Evidence (Blurting) - Democracy and Participation Flashcards
1.1 Referendum
The most recent referendum in the UK was the Brexit referendum in 2016, where 33 million UK citizens voted on whether to remain a member of the EU or leave, 51.89% voted to leave. 72% turnout
1.1 Party membership figures
309,000 are members of the Labour party - 2025 February
131,680 members of the conservative party - 2024 November.
1.1 Recall of MPs
The Recall of MPs Act has been used 6 times since its enshrinement into law in 2015, most recently in October 2023, where the MP for Wellingborough, Peter Bone, was given a suspension for bullying and sexual misconduct against a member of staff. This was successful, with 13% of constituents signing the petition. (10% needed for success)
1.1 petitions
In April 2024, MPs debated a petition on assisted dying, after accruing more than 203,000 signatures on the government e-petition website. UPDATE: 29th November 2024, euthanasia bill has been passed - implying that petitions are effective.
1.1 Switzerland
Switzerland, a country which uses direct democracy often - giving around 10 referendum style votes a year is considered the 8th most democratic state globally, whereas the UK is 17th [Source: World Population Review 2024]
Yet Switzerland’s voter turnout for both referendum style votes and Parliamentary elections are both averaging under 50% compared to the UK at 67% in 2019 (UPDATE: in 2024 the turnout was 60%) - shows voter apathy if used too much
In Switzerland,where initiatives are used regularly minority rights have been damaged.
1.1 Turnout
The Scottish Referendum 2014 = 84.6% turnouot Yes - 44.70% No - 55.30%
the 2016 EU referendum saw 72% - both higher than general Elections which sit around 65%.
The Belfast/Good Friday agreement turnout = 81%, ended the conflict in Northern Ireland
Voter turnout between 1945 & 97 = 76% on average 2000 onwards 64%
1.1 changes in seats in elections
Within the 2019 election, safe seats which had been held by Labour politicians for decades were turned into Conservative MP holding seats, such as in Redcar, a seat that had never before voted in a
Conservative, picked the Tory MP over Labour’s Anna Turley by 3,527 votes.
Seat of Bolsover, Labour since its creation in 1950 and held by Labour’s Dennis Skinner since 1970 was taken by the Tories in 2019.
In the 2024 general election, safe seats which had been held by Conservatives politicians were taken by mostly the Labour candidates, e.g. Finchley & Golders Green, Chipping Barnet (constituencies previously represented by Margaret Thatcher), North East Somerset and Hanham (constituency previously represented by Jacob Rees-Mogg). The seat of South West Norfolk is gained by Labour candidate Terry Jermy, defeating Liz Truss who previously held the seat by 630 votes.
1.1 direct vs representative democracy and referendums
Direct democracy is beneficial for political engagement.
Scottish independence ref, 3\4 of scots got involved in at least one activity related to it, campaigning + use of social media.
Brexit ref, there were around 38 million online interactions related to it from march 2016 - june 2016.
Rep. Dem. is better as representatives are educated, the day of EU referendum, the most searched question was “What is the EU?”
1.2 differences in turnout
Voter turnout has been decreasing overall since WW2
Turnout is even lower in ‘second order’ elections for bodies like the Police and Crime Commissioner, 15% in 2012.
2016 Local Elections = 34% average.
2024 London mayoral elections = 40.5%
2024 general election = 60% turnout, which has dropped 7.9% compared to the 2019 general election, which questions the legitimacy of the mandate and the newly formed Labour government.
In 2024 the winning party Labour was elected with 33.7%. In the 1950s = over 80% turnout, now they are just in the mid-high 60s.
2001 = 59%, lowest voter turnout since the end of WW1
Now it is still hovering around 68%, 10% lower than that of 1997.
% of the popular vote, meaning 66.3% of voters voted against the governing party. This calls into question the legitimacy of the government.
1.2 party membership changes
In 2022, Labour lost 25,000 members, putting it 125,000 down from the 2019 election which was at 500,000. Currently, in 2024 it has 366,604 members
BSA 2019: 60% were ‘very’ or ‘fairly’ satisfied with UK Democracy
Reform UK sit at 5000 members (March 2024) - 182 000+ members (January 2025) -
In the 1990s, membership of the conservative party was at an estimated 400,000
2016 it was under 150,000, showing a significant drop in party membership- participation crisis. Currently around 131,000.
In 2024, (January-March) The Labour Party suffered a sharp fall of 23,000 members following controversies over its policies on Gaza and its U-turn on green investment.
1.2 fall in young voters
Voting within the age range of 18-24 between 1992 and 2015 has fallen by more than 50%.
1.2 online engagement
There is significant engagement with politicians online with Jeremy Corbyn having 2.4 million followers on Twitter and Nigel Farage having 1.6 million – despite both being out of frontline politics.
1.2 Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022
The 2024 general election is the first election called under the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, which replaces Fixed Term Parliament Act 2010. This gives the ultimate power for the Prime Minister to call an election at a time they prefer, instead of setting regular terms (5 years).
1.2 Palestine
The Palestinian crisis has become a large source of direct action and protest within the past year, with protests in London had 400,000 marchers.
vBUY +are elected as MPs, including MP Jeremy Corbyn who previously has been forced to stand as an independent candidate by the Labour Party due to antisemitic statements made. Notably, issue voting on the Gaza crisis increases the vote share of independent candidates who openly support Palestinians and work for Palestinians.
1.2 Reform UK
In the 2024 general election, Nigel Farage has eventually elected as an MP in Clacton-on-sea after 8 attempts running in elections.
5 Reform UK candidates including Richard Tice and Lee Anderson are elected. However, the aggregate votes in Reform UK ranked the third place in this election (4.1 million votes), which leads to questions on the proportional representation by comparing with votes gain and seats gain.
1.2 Rwanda scheme
The Supreme Court and the House of Lords have both tried to interfere with the Rwanda Plan, with the Court holding that the government’s scheme to send asylum seekers to Rwanda as unlawful.
The House of Lords passed five amendments to the bill in March 2024 which started another round of parliamentary ping-pong.
1.2 changes to voting system
Changes to the voting system have been rejected - major House of Lords reform was rejected in 2012 *by the coalition government, and in 2011 the public voted against AV.
Arguably, what Biden has done as well. Him pardoning his son.. as a father no but in terms of politics, is classified as democratic deficit.
1.3 Acts that have made changes to the franchise
1832 Great Reform Act: The Act disenfranchised 56 boroughs in England and Wales and reduced another 31 to only one MP. It also created 67 new constituencies, broadened the property qualification (so including smaller landowners) and gave the vote to householders who paid a yearly rental of £10 or more.
1867 Representation of the People Act (Second Reform Act): this gave the vote to working class men for the first time.
1918 Representation of the People Act: following pressure from the Suffragettes, and the success of working women during World War One, the right to vote was granted to women over the age of 30 who met a property qualification, and all men over the age of 21.
1928 Representation of the People Act (Equal Franchise Act): this granted, for the first time, equal voting rights to women and men. As a result, both men and women could vote at the age of 21.
1969 Representation of the People Act: this extended the franchise to men and women over the age of 18.
1.3 Enfranchising 16 and 17 year olds
The Electoral Commission reported that there was a turnout of 75% amongst 16-17 year-olds in the Scottish Independence Referendum, with 97% of those who voted saying they would vote again in the future. This is extremely high, compared to 54% of 18-24 year olds and 72% of 25-34 year olds.
The Isle of Man enfranchised 16 and 17-year-olds in 2006. In every election since then, voter turnout among this age group has decreased – 55% in 2006 to 46% in 2021
1.3 online voting
Research by Survation found that two thirds of non-voters in 2010 would have been significantly ‘more likely’ to vote had there been an online voting option
Estonia is a country which has adapted to the online voting system, where almost 1/4 of all votes cast in the 2011 election were made online. It uses biometric ID cards and verification servers to stop voter fraud.
The Brazilian Electoral Tribunal has allowed no testing of the country’s electronic voting system since 2012, when a research team uncovered several vulnerable holes in the system having been granted brief access to millions of lines of code.
1.3 petitions
Change.org: currently 570,000 signatures for e-petition about the compensation for post office scandal
In 2017 around 1.86 million signatures were collected to stop president trump having a state visit – this worked and he came on business rather than a state visit
Sometimes they can lack formality highlighted by the Haaland petition where around 2 million signatures wanted him to leave Man city.
1.3 prisoner voting
YouGov (2015) found that 8% of the public believed all prisoners should be able to vote
1.3 compulsory voting
Compulsory voting is a measure currently in force in 15 democracies worldwide, including the comparable European and Commonwealth countries of Belgium and Australia.
1.3 voting as a duty
Polling shows that over 70% of the British public agree with the fundamental proposition that voting is a duty, with fewer than 20% dissenting. (2023)