Consciousness Flashcards
working definition for consciousness
awake vs sleep
consciousness is the fundamental basis of mind and behaviour.
If we understand consciousness then:
We might know how to fix it when it goes wrong
How to monitor it e.g. during general anaesthesia
Maybe answer fundamental questions like: what is the nature of reality
Basically if we understand consciousness then we understand the brain
Understand how the pain of stubbing, texture of stone etc. is formed by the brain
Astonishing hypothesis
who you are etc. are no more than the collective activity of nerve cells. Your mind is what the brain does and that’s who you are. (Monism)
The scientific consensus is that dualism is wrong
There is no you, separate from your body and brain
The mind is what the brain does
Rene Descartes
What can be doubted/ what was he sure of
I believe there is a god
I believe I have friends
I believe I have family
The whole thing might just be an illusion
How to be sure tho
‘I think therefore I am’
Dualism
Descartes supports the idea that bodies and minds are different
Movies in which characters wake up in a different body
Majority of people on the earth believe that when their bodies die, they won’t
E.g. if we cut off a finger, doesn’t effect who we are
Problem with Dualism
It is unscientific: we want to know about mental phenomena
Dualists say it is all just out there, part of the aether
Descartes- physical objects can not do certain things like play chess.
- But now computers can play chess
- So if machines can do complex things then maybe we are like complex machines (brains)
You and your brain
If you chop off your hand, it doesn’t really change your consciousness. You can still have conscious experiences of an arm
Brain activity corresponds to your thoughts
- Or your thoughts correspond to your brain activity
What you do with your body can change your mind
- Drinking coffee and brain damage can change your behaviour
Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)
- Put you in this scanner
- Can tell if you are thinking about music, playing tennis or solving a moral dilemma
- Physical patterns going on in your brain can predict what youre conscious of
- Your thoughts have a specific physical associations in the brain and every time you have that pattern, you have that thought
- We can even make you see something that’s not there by stimulating your brain
Having a particular pattern of activity in your particular brain is simply what it feels like to be you
So could a phone become conscious? You have no way of knowing except through its behaviour
Modern day Free will experiments
Person lies in a fMRI scanner and sees string of letters on screen. Then decide whether to press left or right button, remembering which letter you saw.
Looking at their brain, we can predict what button they were going to press 6 secs before they did it
Evidence that information for a decision exists in the brain before we feel like we have made a decision
So does that mean we don’t have free will? OR our brain activity is ‘us’ deciding (Monism)
Are we our brain then?
Analogy of TV set:
It has content
It can be damaged or distorted
Can stimulate certain parts and see something on screen
But does this mean the TV creates the TV shows
Qualia (from latin)
Words used in philosophy and now science to describe qualitative feeling of an experience
E.g. redness of red AND wetness of water
It is impossible to compare your quale and mine
You can never experience what I am experiencing
Some people don’t realise they are colour blind
Why have qualia?
The most efficient way of processing information?
A lot of what goes on in our brains bypasses consciousness
Reflex action to a bug on foot
Bodies react to fearful sights e.g. spider or gun
High level things like decision making and creativity often happens outside of awareness
Things we are not aware of can effect our behaviour
Awareness and action e.g. a room with moving walls
Brain injuries e.g. blindsight
Many ‘zombie’ agents in the brain (without consciousness: autopilot
So why do we need consciousness if we have ‘zombie’ agents? WE DUNNO YET
Problem of 3rd party consciousness
I can never be sure that you are conscious
AND you can never be sure that I am conscious
E.g. the colour green (dunno how others perceive green)
Motion induced blindness LOOK AT LECS
Illusion of blinking green light and 3 yellow lights
There are enabling factors (what our body needs to get to consciousness)
Do u need a blood supply, do u need a oxygen to be conscious? Dunno
Do you need toes and fingers to be conscious of your toes and fingers? No
Search for the NCC (neural correlates of consciousness)
Look for the neural patterns etc. that correlates with being conscious
Does not mean the neural activity is causing consciousness but correlates with it?
- Just bc there is correlation doesn’t mean causation
Visual parts of the brain
The back half of the brain is dedicated to vision- vision is very reliant on the brain.
So a lot of research first starts off in vision before moving off to other senses.
Eyes
Light comes in through the lens and hits the retina at the back which starts a cascade of neuron activity
Do we need eyes to be conscious? Not rlly
Eyes are not crucial to having a visual conscious experience
Damage to the brain
Phineas Gage Frontal lobe damage (a bar went through his frontal lobe of brain)
- He was still conscious and could read and write
- But he couldn’t plan, memory was wonky, but he was fully conscious of everything
- More damage on personality and functioning NOT consciousness
- This is the firsts step in discovering which parts of brain is doing what
Primary visual cortex, visual area one (V1):
What happens if V1 is damaged?
- Can’t see some things
- Lose ability to see half of things
Patients asked to point to the light source even if they could not see it
- They can point to the yellow dot even thought they’re not conscious of it.
Blind sight:
the ability to respond to visual stimuli without consciously perceiving them, a condition which can occur after certain types of brain damage
E.g. put a shape in their blind side and ask them to describe how they feel. They will use words that describes the shape.
So even without V1, some information can still get through
- Does this mean that V1 is not the site for NCC?
Damage to higher level areas
Visual neglect
Motion blindness area MT
Akinestpsia (inability to perceive motion)
Color blindness from damage to the cortex
NCC for motion
- Even without higher level visual areas we still perceive, but the experience is incomplete
- BUT without motion area (MT) we can’t perceive motion
- Does that mean MT is the NCC?
Where motion is processed in the brain
Stimulating MT causes motion perception
TMS (transcranial magnetic stimulation)
So there is strong evidence that MT processes motion