Moral Principles Flashcards
Pope on rules and knowledge
We must be careful not to dismiss the rules because we think we know better
Tillich on rules
Rules are not meant to be slavishly adhered to
Pope on understanding love
To understand love is to understand the laws in their true meaning
Mouw on laws
The law of love does not necessarily hold greater weight than other laws
Concern about temptation
How does one avoid using love to justify illicit relationships?
Potential dangers of love as a principle
Could lead to selfish and individualistic actions, breaking important rules
Support for co-operation
Loving many individuals requires co-operation, communally and perhaps democratically
Agape as an ethical principle
Powerful and self-sacrificial, but complex and requiring justice and wisdom as part of it
Pope Francis on recognising human dignity in ‘The Joy of Love’
“Love inspires a sincere esteem for every human being and the recognition of his or her own right to happiness”
Exodus 20:17
“You shall not covet your neighbour’s wife”
Love in commandments
Love means fulfilling the last 2 commandments of God’s law
Pope Francis on compassionate approach
Advocates for a compassionate approach, acknowledging both wisdom in rules and realism in difficulties
Pope Francis on authority in ‘The Joy of Love’
“Nor it is helpful to try to impose rules by sheer authority”
Pope Francis on authority in ‘The Joy of Love’
“Nor it is helpful to try to impose rules by sheer authority”
G.K Chesterton’s quote
“Tradition is the democracy of the dead”
Risk of agape application
Taking agape love too far could be overly permissive
Tillich on rules and love
Rules have some bearing but must always be interpreted through love, balanced with the wisdom of moral rules as a corrective to subjectivity
Tillich on individual deliberation
Moral action is where individuals actualise themselves as persons, giving ultimate authority to the individual’s own deliberations
Tillich on traditional laws
“Laws of religions, nations, and society embody traditional laws” and should not be applied abstractly to every situation
Tillich on the voice of situations
Each situation has its own voice that cries out, which can be heard if driven by love
Tillich on moral situations
Love needs to act in the immediate, concrete moral situation, not hypotheticals
Paul Tillich in ‘Ethical Principles of Moral Action’
Critical of Christian moral decision-making that follows rules, calling it Moral Puritanism
Dimensions of agape love
Agape includes eros – love of the true, good, and beautiful; philia – love of friendship and trust; libido – sexual love
Paul Tillich on love’s connection
Love is a continuous desire to break through isolation connected to every person
Paul Tillich on ethics
Ethical norms such as justice, love, and wisdom should work together. Love is most important, guided by wisdom and having justice as its backbone
Rudolf Bultmann quote
“God is love” is more than an idea, it is concrete content. “God forgives sin”
Rudolf Bultmann on Christian morality
The challenge is to move beyond laws and judgements to forgiveness based on love
Prophetic Christianity
Insists on the ideal of love in morality – ultimate law of life is love
Orthodox Christianity
Denies relevance of love in ordinary moral matters, reducing morality to conformity of tradition