Lecture Flashcards
Durkheim Book #1
Concerned with changin nature of social solidarity
- nature of crime and punishments vary depending on solidarity
- primitive societies = very punitive
- moderate societies = rehab based
- examines mechanic and organic solidarity
Durheim book #3
unspoked debate with marx concerned with abnormal social solidarity 3 conditions of solidarity 1. anomic 2. forced division of labour 3. ...
Conceptual template
organizing ideas we struggle with
- contrasts mostly aren’t resolvable
Major issues in theory
nominalism vs. realism
facts vs. value judgements
objectivity vs. subjectivity
conservitive vs. radical
6 contrasts in sociology
- organicism vs atomism
- nature vs. nurture
- reactors vs. actors
- realist vs. nominalist
- facts and/or values
- conservative vs. radical
Explain organicism
- everything is a system
- institution is structure which serves purpose of society
- we are all players of roles inside a functioning system
- personal details irrelevant
- all interdependent on eachother recognizing other roles
- system falls apart if we deviate
- doesn’t consider criticisms, activism is deviance
- conservative
explain atomism
- exactly the same as organicism with one addition
- it is possible for a person to step outside the institution to critique it
- comes along with moral judgements
organicism vs. atomism
- on criticism of the system
-organicism believes critiques are deviants
= systems are naturally homogenous, theorists must protect system
believe in human nature - atomists believe you can step outside and be critical of the system
- believe in nurture
explain relationship between culture, society and the individual
- reactors - we are simply sponges conditioned by social world around us
- organicism - actors - humans are sometimes capable of making up our own minds, articulating unexpected demands of the system
- atomistm
what are the 2 analytical epistemologies in soc?
realism vs nommanalism
explain realism
- explain social events and processes with reference to ‘natural’ forces
- don’t explain in reference to human intentions
explain nomminalism
- social processes occure because of the intention of the individual
- we must develop methodologies to ask why i do what i do, realists don’t ask questions
- nomminalism gives agency to objects of study
what are descruptive/ analyticial explanations?
- if you are a you do B
- straight forward definitions not accounting for hybridity
explain prescriptive/ evaluative logic
- any judgement theorists make about ‘preserving’ social order
- that there are things we ‘ought’ to do to preserve it is a prescriptive/ evaluative statement for realism
prescriptive nominalist statement
- social order should be maintained OR changed in order to foster needs of humans
what are facts
- anything that is indisputably the case is one definition
- to say something is face assumes everone agrees, what happens when you can imagine disagreement
- when there isn’t universal agreement there is bias
-when there is universal agreement there is objectivity
-objectivity isn’t a matter of fact, it is a way of expressig intersubjective agreement
= can’t be forced or coerced