Page 7 Flashcards
What are the three different types of consent?
- express consent
- implied consent
- consent as a matter of law
What is consent?
When a P gives permission that is objectively manifested, making otherwise tortious behavior of the defendant privileged, and therefore defendant is not liable
What is express consent?
Words, pictures, or gestures where the plaintiff affirmatively communicates permission for the defendant to act
What is implied consent?
Under the circumstances, a reasonable person would interpret the plaintiff’s conduct as permission to act
If you don’t object to a vaccination, what have you given?
Your implied consent
When you play sports, you have impliedly consented to what?
Normal contact by other players
If you get on a busy subway, you have impliedly consented to what?
Some jostling
What is consent as a matter of law?
The law provides consent to serve the purpose of presuming what most people in society want or can be implied from community custom
What is an example of consent as a matter of law?
Emergency medical care
What is an example of consent being implied from community custom?
People usually walk across each other’s grass to knock on doors
If the community custom is to walk across each other’s grass to knock on each other’s doors, how can you negate your consent?
By putting up a sign, otherwise there is no trespass
If you tell someone they have permission to come onto your land, even though you really mean no, do they have the defense of consent?
Yes, because you objectively manifested your consent, so unless they knew you were secretly not agreeing, then you consented
When does matter of law consent apply?
- P is unconscious/unable to give consent
- immediate decision is necessary
- no reason to think P wouldn’t consent
- reasonable person in plaintiff’s position would consent
What are the different exceptions that invalidate consent?
- mistake
- incapacity beyond scope
- medical malpractice
- fraud
- duress
- illegality
What are some examples of people that do not have the capacity to consent?
- children/teenagers
- insane people
- drunk people
If you procure someone’s consent when you don’t know they are incapacitated, and there was no reasonable way to know, is their consent invalidated?
No
How does an action beyond the scope invalidate consent?
If the defendant’s conduct substantially exceeds in degree or nature the scope of the plaintiff’s consent, the defendant is liable
What is an example of consent being invalidated because the action went beyond the scope?
Agreeing to play football, but not to be bitten