Principles of EBP and asking EBP questions Flashcards
PPCP
Outer: Collect, Assess, Plan, Implement, Follow up/monitor
Inner: Communicate, Collaborate, Document
EBP occurs in all parts of the PPCP
Where does EBP go in a SOAP note?
Assessment
Definition of EBP
Decision making and patient care integrated with research: “conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about care of individual pts”
Three things EBP does
- emphasized the use of evidence from medical literature
- requires searching and critical appraisal skills
- minimizes the impact of intuition, personal observations, and expert authority
Factors that impact EBP decisions
- Patient values and characteristics
- Clinical expertise
- Best evidence
Highest strength of evidence
systematic reviews of randomized controlled trials
Lowest strength of evidence
Unsystematic clinical observations
The 5 A’s in EBP
Ask Acquire Appraise Apply Act
Define the 5 A’s
- Ask and frame the question
- Acquire the evidence
- Appraise the evidence
- Apply and integrate the evidence with our clinical expertise and pt values and circumstances
- Act to implement your plan, assess your own performance
Two types of questions
Foreground
Background
What do background questions consist of
general knowledge about a medical condition or drug therapy
two parts:
1. a question root with a verb (who, what, where, why, how)
2. A disorder or an aspect of a disease or drug
Specialized background questions
DDI - detailed OTC meds IV drugs Compounding Natural products Peds Geriatrics
Where to find background answers
Textbooks
Tertiary resources
Examples of background evidence resources or therapeutics texts
micromedics, lexicomp, clinical pharmacology, up to date, PDR, Red Book, etc
Where to find info on IV drug compatibility/stability
Trissel’s (Gold standard)
King’s
Info on Drug compounding
Remington
Info on Pregnancy and Lacation
Brigg’s (Gold Standard)
Micromedex
Lexicomp
Info on DDI
Hansten and Horn
Micromedex
Lexicomp
Info on natural/herbal products
Natural medicines
Info on pediatrics
Harriet Lane
Info on Geriatrics
Merck Manual of Geriatrics
Geriatric Dosing Handbook
Other background info sources
Applied Therapeutics by Koda-Kimble Pharmacotheraphy by DiPiro Harrisons Internal medicine Current Medical Diagnosis and Tx DynaMed UpToDate
Physical assessment resource
Bates’ Guide to Physical Examination
What is a foreground question
- refers to questions related to the management of pts, which may be changing with new evidence
- asks for specific knowledge about managing pts with disorders
- in most cases, one needs to understand the background info before addressing foreground questions
What do foreground questions ask
- for specific knowledge about managing pts with disorders
2. asked in a specific format
Ask EBP questions in what format
PICO
P in PICO
Patient or population
start with broad pt and narrow
I in PICO
Interventions or exposures
C in PICO
comparators
O in PICO
outcomes important to the pt
Common types of foreground questions
Therapy
Harm
Diagnosis
Prognosis
Therapy questions
- determine the effect of different tx on improving pt function or avoiding adverse events
- generally RCT are preferred
Harm questions
- determine the effect of potentially harmful agents
- for potentially harmful exposures, an RCT is not practical or ethical
- observational studies are used, although weaker than RCT
Diagnosis questions
- establish the characteristics of a diagnostic tool
- conducted by comparing the new diagnostic tool with the gold standard
Prognosis questions
- estimate the future course of a pts disease
- typically identify a group of pts with or without factors that modify their prognosis
- follow pts to determine if they develop the target outcome
How does PICO support critical appraisal
- validity
- O = importance
P = applicability - focus on clinical outcomes
The 5 D’s (patient important outcomes of disease)
Death Disease Discomfort Disability Dissatisfaction Prevent, cure, and reduce all but death
Surrogate endpoint
Substitute for a clinically meaningful end point; biomarker; direct measure of how a pt feels, functions, or survives. Predicts effect of therapy
Is lowered BP a surrogate endpoint or clinical outcome
Surrogate endpoint
Clinical outcome would be: death, MI, stroke, etc