriage
Intestacy - No spouse
Whole estate passes absolutely according to the statutory orde of priority:
- issue (on statutory trusts)
- parents
- brothers/sisters of the whole blood (or their issue - on ST)
- brothers/sisters of the half blood (or their issue - on ST)
- grandparents
- uncles/aunts of the whole blood (or their issue - on ST)
- uncles/aunts of the half blood (or their issue - on ST)
- Crown/Duchies of Lancaster or Cornwall as bona vacantia
s.47A AEA 1925
Spouse has a statutory right of redemption of their life interest in half of the remainder of an intestate’s estate, subject to:
- the application being made within 12 months of the date of the grant of representation (unless extended by order of the court);
- the property is in possession (i.e. no remainder interests passing on death); and
- notice is given by B to PRs or court (if B is also sole PR)
Will drafting considerations - Commencement
- Full name and address of T
- Appropriate revocation clause (full or partial)
Will drafting considerations - Appointment of executors/trustees
- Unlimited number can be appointed (N.B. only 4 may apply for a grant)
- Normal to appoint same people as executors and trustees
- 2 better than one (back up if one dies) and should be younger than T
- Must be over 18 and of sound mind
- Charging clauses for professional trustees