geography_20240525133748 Flashcards
Geographical concept of place has which 3 aspects?
Location, Locale, Sense of Place
Location
where a place is on a map, its latitude or longitude coordinates
Locale
each place is made up of a series of locales or settings where everyday life activities take place, such as an office, a park, a home or a church. These settings affect social interactions and help forge values, attitudes and behaviour- we behave in a particular way in these places, according to social rules we understand. o Geographers agree that a locale need not be tied to a particular physical location , so a vehicle or an internet chat room may be a locale that structures interactions between people
John Agnew 1987 quote on locale
‘locale means not just the mere address but where of social life and environmental transformations’
Sense of Place
this refers to the subjective and emotional attachment people have to a place. This may be completely different when looked at from another’s perspective
Glastonbury example (e.g. could use for a 4 marker)
location: country of somerset, 23 miles south of Bristol, dry point on the low-lying somerset levels
locale: home to a number of visitors attractions including Glastonbury Abbey and Glastonbury Tor- young Christ visited
o the national trust describes Glastonbury Tor as being ‘a spiritual magnet for centuries, for both Pagans and Christians’
sense of place: a place of great spiritual importance for people interested in paganism, religious or the King Arthur link
o Others: Glastonbury evokes emotions about the internationally famous music festival about the internationally famous music festival which takes place at Worthy farm in Pilton on the edge of Glastonbury
o First festival took place in June 1970, it was attend by 1500 people and cost £1 with free milk from the farm
Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz quote
‘There’s no place like home, there’s no place like home…’
Yi-Fu Tuan’s approach to place
- The depth of attachment we have for a place is influenced by the depth of our knowledge and understanding of it (attachment increases with age and with our physical ability to explore the world )
- our attraction to a place is influenced by the quality and intensity of the experience we have there
- the more enjoyable , the safe we feel, the more we feel attached to it
Topophilia
A strong attachment to a place
Yi Fu Tuan 1974 quote
‘the human love of a place… diffuse as a concept, vivid, concrete as personal experience’
Topophobia
a dread or adverse reaction to a place
Ted Relph 1976
To be human is to live in a world that is filled with significant places’
Descriptive approach
This is the idea that the world is a set of places and each place can be studied and is distinct
A social constructionist approach
sees place as a product of a particular set of social processes occurring at a particular time.
For example, Trafalgar Square was built to commemorate a British naval victory in the 1800s and, using a social constructionist approach, could be understood as a place of empire and colonialism.
A phenomenological approach (Yi-Fu Tuan and Ted Relph)
interested in how an individual person experiences place, recognising a highly personal relationship between place and person
Ralph approach
Ralph argues that the degree of attachment, involvement and concern that a person or group has for a particular place is critical in our understanding of place.
Doreen Massey approach (Sense of place)
Places are dynamic, with multiple identities and no boundaries. They are constantly changed and moulded by the outside influences of the wider world.
E.g. The result of lived experience in a nation e.g. little Chalfont
Cultural approach - Jon Anderson
Places are given meaning by the traces that exist in them- physical traces such as
● Material traces are physical additions to the environment and include things such as buildings, signs and statues.
● Non-material traces include events, performances or emotions which occur in that place.
e.g. Glastonbury is given meaning by the Glastonbury music festival.
Example of concept of place/ changing places
Trafalgar Square, the traces are the statue of Lord Nelson and a large public square.- behind them social constructionists - commemorate Nelson’s naval victory - commemoration of British leadership and victory - can be understood as a space of Empire- a place of pride and patriotism. Today the square is still used to celebrate victory - e.g. Olympics. 4th plinth used to change place meanings - innovation and diversity. Also used for protests
Protests related to place
In London, from 2018 onwards, climate change activists, led by Extinction Rebellion, held peaceful protests centred around Parliament Square.
-the activists used the power of place to attract attention and lodge their message in people’s memories
Example of changing place- 9/11 memorial , NY
-All places are changing, but few have gone through such dramatic changes in the last 15 years as Ground Zero, the site of the former world trade centre in NY
-Different views on memorial – some say is beautiful , others its cold, stark and uncomfortable
Person-Place relationship
people define themselves through a sense of place and by living in place and carrying our a range of everyday practice there
Lived experience has 3 aspects.
-Identity, Belonging, Well-being
Identity at different scale
Localism, Regionalism, Nationalism, Globalism. A person may think of their indentity as layers, that derive from distinct aspect of their family history, upbringing and experience