clinical practice Flashcards
why are mental health services needed?
- reduction of suffering
–> lessening distress
–> improved quality of life, meaning and purposeful activity
–> limit risks to the individual and other people - social benefits
–> foster a more diverse, inclusive and fairer society
–> lower risk to self and others - economic costs and benefits
mental health sats and facts
- 1 in 6 experience common mental health difficulties (i.e. broadly depression or anxiety)
- 1 in 5 experience suicidal thoughts over their lifetime
- number of people with mental health problems is increasing
economic benefits of providing care
- output effects
–> employment - savings to the NHS
–> reduced costs per person, including physical and mental health services
–> reduced referrals to secondary sector, fewer inpatient admissions, fewer GP consultations and less medication
–> estimated £300 over two year period - savings to the exchequer
–> increased employment (reduction in benefits and increased tax receipts)
–> savings in NHS costs
economic costs of mental health
- mental health problems cost around £105 billion per year in England
–> providing services, lost work, reduced quality of life
–> costing over £2000 per person per year in England - only about 1/3 of people with a mental health disorder get help for it
key questions regarding economic cost
- should we put more resources into services to provide help for more people?
- does paying more to treat people actually have to cost more?
economic costs of mental health in England
health care costs for:
- all problems = around £100 billion per year
- people with mental health problems = £13 billion
–> anxiety and depression = £3.75 billion
–> children and adolescents with mental health problems = £0.75 billion (750 million)
- medically unexplained symptoms = £3 billion
proportion of funding to mental health
- of all health research funding, only 5% goes to mental health
–> large chunk goes to Dementia research
cost-benefit trade off: an example
- initiative was set up based on the cost-benefit trade off
–> Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) - mean resource cost for course of treatment = £750
- financial planners and commissioners of services want to know - do the benefits outweigh the cost?
- if they don’t, what other interventions or resources that might be offered?
cost analysis for IAPT
- what are the benefits of treatment?
- across all patients (whether they recover or not)
–> treating someone reduces their mean benefit costs by one month = £750
–> employment level goes up by 18%
–> absence from work goes down by 31 days/year
–> economic output per person rises by £1100/month
–> where present, costs of comorbid physical conditions go down by several thousand pounds
cost-benefit trade off: early intervention in psychosis
- around 1% of the population will develop psychosis require longer term care
- Early Intervention in Psychosis (EIP) services seek to reduce the amount of time between the onset ofsymptoms and when people receive help
- aims to reduce the impact of symptoms on:
–> their ability work, foster relationships
–> engagement in education
non-EIP vs EIP patients
- compared to patients receiving non-EIP services, patients receiving EIP services were:
–> 116% more likely to gain employment
–> 52% more likely to become accommodated in a mainstream house
–> 17% more likely to have an improvement in the emotional well-being domain of the HONOS questionnaire
cost analysis for EIP
- the key cost differences associated with EIP were:
–> lower mental health inpatient costs (£4,075)
–> lower acute hospital outpatient costs (£59)
–> lower accident and emergency costs (£31)
–> higher mental health community costs (£648) - overall using significantly less (costly) health services had a saving associated with EIP of £4,031
overview of mental heath services
- mental health services provide life saving care
- people benefit from reduced distress / increases quality of life
- research also shows how mental health services reduce costs that would otherwise happen (e.g. increased unemployment, acute care, housing, police involvement)
- this approach can be controversial and has been criticised
basic outline of the NHS
- across lifespan
- acute to longer term care
- for physical and mental health
- provides information and evidence of practices
general practice
- around 90% of NHS patient interaction is with primary care services:
–> GPs
–> dentists
–> community pharmacy services - around 30% of people who make an appointment with a GP do so for help with psychological distress
GPs can refer patients to…
- child and adolescent mental health services (CAMHS)
–> NHS services that assesses and treat young people with emotional, behavioural or mental health difficulties to age 18
–> most CAMHS services work with the whole family to support a young person’s health - Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT)
–> IAPT services provide evidence based treatments for people with anxiety and depression, predominantly stepped care relying on CBT principles
–> IAPT also accept direct referrals
GPs refer patients to… (continued)
- Early intervention in Psychosis (EIP)
–> integrated service for people 14 – 65 presenting with a first episode of psychosis
–> multi disiplinary team structure (doctors, nurses, social workers etc) - Community Mental Health Team (CMHT) & Assessment and Brief Treatment (ABT)
–> many areas have services that provide an initial assessment for signposting to other services - Older Adult Mental Health Team (OAMHT)
–> work families and adults 65+ who are in mental health crisis
types of longer term care
- Community Recovery Teams (CRTs)
–> supporting people 18 – 65 with long term needs - High support / Integrated care teams
–> provide support to people over 18 who have a long term condition (mental or physical health) who live at home or in nursing care - rehabilitation services
–> for people who’ve undergone a recent change in functioning
–> e.g. as a result of acquired brain injury or illness - Community Learning Difficulties Services (CLDS)
specialist services
- Eating Disorder Services (EDS)
- Early Intervention in Psychosis Services (EIP)
- Personality Disorder Services
- Therapeutic Communities / Crisis Houses
acute care for physical and mental health
- Accident and Emergency (A&E)
–> treat patients with acute health problems
–> loss of consciousness
–> acute confused state
–> fits that are not stopping
–> persistent severe chest pain
–> breathing difficulties
–> severe bleeding that cannot be stopped
–> severe allergic reactions
–> severe burns or scalds - Mental Health Liaison (MHL)
–> work in acute general hospital settings and assess people for referral to mental health teams
services for mental health crisis:
- Inpatient mental health care provided in all areas of the country. - This is provided where:
–> there’s need to be admitted for a short period for further assessment
–> there’s a risk to safety if they don’t stay in hospital, for example, if the person is severelyself-harmingor at risk of acting onsuicidal thoughts
–> there is a risk they could harm someone else
–> there isn’t a safe way to treat them at home
–> need more intensive support than can be given to them elsewhere
Home Treatment Teams (HTT)
- inpatient services are supplemented by Home Treatment Teams (HTT)
–> for adults aged 16-65 whose mental health crisis is so severe that they would otherwise have been admitted to a hospital - these are sometimes called Crisis Resolution and Home Treatment (CRHT) teams