clinical practice Flashcards
why are mental health services needed?
- reduction of suffering
–> lessening distress
–> improved quality of life, meaning and purposeful activity
–> limit risks to the individual and other people - social benefits
–> foster a more diverse, inclusive and fairer society
–> lower risk to self and others - economic costs and benefits
mental health sats and facts
- 1 in 6 experience common mental health difficulties (i.e. broadly depression or anxiety)
- 1 in 5 experience suicidal thoughts over their lifetime
- number of people with mental health problems is increasing
economic benefits of providing care
- output effects
–> employment - savings to the NHS
–> reduced costs per person, including physical and mental health services
–> reduced referrals to secondary sector, fewer inpatient admissions, fewer GP consultations and less medication
–> estimated £300 over two year period - savings to the exchequer
–> increased employment (reduction in benefits and increased tax receipts)
–> savings in NHS costs
economic costs of mental health
- mental health problems cost around £105 billion per year in England
–> providing services, lost work, reduced quality of life
–> costing over £2000 per person per year in England - only about 1/3 of people with a mental health disorder get help for it
key questions regarding economic cost
- should we put more resources into services to provide help for more people?
- does paying more to treat people actually have to cost more?
economic costs of mental health in England
health care costs for:
- all problems = around £100 billion per year
- people with mental health problems = £13 billion
–> anxiety and depression = £3.75 billion
–> children and adolescents with mental health problems = £0.75 billion (750 million)
- medically unexplained symptoms = £3 billion
proportion of funding to mental health
- of all health research funding, only 5% goes to mental health
–> large chunk goes to Dementia research
cost-benefit trade off: an example
- initiative was set up based on the cost-benefit trade off
–> Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) - mean resource cost for course of treatment = £750
- financial planners and commissioners of services want to know - do the benefits outweigh the cost?
- if they don’t, what other interventions or resources that might be offered?
cost analysis for IAPT
- what are the benefits of treatment?
- across all patients (whether they recover or not)
–> treating someone reduces their mean benefit costs by one month = £750
–> employment level goes up by 18%
–> absence from work goes down by 31 days/year
–> economic output per person rises by £1100/month
–> where present, costs of comorbid physical conditions go down by several thousand pounds
cost-benefit trade off: early intervention in psychosis
- around 1% of the population will develop psychosis require longer term care
- Early Intervention in Psychosis (EIP) services seek to reduce the amount of time between the onset ofsymptoms and when people receive help
- aims to reduce the impact of symptoms on:
–> their ability work, foster relationships
–> engagement in education
non-EIP vs EIP patients
- compared to patients receiving non-EIP services, patients receiving EIP services were:
–> 116% more likely to gain employment
–> 52% more likely to become accommodated in a mainstream house
–> 17% more likely to have an improvement in the emotional well-being domain of the HONOS questionnaire
cost analysis for EIP
- the key cost differences associated with EIP were:
–> lower mental health inpatient costs (£4,075)
–> lower acute hospital outpatient costs (£59)
–> lower accident and emergency costs (£31)
–> higher mental health community costs (£648) - overall using significantly less (costly) health services had a saving associated with EIP of £4,031
overview of mental heath services
- mental health services provide life saving care
- people benefit from reduced distress / increases quality of life
- research also shows how mental health services reduce costs that would otherwise happen (e.g. increased unemployment, acute care, housing, police involvement)
- this approach can be controversial and has been criticised
basic outline of the NHS
- across lifespan
- acute to longer term care
- for physical and mental health
- provides information and evidence of practices
general practice
- around 90% of NHS patient interaction is with primary care services:
–> GPs
–> dentists
–> community pharmacy services - around 30% of people who make an appointment with a GP do so for help with psychological distress
GPs can refer patients to…
- child and adolescent mental health services (CAMHS)
–> NHS services that assesses and treat young people with emotional, behavioural or mental health difficulties to age 18
–> most CAMHS services work with the whole family to support a young person’s health - Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT)
–> IAPT services provide evidence based treatments for people with anxiety and depression, predominantly stepped care relying on CBT principles
–> IAPT also accept direct referrals
GPs refer patients to… (continued)
- Early intervention in Psychosis (EIP)
–> integrated service for people 14 – 65 presenting with a first episode of psychosis
–> multi disiplinary team structure (doctors, nurses, social workers etc) - Community Mental Health Team (CMHT) & Assessment and Brief Treatment (ABT)
–> many areas have services that provide an initial assessment for signposting to other services - Older Adult Mental Health Team (OAMHT)
–> work families and adults 65+ who are in mental health crisis
types of longer term care
- Community Recovery Teams (CRTs)
–> supporting people 18 – 65 with long term needs - High support / Integrated care teams
–> provide support to people over 18 who have a long term condition (mental or physical health) who live at home or in nursing care - rehabilitation services
–> for people who’ve undergone a recent change in functioning
–> e.g. as a result of acquired brain injury or illness - Community Learning Difficulties Services (CLDS)
specialist services
- Eating Disorder Services (EDS)
- Early Intervention in Psychosis Services (EIP)
- Personality Disorder Services
- Therapeutic Communities / Crisis Houses
acute care for physical and mental health
- Accident and Emergency (A&E)
–> treat patients with acute health problems
–> loss of consciousness
–> acute confused state
–> fits that are not stopping
–> persistent severe chest pain
–> breathing difficulties
–> severe bleeding that cannot be stopped
–> severe allergic reactions
–> severe burns or scalds - Mental Health Liaison (MHL)
–> work in acute general hospital settings and assess people for referral to mental health teams
services for mental health crisis:
- Inpatient mental health care provided in all areas of the country. - This is provided where:
–> there’s need to be admitted for a short period for further assessment
–> there’s a risk to safety if they don’t stay in hospital, for example, if the person is severelyself-harmingor at risk of acting onsuicidal thoughts
–> there is a risk they could harm someone else
–> there isn’t a safe way to treat them at home
–> need more intensive support than can be given to them elsewhere
Home Treatment Teams (HTT)
- inpatient services are supplemented by Home Treatment Teams (HTT)
–> for adults aged 16-65 whose mental health crisis is so severe that they would otherwise have been admitted to a hospital - these are sometimes called Crisis Resolution and Home Treatment (CRHT) teams
4 tiers to child and adolescent services
- tier 1
–> generalist workers (GP, school nurse etc..)
–> low level psychotherapeutic interventions
–> e.g. recommending self-hep - tier 2
–> general workers (GP, school nurse etc…)
–> low-level specific interventions
–> e.g. counsellors, bereavement workers - tier 3
–> mental health team workers
–> high level psychotherapeutic interventions
–> e.g. CBT for relatively moderate to severe cases - tier 4
– highly intensive or specialist services
–> psychological therapy is highly specialised
–> or is only part of a wider package of care
–> e.g., in-patient units
–> e.g. specialist eating disorders services
making complaints / patient involvement
- The Patient Advice and Liaison Service (PALS)
–> offers confidential advice, support and information on health-related matters
–> they provide a point of contact for patients, their families and their carers - healthwatch England
–> the national consumer champion for people who use health and social care services
–> Its purpose is to ensure that the voices of people who use services are listened and responded to - Integrated Care Boards (ICBs)
–> commission most of the hospital and community NHS services in the local areas for which they are responsible
–> many local ICBs have public engagement and involvement activities that you can participate in
types of recovery orientated care
- clinical recovery
- personal recovery
clinical recovery
an idea that has emerged from the expertise of mental health professionals, and involves getting rid of symptoms, restoring social functioning, and in other ways ‘getting back to normal’
personal recovery
- a deeply personal, unique process of changing one’s attitudes, values, feelings, goals, skills, and/or roles
- it is a way of living a satisfying, hopeful, and contributing life even within the limitations caused by illness
- recovery involves the development of new meaning and purpose in one’s life as one grows beyond the catastrophic effects of mental illness
traditional approach to treatment
- basic concepts:
–> psychopathology
–> diagnosis
–> treatment
–> staff and patients - working practices:
–> description
–> focus on disorder
–> illness based
–> goal = brining under control
recovery approach
- basic concepts:
–> distressing experience
–> personal meaning
–> growth and discovery
–> experts by training and by experiences - working practices
–> understanding
–> focus on person
–> strengths based
–> goal = self control
‘recovery in the bin’ perspective
- do not like the use of ‘recovery’ to control and discipline those trying to find a place in the world and trying to deal with the very real mental distress they encounter on a daily basis
- want to place mental health within the context of social justice and the wider class struggle
first mental health professionals approached
- many people initially approach their General practitioner (GP) for help with their mental health
–> a GP can offer help themselves or refer onto more specialist services - trained therapists and counsellors provide a range of different therapies through NHS services or privately
secondary mental health professionals
- people who are acutely distressed might go directly to hospital either by attending A&E or via the police
- here they will receive help from multidisciplinary mental health teams including:
–> psychiatrists
–> clinical psychologists
–> nurses
–> social workers
–> occupational therapists - mental health teams also work in community settings
members of the multidisciplinary team:
- psychiatrist
- mental health nurse
- social worker
- occupational therapist
- clinical psychologist
role of a psychiatrist
- qualified medial doctor
- provide assessment, care management (including medication and physical treatment)
- consultant psychiatrist can recommend detention for treatment under the Mental Health Act
role of a mental health nurse
- registerednursewith specialist training in the area ofmental health
- they provide a wide range of support from helping with day-to-day life, facilitating medication, assessing risk and counselling
role of a social worker
specialise in helping people with mental health problems to overcome practical difficulties and access services
role of an occupational therapist
- aims to help people overcome any practical difficulties as a result of mental health problems
- this might involve the learning of specific skills or techniques, including creative activities and day-to-day living skills
- promoting agency
define a therapist
- anyone who provides a therapy or talking treatment
- may be a psychologist or psychiatrist, nurse, social worker if part of their role and involves providing therapy
- some require additional training
types of talking therapy practitioners
- Counsellor:
–> offers counselling (a talking treatment that aims to help people find ways of coping with problems that they are experiencing) - Psychotherapist:
–> are trained using therapeutic model CBT, Psychoanalysis, Family, Gestalt and many others
–> there are accredited training programmes for most approaches - Clinical and Counselling Psychologists
–> their training includes carrying out the therapist role trained in similar approaches to psychotherapists and usually more than one
what are protected titles?
- Professions have designated titles that are protected by law and professionals
- must be registered to use them
- membership of a specific professional body & registered with them
- examples:
–> dietician
–> art therapist
–> hearing aid dispenser
how does someone become a psychotherapist?
- ‘psychotherapist’ and ‘counsellor’ are not protected titles
–> in UK and many other countries - take an approved course that provides the necessary eligibility for registration with a professional body
–> e.g. HCPC; BABCP; BPS; BACP - require a basis in understanding psychology
–> e.g. cannot get onto a clinical psychology course if you do not have Graduate Basis for Registration with the BPS
how do you stay a psychotherapist?
- continue professional development:
–> regular updates in training, teaching, reading, conference attendance
–> in some cases, passing tests and/or maintaining portfolios - maintaining standards:
–> not getting struck off for inappropriate or unprofessional behaviour
types of professional roles
- Assistant Psychologist
- Associate Psychologist
- Counselling Psychologist
- Clinical Psychologist
assistant psychologist
- posts advertised through NHS jobs
- usually work under the supervision of clinical psychologists
- could be doing assessment work or brief interventions
- often seen as a step to clinical psychology, but is NOT a requirement
clinical associate psychologist
- new role:
-> undertake circumscribed psychological assessments and interventions for specific populations and/or using specific therapies under supervision of a clinical psychologist - training:
–> Graduate psychologist on NHS Band 5, Band 6 once qualified - MSc apprenticeship
counselling psychology
- Graduate Basis for Chartered (GBC) membership with the British Psychological Society (BPS)
- relevant work with people with emotional demands
- basic counselling skills training
- doctoral training on an accredited course or BPS Qualification in Counselling Psychology
- HCPC registration
- Self funding
clinical psychologists
- Clinical psychologists work with people with mental or physical health problems
- aim to reduce psychological distress
nd enhance and promote psychological well- being - use of research and psychological theory and data
- they work with people throughout the life-span and with those with learning disabilities
clinical psychology as a profession
- work in range of health and social care settings
–> e.g. hospitals, health centres, social services, individually or in teams - most work in the NHS but some can work in teaching and training and in private sector work
- work can centre around:
–> anxiety and depression
–> serious and enduring mental illness
–> adjustment to physical illness
–> neurological disorders
–> addictive behaviours
–> childhood behaviour disorders
–> personal and family relationships
how do clinical psychologists help?
- use expert knowledge in consultation, therapeutics and evaluation
- talking therapies
- working with relatives
- developing specialist services
- supporting care providers
what underpins clinical practice?
- psychological theory
- grounded in research / evidence
- clinical practice
- ethical and practical guidelines
what is missing?
- Health outcomes 20% is access to care
- 80% other factors
- Uptake can be low even when easily available
- Not always culturally acceptable underserved groups
addressing the gaps in clinical practice
- one way is Clinical Psychologists are now working in Public Mental Health teams
- For example, our colleagues in Derbyshire take a whole system approach in suicide prevention
–> Train and Support Local Authority Staff
–> Guide Policy on Messaging
–> Assist in the development of a regional suicide prevention strategy
–> Support voluntary and Community Sector Organisations
the voluntary sector support
- research has found people who self harm value voluntary and community sector support because
- we are now developing ways for clinical psychologists to better support volunteers
routes into clinical psychology
- A three year taught doctorate in clinical psychology
- Currently trainees are employed and have their university fees paid for by the NHS
- HCPC registration
steps towards getting a place in clinical doctorate
- relevant degree
- relevant experience
- or application via clearing house
summary
- mental health services can be shown to be cost effective
–> they reduce other costs and so become at least cost neutral - there are a range of mental health services for people of all ages and with a variety of presenting problems
- mental health professionals have different ways of working and expertise
–> services should ideally bring these strengths together - psychological therapists have established training pathways and regulation of qualified practitioners