Prevention, Consultation, & Psychotherapy Research Flashcards
Models of Prevention
list the 3 types of prevention according to Caplan’s (1964) model
- primary
- secondary
- tertiery
Models of Prevention
match the goals of prevention with the correct type: primary, secondary, or tertiary
a. to reduce the severity and duration of a mental or physical disorder
b. to reduce the occurrence of new cases of mental or physical disorder
c. to reduce the prevalence of a mental or physical disorder in the population through early detection & intervention
Caplan’s (1964) Model
a) tertiary
b) primary
c) secondary
Models of Prevention
who are primary preventions aimed at?
Caplan’s (1964) Model
entire populations/groups
Models of Prevention
match the following examples of preventions with the correct type: primary, secondary, or tertiary
a) providing tutoring to elementary school students who are beginning ot have academic difficulties
b) prenatal care for low-income mothers
c) relapse prevention programs (e.g., AA)
d) providing individuals with counseling
e) public education program about depression & suicide
f) rehabilitation programs
g) using a screening test to identify individuals at risk for depression
h) halfway houses
i) a school-based program for 5th graders to prepare them for the transition to middle school
j) social skills training for patients with schizophrenia
Caplan’s (1964) Model
a) secondary
b) primary
c) tertiary
d) secondary
e) primary
f) tertiary
g) secondary
h) tertiary
i) primary
j) tertiary
Models of Prevention
the goal of secondary prevention
Caplan’s (1964) Model
to reduce the prevalence of a mental or physical disorder in the population through early detection & intervention
Models of Prevention
who are secondary preventions aimed at?
Caplan (1964) Model
specific individuals who who have been identified as being at elevated risk for mental or physical disorders
Models of Prevention
goal of tertiary prevention
Caplan’s (1964) Model
to reduce the severity and duration of a mental or physical disorder
Models of Prevention
who are tertiary preventions aimed at?
Caplan’s (1964) Model
people who have already received a diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder
Models of Prevention
list the types of prevention according to Gordon (1983)
- universal
- selective
- indicated
Models of Prevention
who are universal preventions aimed at?
Gordon (1983) Model
entire populations or groups that are not restricted to individuals who are at risk for a disorder
Models of Prevention
who are selective preventions aimed at?
Gordon’s (1983) Model
individuals who have been identified as being at increased risk for a disorder due to their biological, psychological, or social characteristics
Models of Prevention
who are indicated preventions aimed at?
Gordon’s (1983) Model
individuals who are known to be at high-risk because they have early or minimal signs of a disorder
Models of Prevention
match the following examples of preventions with the correct type: universal, selective, or indicated
a) a drug abuse prevention program for adolescents whose parents have a substance use disorder
b) a drug abuse prevention program for adolescents who have experimented with drugs
c) a drug abuse prevention program for all high school students in a school district
Gordon’s (1983) Model
a) selective
b) indicated
c) universal
Models of Prevention
according to the Institute of Medicine, who is the target population for universal, selective, & indicated preventions in the continuum of care model
Mrazek & Haggerty (1996)
people who have not received a diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder
Models of Prevention
according to the Institute of Medicine, what is the focus of treatment & maintenance strategies for people who have received a mental or physical diagnosis?
Mrazek & Haggerty (1996)
- preventing chronicity or relapse
- providing rehabilitation
Mental Health Consultation
how does mental health consultation differ from collaboration?
- consultation has little to no direct contact with clients
- the consultant is not responsible for the client’s outcomes
a collaborator usually has direct contact with the client & shared responsibility for the client’s outcomes
Mental Health Consultation
according to Caplan (1970), list the 4 types of mental health consultation
- Client-Centered Case Consultation
- Consultee-Centered Case Consultation
- Program-Centered Case Consultation
- Consultee-Centered Administrative Consultation
Mental Health Consultation
Client-Centered Case Consultation
1. focus
2. goal(s)
Caplan (1970)
- a particular client of the consultee who is having difficulty providing the client with effective services (e.g., having trouble identifying an appropriate treatment)
- to provide the consultee with a plan that will benefit the client
Mental Health Consultation
Consultee-Centered Case Consultation
1. focus
2. goal(s)
Caplan (1970)
- the consultee
- goals
* to improve the consultee’s ability to work effectively with current & future clients who are similar in some way (e.g., clients with TBIs, clients from specific backgrounds/cultures)
* to improve consultee’s knowledge, skills, confidence, and/or objectivity
Mental Health Consultation
Program-Centered Case Consultation
1. focus
2. goal(s)
Caplan (1970)
- focus
* program administrators
* an existing mental health program - to provide administrators with recommendations for dealing with the problems they’ve encountered in developing, administering, and/or evaluating a mental health program
Mental Health Consultation
Consultee-Centered Administrative Consultation
1. focus
2. goal(s)
Caplan (1970)
- improving the professional functioning of program administrators
- improve program administrators ability to developm, administer, and evaluate mental health programs
Mental Health Consultation
list & describe 1 factor Caplan (1970) identified as contributors to a consultee’s lack of objectivity
theme interference - occurs when a consultee’s biases & unfounded beliefs interfere with their ability to be objective when working with certain types of clients
Interprofessional Collaboration
list the 3 primary functions of Interprofessional Collaboration (IPC) in primary care settings according to Dragan & Marino (2018)
- improvement of patient care
- improvement of health outcomes for patients
- decreased healthcare costs
Interprofessional Collaboration
According to a meta-analysis conducted by Carron et al. (2021), IPC has inconsistent clinical outcomes, particularly on what factors?
- quality of life
- physical, emotional, & social functioning
- health behaviors & practices
Interprofessional Collaboration
According to a meta-analysis conducted by Carron et al. (2021), IPC has positive clinical outcomes, particularly on what factors?
- the process of care
- patient satisfaction
Interprofessional Collaboration
research on healthcare needs of older patients has provided some evidence that integrated care is associated with what outcomes?
Baxter et al. (2018); Hebert et al. (2010)
- improved access to care
- increased patient satisfaction with services provided
- fewer emergency department visits, hospitalizations, & long-term care placements
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
define efficacy research & list its benefits
clinical trials
* maximize experimental control
* maximize internal validity (e.g.. the ability to draw conclusions about the cause-effect relationship betwee therapy & outcomes)
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
describe ways that efficacy research maximizes experimental control
- assigning participants to groups
- therapists using treatment manuals to ensure standardization of treatment
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
define effectiveness research & list its benefits
naturalistic settings
* maximize external validity (e.g., the ability to generalize the conclusions drawn from the study to other people & conditions)
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
the most useful strategy for evaluating treatment outcomes
Jacobson & Christensen (1996)
- fist conduct an efficacy study to determine a treatment’s effectiveness in well-controlled conditions
- then conduct an effectiveness stidy in “real world” settings to determin its generalizability, feasibility, & cost-effectiveness
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
what is researcher, Hans Eysenck, best known for?
his conclusions about intelligence & personality
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
what did Eysenck propose?
intelligence is primarily due to heredity, with about 80% of variability in IQ scores being due to genetic factors
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
list the 3 major personality traits according to Eysenck’s (1952) personality theory
- extroversion
- neuroticism
- psychoticism
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
why was Eysenck’s (1952) literature review of treatment outcomes for “neurotic” patients who participated in psychoanalytic or eclectic psychotherapy controversial?
- the studies did not include no-treatment control groups
- the studies did not randomly assign participants groups
- the studies did not account for patient characteristics
- Eysenck used other studies to estimate the spontaneous remission rates of neurotic patiens who received care in an inpatient facility or from a physician
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
list the percentage associated with Eysenck’s (1952) average recovery rates for a) patients in psychoanalytic psychotherapy, b) patients in eclectic psychotherapy, and c) patients who did not participate in psychotherapy.
a) psychoanalytic: 44%
b) eclectic: 64%
c) no-treatment: 72%
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
what did Eysenck (1952) conclude from his psychotherapy outcome literature review?
- psychotherapy is ineffective
- psychotherapy may actually have detrimental effects since the average recovery rates for psychotherapy patients were lower than the average spontaneous remissio rate for patients who did not receive psychotherapy
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
Bergin (1971) noted that the criteria Eysench used to determine the recovery rate were questionable. He found different criteria produce what recovery rates for patients who received psychoanaltic psychotherapy vs. patients who did not receive treatmet?
a) psychoanalytic psychotherap: 83%
b) no treatment: 30%
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
who were the first researchers to use meta-analysis in psychotherapy outcome research?
Smith, Glass, & Miller
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
how many studies were included in Smith, Glass, & Miller’s (1980) meta-analysis and what was the mean effect size? what does the mean effect size suggest?
- 475 studies
- mean effect size of .85
- that the average patient who received psychotherapy was “better off” than 80& of patients who did not receive psychotherapy
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
what does an effect size indicate
the mean difference between groups in terms of a standard deviation
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
in a normal distribution, what percentage of scores are below a standard deviation of 1.0? a standard deviation of .85?
- 84%
- 80%
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
Howard et al. (1986, 1996) investigated the relationship between psychotherapy outcomes and what?
the duration of psychotherapy
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
list the 2 models resulting from Howard et al. (1986, 1996) studies of the relationship between duration of psychotherapy and its outcomes
- dosage model
- phase model
Psychotherapy Outcome Research
assumptions & predications of the dosage model
Howard et al. (1986, 1996)
- assumptions: there is a predictable relationship between the number of therapy sessions and the probability of measurable improvement in symptoms
- predictions:
- 50% of therapy clients can be expected to exhibit a clinically significant improvement in symptoms by 6-8 sessions
- 75% by 26 sessions
- 85% by 52 sessions