Education Flashcards
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Language
- cultural deprivation=when children lack cultural equipment needed to do well at school so they underachieve
- ways in which parents communicate with children affects cognitive development and ability to benefit from schooling
- Hubbs-Tait- when parents use challenging language to make children evaluate their understanding, cognitive performance improves
- less educated parents use simple descriptive statements that result in lowered performance
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Language- Speech Codes
- Bernstein
- Restricted code
W/C
Limited vocab and simple sentences
Context-bound - Elaborate code
M/C
Wider vocab and complex sentences
Context-free - elaborate code used by teachers so gives M/C pupils advantages
- Bernstein- W/C pupils fail not because culturally deprived but because schools fail to teach elaborate code
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Parents education
- Douglas- W/C parents place less value on education=less ambitious for children=lower achievement
- Feinstein- M/C parents better educated=advantage in socialisation
- educated parents parenting style=discipline and high expectations
- educated parents more aware what is needed to assist educational progress
- educated parents spend income to promote children’s educational success
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Working-Class Subculture
- large sections of W/C have differing goals and attitudes from rest of society so children fail at school
- Sugarman- W/C subculture features that barrier to achievement:
fatalism / collectivism / immediate gratification / present-time orientation - compensatory education- tackle cultural deprivation by extra resources to schools in deprived areas
Operation head start in US- Sesame Street to transmit values
Education action zones / Sure start - myth of cultural deprivation
Keddie- victim-blaming- disadvantaged by education system
Troyna+Williams- not child’s language but schools attitude towards it
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Material Deprivation- Housing
- Material deprivation=poverty and lack of material necessities to achieve in education
- Overcrowding=direct effect as don’t have space to study
Development impaired through lack of space- moving schools as temporary accommodation - Overcrowding=indirect effects as greater risk of accidents and ill health- more absences
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Material Deprivation- Diet and Health
- Howard=poorer homes lead to lower energy and immune systems=more absences from school and difficulty concentrating in class
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Material Deprivation- Financial Support and Costs of Education
- Have to do without equipment and miss out on experiences that would enhance educational achievement
Tanner=transport / uniform / books - Cheaper equipment/hand-me-downs=stigmatisation and bullying
Flaherty=20% eligible for FSM don’t take up on it - Smith+Noble=cannot afford tutoring / private schooling
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Material Deprivation- Fear of Debt
- Callender+Jackson= W/C students more debt averse- more costs then benefits going to uni and over 5x less likely apply than M/C students
- Increased tuition fees will deter even more
- W/C students receive less financial support from families when at uni
- Reay=W/C more likely local unis so can live at home and save costs
- Dropout rates highest for unis with large proportion poor students
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Capital
- Bourdieu=combines cultural and material explanations- M/C more successful as possess more capital
- Cultural capital=knowledge, attitudes, values, skills etc of M/C
- More likely understand what education system requires for success and develop intellectual ideas=advantage in school as transmits M/C culture
- W/C children lack cultural capital=exam failure
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Capital- Educational and Economic Capital
- Economic capital=wealth that M/C families own
- Educational capital=greater economic and cultural capital can obtain educational capital=qualifications
Allows M/C jobs and more economic capital=reproducing advantages from generation to generation
Class Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Capital- Test of Bourdieu’s Ideas
- Sullivan=questionnaires to assess students cultural capital- reading / TV viewing habits / art galleries and museums / vocab and knowledge of cultural figures
- Complex fiction and serious TV documentaries=greater cultural capital
Children of graduates - Cultural capital only accounts for part of class difference
Greater resources and aspirations of M/C=remainder class gap in achievement
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Labelling
- Label=meanings/definitions attach to someone/something to make sense of them
- Becker= judged according to ideal pupil=M/C as W/C were badly behaved
- Hempel-Jorgensen=W/C primary school- ideal pupil is quiet, passive and obedient
=M/C primary school- ideal pupil personality and academic ability - Dunne+Gazeley=normalised underachievement of W/C but felt could overcome underachievement of M/C
- Rist=fast learners were tigers- M/C- received greater encouragement
=slow learners were cardinals and clowns- W/C- seated far away and fewer chance to show ability
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Self-Fulfilling Prophecy
- Self-fulfilling prophecy=prediction that comes true simply because it has been made
- Create SFP through labels attach to pupils as internalises label and becomes it
- Rosenthal+Jacobson=picked 20% pupils at random and labelled as spurters
Almost half of pupils a year later=significant progress
Conveyed label to pupils through interactions - What people believe to be true will have real effects
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Streaming
- Streaming=separating children into same class for all subjects
SFP more likely occur here
W/C=lower streams=SFP of underachievement - Lacey=streaming as differentiation=separating sheep from goats and educating differently
- Gillborn+Youdell=A-to-C economy=schools focus time, effort and resources pupils have potential to get grade C’s so can boost league table position
- Gillborn+Youdell=educational triage=separating students into pass, potential and fail- those on C/D borderline allocated most resources
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupil Subcultures
- Pupil subculture=group pupil who share similar values and behaviour patterns
- Lacey
Differentiation=categorising pupils according to how perceive ability, attitude, behaviour
Polarisation=pupils respond to streaming by moving towards one of two extremes (pro-school/anti-school)
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupil Subcultures- Pro-school and Anti-school Subcultures
- Pro-school
High streams- M/C- remain committed to values of school
Gain status through academic success
Values=those of the school - Anti-school
Low streams- W/C- loss is self-esteem as school undermined them
Gain status through inverting schools values - Woods- response to labelling/streaming
Ingratiation=teachers pet
Ritualism=going through motions and staying out of trouble
Retreatism=daydreaming and mucking about
Rebellion=outright rejection of everything school stands for
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupil Subcultures- Criticisms
- Useful in showing schools are not fair institutions
- Deterministic=if you are labelled you have no choice but to fulfil prophecy
- Marxists=ignore wider structures of power within which labelling takes place
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupils’ Class Identities and The School- Habitus
- Archer=interaction between W/C pupils’ identities and school=underachievement
- Habitus=learned, taken-for-granted ways of thinking, being and acting that are shared by a particular social class
- M/C=power to define its habitus as superior and impose it on education system so school holds M/C values
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupils’ Class Identities and The School- Symbolic Capital and Symbolic Violence
- Symbolic capital=status and recognition
Schools=M/C habitus so M/C tastes and preferences=more symbolic capital - Symbolic violence=denying of symbolic capital
W/C tastes and lifestyles as inferior=reproduces class structure and keeps in their place
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupils’ Class Identities and The School- Nike Identities
- Symbolic violence=alternative class identities and gain symbolic capital through consuming branded goods
=conflict with schools M/C habitus - Nike identities=W/C pupils’ rejection of higher education as unrealistic and undesirable
Wouldn’t fit in as for richer, posher, cleverer people
Wouldn’t suit their preferred lifestyles/habitus
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupils’ Class Identities and The School- W/C Identity and Educational Success / Class Identity and Self Exclusion
- Ingram=fitting in was problem for W/C grammar boys- tension between neighbourhoods habitus and M/C school habitus
Worthless at school for wearing street clothes but worthless in community for not wearing any - Evans=successful W/C girls face hidden barriers- identity would not fit with habitus of elite unis
Strong attachment to families and would stay home to study
Class Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupils’ Class Identities and The School- Relationship Between Internal and External Factors
- W/C habitus and identities outside school conflict with schools M/C habitus
- W/C restricted code=labelling and SFP
- Poverty=bullying and stigmatisation=truanting and failure
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Evidence
- Black and Pakistani pupils=worst
- Chinese and Indians=best
- White pupils close to national average but because form vast majority of school population
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Intellectual and Linguistic Skills
- Cultural deprivation=underachievement of ethnic groups due to inadequate socialisation in the home
- Low income black families lack intellectual stimulation=fail to develop reasoning and problem-solving skills
- Bereiter+Englemann=language of poorer black American families=ungrammatical and disjointed=cannot express abstract ideas which is a major barrier to educational progress
- Children who do not speak English at home=held back educationally
Mirza=Indian do well even though English not home language
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Attitudes, Values and Family Structure
- Lack of motivation as not socialised into mainstream culture=ambition and competitiveness
- Black Caribbean=fatalistic and immediate gratification
- Moynihan=matrifocal black family=lack of male role model for achievement
- Sewell=lack fatherly nurturing=boys underachieving
Street gangs=alternative perverse loyalty/love
Greatest barrier to success=peer pressure - Sewell=Chinese and Indian=supportive families with Asian work ethic as high value on education
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- White W/C Pupils
- White W/C pupils underachieve=lower aspirations due to culture of lack parental support
- Lupton=poorer behaviour in white W/C schools=lower parental support and negative attitudes of parents toward education
- Evans=street culture in white W/C areas=brutal and brought into school=strong pressure to reject education
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Compensatory Education
- Compensatory education=educational policy to counter effects of cultural deprivation
- Operation Head Start=compensate children for cultural deficit said to suffer because of deprived backgrounds
- Sure Start=support development of pre-school children in deprived areas
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Cultural Deprivation- Criticisms
- Driver=ignores positive effects of ethnicity on achievement- matrifocal family=positive female role model
- Keddie=victim blaming- culturally different not deprived- underachieve due to ethnocentric schools
- Ball=EM disadvantage as don’t know how negotiate education system=cultural exclusion
- Compensatory education imposes white M/C culture on EM groups
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Material Deprivation
- Material deprivation=lack of physical/economic resources to achieve in education
- Palmer=1/2 EM children=low income households / EM 2x likely be unemployed
- More at risk of material derivation due to living in economically depressed areas with high unemployment and low wage rates
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- External- Racism in Wider Society
- Material deprivation=product of racism in wider society
- Members of EM groups=direct and indirect discrimination at work and in housing market=low pay and unemployment which affects children
- Racial discrimination leads to social exclusion which worsens poverty faced by EM
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Labelling and Teacher Racism
- Interactionists=different labels teachers attach to EM children
Black=disruptive
Asian=passive - Gillborn+Mirza=black were highest achievers but when GCSE’s had fallen below average=schooling not background to blame
- Gillborn+Youdell=racialised expectations of black pupils and behaviour was threatening
=high levels of exclusion of black boys
=black pupils in lower sets or streams - Wright=teachers assumed Asians poor English so left out of class discussions / mispronounced names
Connolly=Asian boys more feminine, vulnerable and less able to protect themselves
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupil Identities
- Archer:
Ideal pupil identity=white / M/C / masculine / achieved status
Pathologised pupil identity=Asian / feminine / over-achiever
Demonised pupil identity=black or white / W/C / under-achiever de - Chinese=praised and viewed negatively by teachers- achieved status in wrong way- never ideal pupil=negative positive stereotype
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Pupil Responses and Subcultures
- Fuller=high achieving black girls in year 11=rejected negative stereotypes and channeled anger of labelling into pursuit of educational success
- Mirza=teacher racism
Colour blind=all equal but racism unchallenged
Liberal chauvinists=black culturally deprived so low expectations
Overt racists=blacks inferior and discriminate against
Black girls avoided teachers to avoid their racism - Sewell
Conformists=largest / successful and accepted schools values
Innovators=second largest / pro-education but anti-school
Retreatists=minority / disconnected from school and black subcultures outside
Rebels=small but visible / rejected school and conformed to black macho lad
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Labelling, Identities and Responses- Pupil Responses and Subcultures- Evaluation
- Shows how teacher stereotypes cause of failure
- Stereotypes perceived as product of teachers’ prejudices and not racism of education system as a whole
- Deterministic=once labelled will succumb to a SFP and fail educationally
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Institutional Racism- Critical Race Theory
- Institutional racism=discrimination built into way institutions operate
- Critical race theory=racism is an ingrained feature of society
- Roithmayr=institutional racism is a locked-in inequality=discrimination so large that no longer conscious intent to discriminate- feeds on itself
- Gillborn=ethnic inequality so deep rooted that practically inevitable feature of education system
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Institutional Racism- Marketisation and Segregation
- Gillborn=marketisation means more scope to select pupils=negative stereotypes influence decisions about admissions
- Moore+Davenport=selection procedures=ethnic segregation with EM pupils failing to get into good secondary schools due to discrimination
- Commission for Racial Equality=racist bias in school interviews / report stereotype minority pupils / lack of info in minority languages
Ethnic Differences In Achievement- Internal- Institutional Racism- Ethnocentric Curriculum
- Ethnocentric curriculum=reflects culture of one ethnic group- usually dominant culture
- Troyna+Williams=priority to white culture and English language
- David=specifically British curriculum that teaches culture of host community
- Ball=history is mythical age of empire and past glories while ignoring history of black and Asian people
- EM groups=culture and identity not valued in education so worsens self esteem=negative educational achievement