classic study Flashcards
classic study
Loftus and Palmer 1974
exp 1 (aim)
A: see whether leading questions would influence estimates of speed of vehicle among EWT
exp 1 (procedure)
P: 45 students 5 groups saw 7 short film clips of a traffic accident
How fast were the cars going when they HIT, SMASHED, COLLIDED, BUMPED, CONTACTED?
exp 1 (results)
R; smashed = 40.5 collided = 39.3 bumped = 38.1 hit = 34 contacted = 31.8
exp 1 (conclusion)
C: 1. verb created bias and influenced decisions
2. word changes memory and they recall it differently
loftus and palmer exp 2
p: 150 students watched film showing a car accident
3 groups SMASHED HIT and NO SPEED QUESTION
week later.. did you see any glass
R: smashed = 32% yes
Hit = 14% yes
control = 12% yes
evaluation
- lab exp so controlled variables and standardised so good internal validity and reliability
- good application to legal system
- video different to real life Yuille and Cutshall 1986
- bad sample - all students
overall conclusion
this study kickstarted whole debate about fragility of memory which had negative consequences to legal system
- however, methodological weakness such as artificial setting
reconstructive hypothesis
memory for an event when the information supplied after event merges with info obtaining for witnessing event