Module 11 - Gender Development Flashcards
Sex
Sex refers to biological differences
Sex is typically associated with physical sex characteristics, chromosomes, and hormones.
While sex is often categorized as male or female, there is variation in the biological aspects of sex. For example, intersex is a general term used for people who are born with sexual anatomy that doesn’t fit traditional male or female anatomy
Gender
Gender refers to socially constructed roles, behaviours, and attitudes.
While gender is often categorized as feminine or masculine, gender exists on a continuum and is not binary, and it can change over time.
Gender identity influences how people understand themselves, their relationships with others, and their interactions with society.
Historically, masculine and feminine behaviours were differentiated by
Assertion
Affiliation
Cooperation
Assertion (gendered behaviours)
Tendency to exert influence over the environment via competitive, independent, or aggressive behaviours
For example, standing up for yourself, being assertive, getting your way in a situation.
Stereotypically masculine
Affiliation
Making connections with others via being emotionally open, empathic, or cooperative.
For example, putting effort into relationships, valuing relationships, intimacy, willing to compromise.
Stereotypically feminine
Cooperation
Associated with gender role flexibility, which involves a coordination of assertion and affiliation.
This is sometimes referred to as androgyny.
Gender Typing
The process of gender socialization and development.
Gender-typed behaviour
Those traditionally associated with a given person’s gender (gender stereotyped).
For example, in our current society, a little girl playing with dolls would be a gender-typed behaviour.
Cross gender-typed behaviour
Those traditionally associated with the gender other than that of a given person
For example, in our current society, a little girl who enjoys racing toy trucks would be an example of cross-gender-typed behaviour.
Sex vs Gender
sex refers to the biological basis of being male, female, or somewhere in between.
In contrast, gender is socially constructed by society. Gender exists on a continuum of masculinity and femininity.
Some researcher study sex and gender together, as a view of the whole person.
Key Biological Theories (gender development)
Evolutionary theory
Neuroscience approaches
What are the theoretical models of gender development?
Biological theories of gender development
Cognitive theories of gender development
Evolutionary Theory
Males and females have different evolutionary purposes. For example, males hunt and compete for mates, whereas females play a crucial role in child-rearing. Many societies today still promote these gender stereotypes.
What is The main issue with evolutionary theory ?
its reliance on circular reasoning. We say things evolved this way because that’s what was needed to survive. How do we know that? Well, that’s because that’s what things are like now (see the circularity).
Biosocial Theory (related to evolutionary theory)
argues that while men and women evolved to have such gender differences, these differences are no longer relevant in today’s society.
For example, men evolved to have greater physical strength than women because this was evolutionarily advantageous. However, having greater physical strength does not promote survival today.
Neuroscience approaches
Neuroscience approaches to gender development consider how hormones impact neurodevelopmental differences. In particular, androgens impact brain development. Most of these impacts occur either prenatally (i.e., when the brain is being built) or during puberty (i.e., when the brain is being re-organized).
Specifically, hormones impact development in two key ways:
-Organizing influences
-Activating influences
Activating influences (neuroscience approaches)
Differences in hormones leading to differences in behaviour. While there are no structural changes, different hormone levels lead to differences in brain function and behaviour.
Organizing influences (neuroscience approaches)
Affect brain organization prenatally and in puberty. That is, there are structural differences in the brain.
Neuroscience approaches have found that women….?
tend to be less lateralized in the brain than men.
For example, men tend to process language mainly in the left hemisphere and spatial stimuli in the right hemisphere. But for women, there would be more activation on both sides when processing this information.
Additionally, women also tend to have larger corpus callosum than men (the bundle of fibres that connects the two hemispheres).
Key Cognitive Theories (gender development)
1) Kolhberg’s Cognitive Developmental Theory
- Gender Schema Theory
- Social Identity Theory
- Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory
Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory (gender dev)
argues that gender-typed behaviours are modeled and reinforced.
This theory argues that children learn about gender through:
- tuition
- Enactive experience
- Observation
Tuition
learning through direct teaching
This is direct teaching about what it means to be a boy or a girl (not what you pay to take this class…). For example, girls may receive explicit instructions from adults about gender-typed behaviours like “girls don’t play contact sports”. Parents might also be the ones to buy gender-typed toys and dress their children in gender-typed clothes.
Enactive Experience
learning to take into account the reactions one’s past behavior has evoked in others
Children evoke reactions from others and tend to be positively reinforced for gender-typed behaviours. For example, boys are more likely to be punished by adults for cross-gender-typed behaviours like wearing makeup or engaging in cross-gender-typed play.
Observations
learning through watching other people and the consequences others experience as a result of their actions
Children learn indirectly from watching others and the media. Indeed, children are more likely to spend time with adults and peers of the same sex, so there are lots of opportunities for vicarious reinforcement. This also means that there are fewer opportunities for children to observe cross-gendered behaviours (e.g., a Dad who cooks and cleans the house). Interestingly, we find that girls are more willing to imitate men than boys are willing to imitate women.
Kolhberg’s cognitive developmental theory
Kolhberg’s cognitive developmental theory is influenced by Piagetian Theory and the idea that children construct their own knowledge about gender. That is, children form gender schemas by observing the world around them.
This theory consists of three stages:
1) Gender Identity
2) Gender Stability
3) Gender Consistency
Gender identity
self-identifying as a boy or a girl (or possibly as both or possibly neither)
Gender identity: by ~30 months old, children can reliably label their own gender.
Gender Constancy
realization that gender is invariant despite superficial changes in a person’s appearance or behavior
Once children understand gender identity, gender stability, gender consistency, they are said to have gender constancy and are able to then understand gender stereotypes.
We know now that this is not true, however, as children hold gender stereotypes long before they achieve gender constancy.
Gender Schema Filter
initial evaluation of information as relevant for one’s own gender
the key idea in gender schema theory is that children attend to information relevant to our own gender, and ignore, misinterpret, or actively reject any inconsistencies. This is known as a gender schema filter.
Gender Consistency
Gender consistency: by ages 5-6, children understand that gender tends to be stable across situations.
For example, they now understand that a male doll wearing a dress is still a boy. I
n other words, children by this age generally understand that gender does not change (as adults we realize gender is a bit more complicated than this, but this is how a 5-year-old generally would understand things).
Gender Stability
awareness that gender remains the same over time
Gender stability: by ages 3-4 years old, child understand that gender tends to be stable across time.
For example, a girl realizes that she will grow up to be a “mommy”. However, this gender stability does not necessarily apply to other people.
For example, if you put a dress on a male doll and ask a 3-year-old if it’s a boy or a girl, they’ll tell you it’s a girl.
Gender Schema Theory
Gender schema theory combines social learning, information-processing, and cognitive approaches.
This theory argues that gender-typed behaviours occur as soon as children can label their own gender
Social Identity Theory
Social identity theory is based on in-group/out-group ideas from social psychology.
Specifically, according to in-group bias, we prefer our own group and conform to group norms (in-group assimilation).
Thus, once children identify with a gender, they tend to prefer that gender group. This means that gender-typed behaviours become stronger over time.
postulated that the high-status group is more valued.
interest filter ( Gender Schema theory)
initial evaluation of information as being personally interesting
For ambiguous stimuli, however, information is processed using an interest filter. So if you don’t know whether something is “for” your gender or not, you approach it based on your interest.
social identity theory postulated that the high-status group is more valued - what does this mean?
male-dominated societies, masculine-associated behaviours like assertiveness tend to be more valued.
-cross-gender-typed behaviours are more common among girls than boys. This is because masculine behaviours are often more valued by society.
- gender-typing pressures are more strict for boys. This is because feminine behaviours are devalued by society.
-When it comes to children, this means that being a “tom-boy” would be much more acceptable for girls than feminine behaviours would be for a boy.
Biological theories tend to focus on
the nature side of things (e.g., role of hormones).
Cognitive theories tend to focus on
how children nurture side of things (e.g., how children learn about gender).
According to Kolhberg, children categorize themselves as either a boy or a girl around
30 months
Statement supporting Bandura’s social cognitive theory of gender
Boys are more likely to be praised by adults when they engage in masculine-typed activities than when they engage in feminine-typed activities
Gender schema theory
Focuses on attention to gender-relevant information
Social Identity Theory
Focuses on in-group/out-group bias
Kolberg’s Cognitive Developmental Theory
How children construct their own knowledge about gender
Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory
How gendered behaviours are modeled and reinforced
Neuroscience approaches
How hormones influence brain development
Evolutionary Theory
Focuses on evolved differences in males and females
Children can distinguish between male and female genders as early as
6-9 months of age.
Infancy and toddlerhood gender milestones
Children can distinguish between male and female genders as early as 6-9 months of age.
Around 24 months old, children have gender expectations, and children can consistently label their own gender by 2.5 years old.
At 12m, both girls and boys tended to look more at the dolls. This is thought to be related to infants’ early preference for human faces.
By 18m, girls demonstrated a preference for dolls, whereas boys demonstrated a preference for vehicles.
At 23m, however, girls were equally likely to look at the doll and the vehicle. Boys, on the other hand, showed a strong preference for looking at the vehicle.
this research highlights that girls’ and boys’ preferences for gender-typed toys emerges early in development (i.e., between 12 and 18 months of age). This result suggests that infants prefer gender-typed toys even before they can reliably label their own gender identity.
Why does gender segregation occur?
One reason gender segregation is thought to occur is differences in preferred types of play. Although stereotypical, boys tend to prefer rough and tumble play whereas girls tend to prefer quieter, cooperative play activities. Over time, as children become more and more segregated, conformity pressures may also play a role.
Childhood gender Milestones
Gender segregation begins in preschool and peaks in middle childhood. This means that boys tend to play with other boys, and girls tend to play with other girls. This is generally universal across cultures.
middle childhood (e.g., ages 9-10) children start to understand that gender is socially constructed.
gender development in transgender children
In contrast to their cisgender (a person whose gender identity matches their sex assigned at birth) peers, transgender children have spent time living as both genders.
gender development is the result of a complex interweaving of nature and nurture factors. By studying transgender children, however, we can aim to better understand these influences.
For example, a transgender boy may have XX chromosomes, female genitalia, been assigned as a girl at birth, and treated like a girl from others. However, this individual may self-identify as a boy and self-socialize as a boy. Gulgoz et al. (2019) attempted to disentangle some of these effects in their research.
transgender children’s gender development
mirrored their cisgender counterparts on every measure
For example, this means that transgender boys self-identified as boys, preferred masculine toys, and preferred to be friends with other boys to the same extent that cisgender boys do (and vice versa for girls).
transgender children showed a clear pattern of gender development associated with
their current gender and not with their sex assigned at birth
key ingredient in gender development
how children self-socialize their own gender.
In other words, neither sex assigned at birth nor indirect gender socialization (e.g., being treated as a girl) seems to impact gender identity. This does not mean that gender socialization does not impact gender development at all–just that it doesn’t seem to impact gender identity as a boy or a girl.
Adolescence Gender Milestones
two main processes unfold related to gender development:
1)Gender-role intensification
2) Gender-role flexibility
Over adolescence, more opposite-sex friendships occur. This corresponds with puberty and the emergence of romantic relationships.
Gender-role intensification
heightened concerns with adhering to traditional gender roles that may occur during adolescence
gender-role intensification involves an intensification of gendered behaviours. For example, girls that were once “tom boys” may become more “girly” and worry more about how they look. This tends to be associated with increased interest in romantic relationships. Given the changing perspectives of gender roles in today’s society, this may not occur to the same extent as it once did
Gender-role flexibility
recognition of gender roles as social conventions and adoption of more flexible attitudes and interests
increasing cognitive development in adolescence also leads to an understanding of gender-role flexibility. Adolescents have the ability to think abstractly and reason about stereotypes, which can encourage a loosening of gender stereotypes.
Children develop an understanding of gender discrimination (and its unfairness) during which developmental stage?
Middle childhood
During adolescence, gender roles become ____________ depending on individual and contextual factors.
Either more rigid or more flexible