ENFORCEMENT & CONTEMPT Flashcards
Can a party be held in contempt for nonpayment of debt not involving support
NO
Can court hold party in contempt for failure to pay spouse pension payments
No - pension is an asset, not support.
Does the court have contempt power to compel compliance to perform acts besides payment of money?
Yes, 12.570 - to force signature of title, deed or transfer documents such as mortgage
WHEN THE ACT AT ISSUE DOES NOT INVOLVE PAYMENT OF MONEY, TRIAL COURT MAY ENFORCE PROPERTY DIVISION THROUGH CONTEMPT
Can court issue writ of bodily arrest for future noncompliance with alimony
NO - cannot issue civil contempt for incarceration based on future anticipated noncompliance with court’s periodic support order
Identify the types of obligations to be enforced
- Parenting Issues
- Equitable distribution: non payment of debt, property division or perform an act
- Alimony
- Child support
- Attorney’s Fees
What are the 4 different types of contempt
- Direct Civil Contempt
- Indirect Civil Contempt
- Direct Criminal Contempt
- Indirect Criminal Contempt
What can habeas corpus be used for in enforcement
To require a party to appear before court to enforce PP
What is proper venue for habeas corpus
Only in the county in which child is detained or withheld
What is the definition of contempt
A refusal to obey any legal order or mandate give by a Judge relative to any business of the court, after due notice, contempt can be punished accordingly.
It is an act tending to embarrass, hinder or obstruct the court in the administration of justice or less its authority or dignity.
What is DIRECT contempt
It is a contemptuous act that is committed in the immediate presence of the court
What is INDIRECT contempt
An act committed outside the presence of court
What is the difference in seeking civil contempt v. criminal contempt
Civil contempt is REMEDIAL
Criminal contempt is PUNITIVE
When is criminal contempt appropriate
It involves conduct that is calculated to embarrass, hinder or obstruct the administration of justice and is used to vindicate authority of the court and PUNISH offending party
When is civil contempt appropraite
It is used to coerce an offending party into complying with a court order rather than pushing them for failure to comply
How do we determine if contempt proceedings are civil or criminal
It goes to the nature of the alleged contemptuous act and is NOT dependent on the nature of the cause from which the contempt citation arose
If a fine imposed is not related to any damage suffered by aggrieved party, what type of contempt is it
criminal - it’s punitive
What is necessary for a valid civil contempt action
Contempt order must include a purge provision - without it, there is danger that the contempt sanction could be transformed from a civil to criminal contempt sanction without having followed underlying procedural protections attendant to criminal proceedings
What must potential criminal contemnors be entitled to
Same constitutional due process protections
What are the 6 elements for direct criminal contempt
- SHOW CAUSE
- SIGN ORDER & PRONOUNCE IN OPEN COURT
- CONDUCT IN PRESENCE OF COURT
- GIVE OPPORTUNITY FOR EVIDENCE TO MITIGATE
- SUMMARY OF PUNISHMENT
- WRITTEN JUDGMENT OF GUILT W RECITAL IF FACT
What is the burden of proof for direct criminal contempt
BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT
When must court appoint counsel for direct or indirect criminal contempt proceeding?
When the offense is punishable by incarceration but it is NOT required if the imposition of incarceration DOES NOT EXCEED 6 MONTHS
Court doesn’t have to give you the right to counsel in a direct or indirect criminal contempt action unless the incarceration is for a period of 6 months of more
Will failure to return to court without court ordered documents, subject you to direct criminal contempt
It could be constituted as direct criminal contempt and be punished summarily accordingly
Can telling Judge to fuck himself in elevator subject you to direct criminal contempt
No - bc it did not happen in court and interrupt or hinder judicial proceedings.
On the way to court room kid kicks door and tells bailiff to go fuck himself but judge hears it, can court hold in direct criminal contempt
Yes bc here it was in presence of judge and conduct lessened court’s authority or dignity