Lesson 4 of Retirement Planning: Other Tax-Advantaged Plans Flashcards
IRAs and SEPs!
IRAs, SEPs, SARSEPs, SIMPLEs, and tax-sheltered annuities (403(b) plans) are:
- not qualified plans, and
- are not entitled to the same benefits as qualified plans.
They are referred to as “other tax-advantaged plans” to indicate that:
- while not qualified plans, they have many of the same benefits and features as qualified plans.
Important Numbers 2023
Chart Compares the Characterisitcs of Qualified Plans and Other Tax-Exempt Plans
Exam Question - Tax-Advantaged vs. Qualified Plans
Each of the following are requirements imposed by law on qualified tax-advantaged retirement
plans EXCEPT:
a) Plan documentation
b) Employee vesting
c) Selective employee participation
d) Employee communications
Answer: C
Broad employee participation, as opposed to selective participation, is a requirement of a tax-
advantaged retirement plan. All of the others are requirements for “qualified” plans
Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs)
There are two general types of Individual Retirement Arrangements ((As) under present Law:
- Traditional IRAs, to which both deductible and nondeductible contributions may be made, and
- Roth IRAs: to which only nondeductible contributions may be made.
Traditional IRAs
IRAs 2 forms
Contribution Limit
- Earned Income - Individual IRA
- Earned Income - Spousal IRA
- Earned Income
- Excess Contributions
- Timing of Contributions to IRAs
- Deductibility of IRA Contributions
- No Qualified or Other Retirement Plan
- Active Participants of Qualified or Other Retirement Plans
- Calculation of IRA Deduction - Subject to Phaseout
- Active Participant Status
- Nondeductible IRA Contributions
Saver’s Credit
Distributions from Traditional IRAs
-Required Minimum Distributions
The 10% Penalty and Exceptions from Early Withdrawal’s
2 Forms
IRAs take one of two forms, an IRA account or an IRA annuity.
An IRA account can hold a wide variety of investments and can be held by a wide variety of
custodians (e.g., brokerage, bank, mutual fund, etc.).
An IRA annuity is usually held by an insurance company as custodian.
Contribution Limits
Anyone with earned income can contribute to a traditional IRA, up to applicable limits.
The current annual contribution for individuals under the age of 50 is limited to the lesser of $6,500 or earned income.
Individuals who have attained the age of 50 before the end of the year are also entitled to a catch-up contributions ($1,000 for 2023).
Therefore, the maximum contribution that can be made in 2023 is $7,500 ($6,500 + $1,000 catch-up).
Note that these contribution limits apply to both Traditional and Roth IRAs
Earned Income - Individual IRA
The annual contributions to an IRA are limited to the:
- lesser of an individual’s earned income or
- the annual limit in effect.
Earned income includes:
- any type of compensation where the individual has performed some level of services for an employer or is considered self-employed.
- Earned income also includes
alimony received by the taxpayer.
Note: 2017 TCIA Modification: Alimony subject to a divorce agreement signed after 12/31/
2018 is not income and thus no longer considered earned income.
ALimony are amount paids from spouse, through seperation or divorce.
Earned Income - Spousal IRA
Individuals who do not have any earned income may still be eligible to establish an IRA if their spouse has sufficient earned income.
An IRA for a spouse who has no earned income is generally referred to as a spousal IRA and can be established provided the other spouse has sufficient earned income.
- The necessary level of earned income is equal to the total amount that is to be contributed to both IRAs. Spousal IRAs can be established up to the contribution limit for the year in question (i.e., $6,500 for 2023). The catch-up contribution is also available for those individuals age 50 and over.
Example - Spousal IRA
Joe, age 48, and Holly, age 43, have been married for twenty years and are currently retired
Although Joe is currently unemployed, Holly earns $12,000 from her part-time work at the local shopping market during 2023. Who can contribute to an IRA?
Because Holly has income of $12,000, both Joe and Holly can contribute up to $6,500 to each of their IRAs in the year 2023.
What is Earned Income?
EXAM TIP: Make a flashcard and understand the difference between earned income and unearned income.
W-2 income
Schedule C net income
K-1 income from an LLC
K-1 income from a partnership where the partner is a material participant.
Alimony (If divorce agreement was signed prior to or by 12/31/18. TCJA 2017)
What is NOT Earned Income?
EXAM TIP: Make a flasheard and understand the difference between earned income and unearned income.
Exam Question - Contribution Limit
Andrew, age 53, had the following items of income:
- Investment returns as a limited partner in a partnership of $1,200
- Unemployment compensation of $350.
- Income from a law practice of $600.
- Deferred compensation from a former employer of $14,000, not constructively received this year.
- Alimony of $750 (he was divorced in 2017).
- Wages of $1,000.
- What is the maximum contribution Andrew can make to an IRA for this year?
a) $1,750.
b) $2,350.
c) $6,000.
d) $7,000.
Andrew is limited to making an IRA contribution equal to the lesser of $7,500 (2023) (including
the catch-up) or his earned income for the year. Andrew’s earned income includes his law practice income, alimony, and wages, which total $2,350. Alimony prior to the TCJA will continue
to be considered income for Andrew unless any material modifications to the agreement are
made. Should a material modification be made, the alimony payments will follow the new rules.
Earned Income
SECURE Act 2019 removed the age restriction on contribution to IRAs. If an individual has earned income, they may contribute. Earned income comes from a w-2, 1099SE, or alimony from an agreement dated prior to 2018.
Excess Contribution
Contributions that exceed the limits discussed above are subject to an excise tax of 6%. This penalty is charged each year that the excess contribution remains in the IRA.
Corrective distributions will not be assessed the 10% early withdrawal penalty on any earnings distributed that were associated with the excess amount of the contribution. This waiver became effective with the passage of SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022.
The six year period of limitations on the excise tax begins when the taxpayer files an individual
tax return (Form 1040) for the year of the violation.
Example
In 2023, Ava, age 32, contributed $5,000 to her traditional RIA and $2,000 to her Roth IRA.
She has made an excess contribution of $1,000.
She can avoid the six percent penalty by withdrawing the excess contribution and any related earnings from either the IRA or the Roth IRA account (or both) by the following April 15th.
Timing of Contributions to IRAs
For IRAs, contributions must be made to both traditional and Roth IRA accounts by the due date of the individual federal income tax return without considering extensions.
For most taxpayers, this due date is April 15th of the year following the tax year end.
Finally, the contribution to a traditional IRA or Roth IRA must be made in cash with an
exception for rollover contributions.
No other type of asset may be contributed to an IRA.
Deductibility of IRA Contributions
Deductibility of the traditional IRA contribution for an individual’s federal income tax return
depends on several factors,:
- including coverage or participation in a qualified plan or
- other retirement plan, also known as the “active participant” rule AND the individual’s Adjusted Gross Income (AGI)
No Qualified or Other Retirement Plan
An individual who is not an active participant and whose spouse is not an active participant has no income limitation for purposes of deducting his IRA contributions.
Therefore, his contributions are fuly deductible.
Active Participant of Qualified or Other Retirement Plans
For individuals or married couples filing jointly who are considered active participants (defined below) of a qualified plan or other retirement plan, there is an income test to determine the deductibility of IRA contributions.
If the taxpayer’s AGI is greater than the upper limit of the phaseout ($83,000 in 2023 for Single; $136,000 in 2023 for MFJ), no deduction is permitted. If the taxpayer’s AGI is less than the lower limit of the phaseout ($73,000 in 2023 for Single; $116,000 in 2023 for MFJ), then a full deduction is permitted. If the taxpayer’s AGI is between the limits, then the deduction is ratably phased out.
Married couples filing separately are effectively phased out between an AGI of $0 and
$10,000. Individuals falling within these phaseout ranges must calculate the dedictible amount of the contribution utilizing the calculation discussed below:
Solo spouse participant - One spouse being covered by a qualified plan does not prohibit the
other spouse from deducting a contribution to
a traditional IRA. This ability to deduct the contribution, however, is partially phased out for married individuals with AGI beginning at $218,000 and is completely phased out for AGI at or above $228,000.
Two different phase outs schedules are used in this scenario. The active participant follows the MFJ phase out and the non-active participant spouse will follow the spousal IRA phase out.
calculation of IRA Deduction - Subject to Phaseout
An individual who is an active participant in a retirement plan and has an AGI within the phaseout range will have a reduced maximum deductible IRA contribution.
The deduction limit ($6,500 for 2023) will be reduced based on a proportion equal to the amount by which the individual’s AGI exceeds the lower limit of the phaseout range divided by $10,000 (or $20,000 in the case of a joint return).
The following chart summarizes the deductibility of an IRA contribution:
EXAM TIP
Anyone with earned income can make an IRA contribution. Make sure that You understand the circumstances under which an IRA contribution is deductible.
Likely to see this!
Example 1
Jody is single, age 38, and an active participant in his employer’s qualified retirement plan. His
AGI for 2023 is $80,000, and he makes the maximum contribution to his traditional IRA.
Reduction = [ 6,500 x ( ( 80,000 - 73,000 ) ÷ 10,000 )
= $4,550
Thus, Jody’s traditional IRA deduction for 2023 is reduced by $4,550 to $1,950 ($6,500 -
$4,550).
Example 2
Assume the same facts as above except that Jody is over the age of 50 and is eligible for the catchup contribution of $1,000. In this case, the traditional IRA deduction is reduced by $700.
Reduction = [ 7,500 x ( 80,000 - 73,000 ) ÷ 10,000]
= $5,250
Thus, Jody’s traditional IRA deduction for 2023 is reduced to $2,250 ($7,500 - $5,250). Notice
that the portion that is phased out represents 30 percent of the contribution. Therefore, with the
additional $1,000 contribution, only 70 percent will be deductible (84,550 + $700 = $5,250).
Example 3
Amir, age 32, and Stacy, age 31, are married and are active participants in qualified plans. They file a joint return and have AGI of $120,000 for 2023.
Both Amir and Stacy make the maximum contribution to their respective traditional IRAs in 2023.
Reduction = [ 6,500 x ( 120,000 - 160,000 ) ÷ 20,000 ]
= $1,300
Thus, Amir and Stacy can each deduct $5,200 ($6,500 - $1,300).
Exam Question - Active and Non-Active Participant Spouse
Use the facts for Amir and Stacy, but assume for this question, that Stacy does not participate in
her company 401(k). What are their combined deductible amounts in this case?
a) 0
b) 1,300
c) 7,800
d) 11,700
Answer: D
(Amir) Reduction = [ 6,500 x ( 120,000 - 116,000) ÷ 20,000]
=$1,300
Stacy will not have a reduction on her deduction. She will use the $218,000 - $228,000 phase
Out for a non-active participant of a participant spouse (aka spousal IRA phase out).
Amir’s deduction is reduced by $1,300, so he can deduct $5,200 ($6,500 - 1,300) while Stacy
Can deduct the full contribution of $6,500. In total, of their $13,000 combined contribution, they can deduct $5,200 plus $6,500, which equals $11,700.
Exam Question Deductibility of Contribution
Hamilton, a single 29 year old, deferred 2% of his salary, or $2,000, into a 401(k) plan spon-
sored by his employer during the current year. What is the maximum deductible IRA contribution Hamilton can make during the current year?
a) $0.
b) $1,100
c) $4,000
d) $6,000
Answer: A
Hamilton cannot make a deductible IRA contribution for the year because he is an active participant in a qualified plan with an AGI of at least $100,000 ($2,000 ÷ 2%), which exceeds the single taxpayer phase-out limits for 2023.
Active Participant Status
The deductibility of traditional IRA contributions may be reduced if the taxpayer is an active participant in a retirement plan during the same year. An active participant is an employee who has benefited under one of the following plans through a contribution or an accrued benefit.
- qualified plan
- Annuity Plan
- tax-sheltered annuity (403(b) plan)
- certain government plans
- simplified employee pensions (SEPs)
- simple retirement accounts (SIMPLEs)
Example
Derek is employed by Healthcare Company, which sponsors a profit sharing plan. The plan was established in 2022. Healthcare decides in January of 2023 to make a contribution to the plan for the year 2022. Since Healthcare made the contribution in 2023, Derek would be considered an active participant for the year 2023, not 2022. If a contribution was made for Derek in 2022, however, then Derek would be an active participant for 2022.
Exam Question IRA Contributions
Rex a married 29 ear old, deferred 10% of his salary, or $10.000. into a 401 (k) plan sponsored by his employer this year. His wife was unemployed all year and did not receive unemployment compensation. Assuming Rex has no other income, what is the maximum contribution Rex’s wife can make to her Roth IRA for this year?
a) $0
b) $1,000
c) $4,500
d) $6,500
Answer: D
Rex’s wife can make a $6,500 Roth IRA contribution, the maximum for this year, because Rex’s AGI of $100,000 ($10,000 deferral divided by 10% deferral percentage) is below the phase out limit of $218,000. Even though she does not have any earned income of her own, she can use
Rex’s earnings to qualify for the contribution. The Roth IRA has contribution limitation based
on AGI.
Exam Question IRA Contributions
Darryl, single and age 54, is a participant of his employer’s qualified profit sharing plan. For the
current year he received a forfeiture allocation of $25, but the employer did not make any other
contribution for the vear. Darrvl would like to make a deductible IRA contribution. If Darryl’s
AGl is $90,000 (all comprised of W-2 earnings and portfolio income), what is the maximum
deductible IRA contribution Darryl may make?
a) $0
b) $3,250
c) $6,500
d) $7,500
Answer: A
Because of the forfeiture allocation Darryl received from his employer’s plan, he would be con.sidered an active participant of his employer’s qualified plan. Accordingly, his maximum deductible contribution to the IRA may be limited based upon his AGl. The AGI phaseout for a single active participant in a qualified plan is $73,000 - $83,000 (2023). Since Darryl’s AGI
exceeds the threshold. he cannot make a deductible IRA contribution.
He can make a non-deductible contribution. ensure you double check what the question asks for.
Nondeductible IRA Contributions
Although one of the advantages of an IRA contribution is that they are often income tax deductible for AGI, contributions to an IRA can be nondeductible.
When an individual makes a nondeductible contribution to an IRA, the individual has an adjusted basis in the IRA. Withdrawals from the IRA will consist partially of account earnings that have not been subject to income tax and partially of return of adjusted basis for which the individual has already paid income tax.
Saver’s Credit
The purpose of this nonrefundable credit is to encourage low-income and middle-income taxpayers to establish and maintain savings for retirement.
The amount of the credit is equal to the applicable percentage times the amount of qualified retirement savings contributions (up to $1,000 if single and $2,000 if married filing jointly) made by an eligible individual in the tax year.
Distributions from Traditional IRAs
Generally, distributions from traditional IRAs are taxed as ordinary income.
The one exception is for distributions consisting of a combination of tax-deferred earnings and the return of adiusted basis that results from either nondeductible IRA contributions or rollovers of contributions from qualified plan balances that included after-tax contributions (such as thrift plans).
In such cases, each distribution will consist of a combination of return of Adjusted Basis (AB) and
ordinary income. The ratio of return of AB is equal to the ratio of the total AB of the account before the withdrawal to the fair market value of the total account balance.
Think Income Tax Annuity Rules!!!
Ratio of AB =
AB Before Withdrawl
÷
FMV of account at Withdrawl
Required Minimum Distriibutions
Traditional IRA distributions can be taken at anytime, but the Required Minimum Distribution
(RMD) rules state that the distributions must (except Roth IRAs) begin by April 1st of the year following the year in which the owner attains the age of 72 - for those attaining age 72 before
January 1, 2023 or 73 for those attaining age 72 after December 31, 2022, just like qualified
plans.
Required distributions that are not taken are subject to a 25 percent exercisw tax! SECURE 2.0
Act of 2022 reduced this penalty to 25 percent and further reduces the penalty to 10% if a
corrective distabution is made during the correction window
The 10% Penalty and Exceptions for Early Withdrawals
The government encourages taxpayers to leave funds in their traditional and Roth IRAs until
retirement by imposing a 10% premature withdrawal penalty for distributions prior to age
59½.
Therefore, traditional and Roth IRA distributions before the age of 59½ will be subject to the 10% penalty unless a specific exception applies.
Certain exceptions from the 10% penalty apply only for withdrawals from IRAs (not qualified plans) including withdrawals for higher education expenses. For acquisition costs of a first home (up to $10,000), and for health insurance premiums for the unemployed.
The following chart summarizes the exceptions to the 10 percent withdrawal penalty.
EXAM TIP: Know the Following Chart
- Where there is a distribution at divorce and the payee is under 59 1/2, the use of a QDRO directed distribution will result in a taxable event, but will not incur the 10% early withdrawal penalty. Under the same circumstances except that the distribution is from an IRA, the result is both a taxable event and the application of the 10% early withdrawal penalty. However, the payee in any case can choose to rollover the distribution in which case the rollover rules would
apply or the payee can take substantially equal periodic payments under section 72(t).
IRA Annuity vs IRA Accounts
An individual retirement annuity is different than a traditional IRA account because it is an annuity contract or endowment contract issued by an insurance company. An IRA annuity, however, must meet certain similar requirements regarding transterability, nontortetability, premiums, and distributions.
Transferability and Nonforfeitability:
- An IRA annuity is not transferable by the owner and the benefits must not be forfeitable.
- The proceeds from an IRA annuity must be received by the owner or by a beneficiary of the
contract. Similar to traditional IRAs, these IRA annuities cannot be pledged as collateral nor can
loans be taken from the contract.
Premiums:
- The annual premiums for an IRA annuity may not exceed $6,500 for 2023.
- In the event that premium payments cease, the owner must be given the right to receive a paid up annuity and the owner of the annuity must also be allowed to forgo payment of the annuity
premum.
Distribution:
- The distribution rules for IRA annuities, including the required minimum distribution rules, are the
same as for traditional IRAs.
Roth IRAs
Although the contributions to a Roth IRA are not deductible, qualified distributions from Roth IRA
accounts consist solely of nontaxable income.
Additionally, Roth IRAs may be funded at any age with earned income, and are not subject to the
required minimum distribution rules during the owner’s life.
Roth IRAs and traditional IRAs share many of the same features and characteristics
Taxpayers can fund Roth IRAs by either making cash contributions or by converting traditional IRAs into Roth IRAs.
Exam Tip:
Make sure you know the difference between traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs.
Chart Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA
Contributions
Both Roth IRAs and traditional IRAs share an annual single contribution limit and use the same
definition for earned income; however, taxpayers may only contribute to a Roth IRA if they fall within the prescribed income limits without regard to active participant status. The following chart specifies the income limits for Roth IRA conributions for 2023.
The following chart specifies the income limits for Roth IRA conributions for 2023.
Roth 401 (k)
For years beginning after 2005, a 401(k) plan may include a Roth contribution program in which employees are able to make after-tax contributions to a Roth account.
Exam Question - Roth IRA Contributions
Sam, age 54 and single, has compensation this year of $85,000. His employer does not sponsor a qualified plan, so Sam would like to contribute to a Roth IRA. What is Sam’s maximum contribution for this year to the Roth IRA?
a) $0
b) $6,500.
c) $7,500.
d) $30,000.
Answer: C
The maximum Roth IRA contribution is $6,500 plus $1,000 (2023) for those individuals 50 and
over. Sam can make a $7,500 contribution to his Roth IRA. Sam is not phased-out (Single Roth
IRA phase-out for 2023 is $138,000 - $153,000).
Conversions
An individual may convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, with the expectation that distributions
are completely tax free. At the time of the conversion, however, the taxpayer must include the value of the conversion amount in their taxable income.
For 2010 forward, a traditional IRA may be converted to a Roth IRA regardless of AGI.
Recharacterized Contributions
IRA owners may recharacterize certain contributions made to one type of IRA as made to a different type of IRA for a taxable year by the due date of the return plus extensions.
As a result of 2017 TCJA, recharacterization cannot be used to unwind a Roth conversion. However, recharacterization is still permitted with respect to other contributions
Distributions
A distribution from a Roth IA is not included in the owner’s gross income if it is a “qualified distribution.”
Qualified distributions from Roths are not subject to the 10 percent penalty.
Qualified Distributions - VERY IMPORTANT
A qualified distribution is a distribution from a Roth IRA that satisfies BOTH of the following tests:
1) The distribution must be made after a five-taxable-year period (which begins January 1st of the taxable year for which the first regular contribution is made to any Roth IRA of the individual or, if earlier, January 1st of the taxable year in which the first conversion contribution is made to any Roth IRA of the individual),
2) The distribution satisfies one of the following four requirements:
- Made on or after the date on which the owner attains the age 59½;
- Made to a beneficiary or estate of the owner on or after the date of the owner’s death;
- Is attributable to the owner being disabled; or
- For first-time home purchase (lifetime cap of $10,000 for first-time homebuyers includes
taxpayer, spouse, child, or grandchild who has not owned a house for at least 2 years).
The five-taxable-year period is not redetermined when the owner of a Roth IRA dies. Thus, the
beneficiary of the Roth IRA would only have to wait until the end of the original five-taxable-year
period for the distribution to be a qualified distribution.
Example 1 - ROTH IRA Distributions
On July 5, 2023, Edward established a Roth IRA for year 2023 with a $1,200 contribution. Since
this was his first contribution to a Roth IRA, his five-year period begins on January 1, 2023
Example 2 - ROTH IRA Distributions
On February 16, 2023, Gabrielle made an initial contribution of $900 to a Roth IRA. She made
the contribution for the 2022 tax year (recall that a taxpayer can make contributions until April
15 of the following year to a traditional or Roth IRA for the prior tax year). Gabrielle’s five-year
period begins on January 1, 2022 even though she made her initial contribution in 2023 because
the contribution was for the 2022 tax year.
Exam Question ROTH IRA Distributions
At the age of 57, Julian converted his traditional IRA, valued at $45,000, to a Roth IRA. At age
60, Julian took a distribution from this Roth IRA of $100,000 to buy a new car for his daughter
for college. Which of the following statements is true with regards to the distribution from the
Roth IRA?
a) $100,000 will be subjected to ordinary income tax.
b) $55,000 will be subjected to ordinary income tax.
c) $55,000 will not be subjected to ordinary income tax or penalty.
d) $55 000 will be subjected to ordinary income tax and penalty.
Answer: B
For a distribution from a Roth IRA to be a qualitied distribution, the distribution must be on
account of death, disability, the owner attaining the age of 59½, or the first-time purchase of a
home. AND the distribution must occur live years after the account was created. In this case
since the Roth was not created five or more years betore the distribution. the distribution will be
taxable to the extent it represents earnings in the account, $$5,000. Since the distribution was
taken after Julian attained 59½, it will not be subjected to the 10% penalty,
Exam Question ROTH IRA Distributions
What is the first year in which a single taxpayer, age 58 in 20x1, could receive a qualified distribution from a Roth IRA, if he made a $4,000 contribution to the Roth IRA on April 1, 20x2, for
the tax year 20x1?
a) 20x3
b) 20x4
c) 20x5
d) 20x6.
Answer: D
A qualified distribution can only occur after a five-year period has occurred and is made on or
after the date on which the owner attains age 59½, made to a beneficiary or the estate of the
owner on or after the date of the owner’s death, attributable to the owner’s being disabled, or for
a first-time home purchase. The five-year period begins at the beginning of the taxable year of
the initial contribution to a Roth IRA. The five-year period ends on the last day of the individual’s fifth consecutive taxable year beginning with the taxable year described in the preceding
sentence. Therefore, the first year in which a qualified distribution could occur is 20x6.
Nonqualified Distributions
Any amount distributed from an individual’s Roth IRA that is not a qualified distribution is treated as made in the following order (determined as of the end of a taxable year and exhausting each category before moving to the following category).
- FIRST from regular contributions (i.e.. the $6,500 for 2023 annual contributions).
- NEXT from conversion contributions on a first-in-first-out (FIFO) basis,and
- FINALLY from earnings
10% Early Withdrawal Penalty
The 10% early withdrawal penalty will generally apply to any portion of a distribution from a
Roth IRA that is includable in gross income (such as distributions that consist of earnings within
the Roth IRA).
The penalty also applies to a non-qualified distribution, even if it is not includable in gross income to the extent it is allocable to a conversion contribution if the distribution is made within the five-taxable-year period beginning with the first day of the individual’s taxable year in which the conversion contribution was made.
It is important to note that although a non-qualified distribution may be subiect to the 10%
penalty based on the Roth IRA rules, the penalty may be avoided if the distribution falls within one of the exceptions to the early 10% early withdrawal penalty.
The following table summarizes the treatment from the standpoint of taxation and penalties of
distributions from a Roth IRA to the extent the distribution is not a qualified distribution.
The following flow chart outlines the process for determining the taxability of an ROTH IRA distribution.