Global Governance: Environmental Flashcards
How is climate change a unique collective action problem?
Every state contributes in some way to its causes, is affected by it and can have an impact on solving it, big or small.
What are the three things states need to work together on climate change?
- A framework to agree the existence and extent of climate change (The Paris Agreement (2015)) and independent scientific evidence (IPCC)
- Forums to debate and agree upon possible solutions (COP)
- International laws and treaties to keep other states accountable and taking action
What % of the scientific community agree that climate change is a problem and what % agree it is due to human activity?
A problem: 100%
Human activity: 97%
Since when have scientists noted the negative effects of climate change?
In the 80’s, it was established that the rapid increase in greenhouse gases (as musch as 35%), due to growing CO2 and methane emissions, are increasing the global temperature.
What are three harmful effects of climate change on people?
- Many coastal regions will face rising sea levels and exacerbated coastal flooding, pushing them out of their homes and many into poverty; The World Bank: the Maldives could be underwater by 2100
- States will begin to wage resource wars for things like water which the UN finds is made more scarce due to droughts
- Increased natural disasters such as floods and droughts can afect food security, such as Typhoon Haiyan in 2013 Phillipines
What is the Global Commons? Giev each of them.
The spaces which no state lays claim to and all are resposible for the upkeep of.
- The high seas
- The atmosphere
- The polar regions
- Outer space
Give two ways that the ‘high seas’ have been affected by climate change.
- Pollution and littering: oil spills and chemical pollution like the 2010 BP oil spill affected 176,000km of the ocean
- Fauna: a 1.5C temperature rise could make waters uninhabitable for 60% of fish by 2100
Give two ways that the atmosphere has been affected by climate change.
- Pollution: 3.5 million a year die from air pollution (1.85 being Chinese)
- Natural disasters: the number of climate related natural disasters has tripled in the last 30 years, IPCC also says they’re getting worse
Give two ways that the polar regions have been affected by climate change.
- Melting: Antarctica is losing about 136bn tonness of ice a year, the polar ices sheets having lost 7.6tn tonnes of ice
- Resource wars: states are increasingly attempting to lay claim to them as a source of oil (13 of udiscovered reserves), Russian explorers planting a flag on the sea bed in 2007
Give one way that outer space has been affected by climate change.
- Pollution: NASA estimates that therre are up to 500,000 pices of human-generated space debris orbiting Earth.
Give an international law protecting each of the Global Commons.
- The High Seas Treaty (2023) aims to place 30% of the sea under protection by 2030
- Kyoto Protocol set legally binding emissions targets for states
- the Antarctica Treaty protects Antarctica from resource extraction
- The Outer Space Treaty protected it from ‘harmful contamination’
What is the Tragedy of the Commons?
Hardin argues that the Global Commons are doomed to be exploited as states’ interests and teh interests of the environment rarely align, such as the cost of becoming sustainable or the strategic loss of weaker economic power.
Why might there not be a Tragedy of the Commons?
What is harmful on an international level is harmful on a national level: deaths from air pollution and increasing worries about drought and famine are what led China and India respectively to join the Paris Agreement.
What is sustainable development?
The alternative to ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, arguing that economic growth can and should be achieved without harming the environment and putting the needs of future generations at risk.
How do the Sustainable Development Goals support states?
- Science: The UN provides funding and training for climate change research within states, along with that of the IPCC
- Costs: The UN brings together different groups like businesses and developing states to help ease the transition to sustainability
- Data: The UN advises states on how to use census data to find the impacts and potential risks of climate change
What is weak sustainability?
The belief that sustainable development is for thepurpose of ensuring the next generations have the same resources as us; as such, economic and human capital are interchangeable, such as the economic gain of a new airport outweighing the environmental cost.
What is strong sustainability?
Favoured by radical ecologists, environmental costs are seen as outweighing economic gain as human capital is a blight on nature rather than equal. They believe that the environment is something borrowed that should be passed from one generation to the next.
What is ecologism?
A political ideology that places emphasis on the effect of states’ and other actors’ effects on the environment, believing that its protection is a moral duty.
What is deep ecology?
Naess argues that the environment should be protected for the sake of the environment itself, regardless of the effect on humans, rejecting the notion of states’ interests. Very rooted in spiritualism.
What is shallow ecology?
Weston argues that we should protect the environment so that we can continue to benefit from it, such as the efficent usage of natural resources to savour them. More rooted in pragmatism.
What is the realist view of tackling climate change?
- Realists favour weak sustainability, believing that economic position of a state must not be lost in favour of environmental gain
- Tragedy of Global Commons due to national interest
- Agrement on Shallow ecology
What is the liberal view of tackling climate change?
- Climate change is a collective action problem that requires global governance and cooperation to be solved
- Belief in sustainable development due to human reason
- Agreement on shallow ecology
What are the two main issues surrounding eonvironmental global governance?
- The dynamic between developing and developed states
- Climate scepticism
What are the four main grievances of developed states about climate action?
- Developed states industrialised and developed with little care for the environmental impact, but now expect developing states to
- Environmental restrictions go against the low regulation doctrine that developed states preach
- Industrialisation is a good way to reduce poverty
- Historic emissions come from developed states