FLK Wills Flashcards
What is the order of priority for entitlement to grant for simple letters of administration?
NCPR s22
a) Surviving spouse or civil partner,
b) Children of the deceased or their issue if they are dead,
c) Deceased’s parents,
d) Deceased’s siblings of whole blood, or their issue if they are dead,
e) Deceased’s siblings of half blood, or their issue if they are dead,
f) Deceased’s grandparents,
g) Deceased’s uncle and aunts of whole blood, or their issue if they are dead,
h) Deceased’s uncle and aunts of half blood, or their issue if they are dead,
I) Treasury solicitor (if Crown is claiming under bon vacantia),
j) Creditor of the deceased.
What is the order of priority for an application for grant of letters of administration with will annexed?
a) Executor, or
b) Trustee of the residuary estate, or
c) Any other residuary beneficiary under the will or anyone entitled to a share of the residue under the intestacy rules or if none,
d) The PRs of the residuary beneficiary (in c) but not the life tenant of the residue, or if none,
e) Any other beneficiary or creditor, of if none,
f) Any PRs of the beneficiary or creditor (in e)
What is the order of priority for intestacy if both spouse and issue are deceased?
a) Issue on statutory trusts, but if none,
b) Parents, equally if both alive, but if none,
c) Brothers and sisters of whole blood on the statutory trusts, but if none,
d) Brothers and sisters of half blood on the statutory trusts, but if none,
e) Grandparents, equally if more than one, but if none,
f) Uncles and aunts of whole blood on the statutory trusts, but if none,
g) Uncles and aunts of half blood on the statutory trusts, but if none,
h) The Crown (bon vacantia)
What business property qualifies for 100% relief?
A business or an interest in a business (including a partnership share) and company shares that are not listed on a recognised stock exchange i.e. private company.
AND
The assets must have been owned by the transferor for a period of two years.
What business property qualifies for 50% relief?
a. Company shares listed on a recognised stock exchange where the testator had voting control immediately before death and
b. Land, buildings, machinery or plant owned by the transferor personally but used for building purposes (by a partnership of which the transferor is a member or a company whether quoted or unquoted of which the transfer has voting control).
Voting control means ability to exercise over 50% of votes in all resolutions. Voting control can be met by considering the combined shareholding of the spouse and the deceased. If it is over 50% then their combined share has voting control.
AND
The assets must have been owned by the transferor for a period of two years.
What is a citation?
A citation is a method of forcing a party with a right to the grant to act.
Can an IPFDA claim be made against someone who is domiciled outside of England and Wales?
No
What is the deadline for making an IPFDA claim?
6 months from issue of the grant
If there is a cause of action against the deceased, do the PRs take on the cause of action? If so, what is the limitation period?
Yes because PRs take on all of the debts and liabilities of the deceased.
PRs must also perform the deceased’s contracts.
They will only be liable to the extent of the deceased’s assets.
The limitation period is six years.
What is the time limit for a proprietary or a personal claim against a PR who has distributed assets to someone who is not entitled to them?
12 years for both
Who can make applications to the court to remove or replace PRs?
The PR themselves or the beneficiaries.
However, the court must ensure that there is at least one PR left.
The main consideration for the court is the welfare for beneficiaries.
What are the defences to claim of devastivit?
- The court has discretion to totally or partially relieve a a PR of personal liability if they acted honestly and reasonably and ought fairly to be excused for devastivit and for omitting to obtain the directions of the court in the matter.
- Exclusion clause in the will.
- Acquiescence of beneficiaries. If an adult beneficiary who has full knowledge of the facts has consented to the PRs breach, they cannot succeed in a claim against the PR.
- PR will be protected from claims from unknown beneficiaries if they placed advertisements and followed procedures for advertising (s27).
- PRs will be protected from claims from missing beneficiaries if they have a Benjamin order, insurance or indemnity.
- But s27 does not protect from IPFDA provisions so should wait 6 months to take out the grant.
- Limitation. The time limit for an unpaid or underpaid beneficiary to bring a claim is 12 years running from the date on which the right to receive the estate accrued. There is no time limit for fraudulent breaches or where PR has taken property from estate for their own use.
What is the consequence if the PRs are found to have breached their fiduciary duty?
The transaction is voidable by the beneficiaries within a reasonable time. They must account to the estate for any unauthorised profit (whether or not the estate has actually suffered any loss).
Can profits that would ordinary be a breach of fiduciary duty be authorised and by whom?
Wills
- Profits may be authorised by a provision in the deceased’s will,
- A court order or
- The consent of all the beneficiaries who must be aged 18 or over.
What is the deadline for executors and administrators to distribute the estate?
Executors and administrators have a year from the end of the month of death the distribute the estate. If the year passes, the beneficiaries can call upon them to distribute.
Who can bring administration proceedings?
Administration proceedings can be brought by anyone interested in the estate including beneficiaries, creditors and PRs.
What are the two categories of administration proceedings?
Wills
a) Applications limited to a particular issue
This application may be non-contentious e.g. just need from court guidance.
b) Applications of a general administration order
Under this order, the court supervises the PRs. The PRs cannot act until the court has given permission.
This is a last resort and the court will not decide to do this lightly.
An alternative would be for the court to appoint a judicial trustee to act as PR with another person or alone.
Do beneficiaries have an equitable interest in the estate before distribution?
Beneficiaries of an unadministered estate do not have an equitable interest in the deceased’s property until the PRs transfer or assent the property to them. The PRs have both the legal and equitable interest. This differs from trusts.
The beneficiaries do have a right to compel due administration even if they do not have an equitable interest.
Do beneficiaries have a right to demand inspection of accounts?
Beneficiaries have a right to demand inspection of accounts (records of receipts and payments kept by PRs throughout the administration). If the PRs refuse to comply, the beneficiaries can apply for a court order.
Do beneficiaries have a right to demand disclosure of reasons for PR decisions and deliberations on a discretionary matter?
There is no automatic entitlement to disclosure of reasons for PR decisions and deliberations on a discretionary matter. However, if they refuse, beneficiaries can apply to court.
What is a citation to take probate?
This may be applicable where an executor has lost their right to renounce probate by intermeddling in the estate but has not applied for grant of probate and will not do so.
Once they have been cited, they have to take out the grant.
If they do not take out the grant without good reason, the citor can apply to court to get the executor to be passed over. If there is no other executor, the grant to take out would then be a grant of letters of administration with with will annexed.
What is a citation to propound a will?
This is used where it becomes apparent that there may be a will but administration has already been carried out under another will or intestacy.
In order for beneficiaries to protect their entitlements from being diminished, they can cite the executors in the later will and any interested persons under the will.
If the citees fail to act on it or enter an appearance, the citor can apply to the court for an order for a grant as if the will were invalid.
What is a citation to accept or refuse a grant?
This is the standard method of clearing off a person with prior right to a type of grant who has not applied and shows no intention of applying for a grant.
If the person cited does not take steps to take out the grant, the grant may be issued to the citor.
What is the best option if the PR is incompetent or unwilling?
Compelling a person to take an grant could cause more issues if they are incompetent and unwilling.
Another option is to apply for a court order to pass them over in favour for someone else. E.g. an executor has intermeddle but will not do anything.