Christian Moral Principles Flashcards
Theonomous Christian Ethics
- Ethics are governed by God’s laws or commands
- For many this is only the bible
Quote the second letter to Timothy and its support for Theonomous Christian Ethics and explain
“All scripture is inspired by God… for training in righteousness”
- View held by biblicist/fundamentalist views of the bible
- Supports the view that all scripture is inspired by God and therefore the Bible is moral instruction
- Bible is the source of morality as God is the author - any struggles is interpretation is our fault
Story of King Davids relationship with Bathsheba as support of Theonomous Christian Ethics
- Shows the teachings are not only in text but also in stories
- The adulterous relationship shows not only the wrongness of the relationship but the failure of Davids moral character
- He misused his King powers to kill Bathsheba’s husband and her husband, Uriah, is moral and everything that David is not
How must the entire theological context of the bible be understood for Theonomous Christians?
- As a covenant with God
- The special promise and agreement from God that humans have to display special behaviour
Old Testament Theonomous Christian Ethics
- Covenant establishes both social and personal ethics
- Ten Commandments act as a summary of these two ideas
- Prophets, e.g Isaiah focus on the social ustice and the treatment of the poor as examples of the proper response to Gods covenant
New Testament Theonomous Christian Ethics
- Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount as the centre of his moral teaching
- New covenant is not only about keeping the law set but also about the inner law of love, peace and righteousness
- Christians are to be ‘perfect’
- Due to Jesus’ life leading to crucifixion and sacrifice humans are called a ‘living sacrifice’ by St Paul
Example of the bible being interpreted too literally, even theonomous Christians dont do this
- Jesus says ‘if your right eye causes you to sin, tear it out and throw it away’
- Who tf is actually going to do that
Katl Barth and ‘bibliolatry’
- Warns of the dangers of literalist interpretation as it gives the bible divine status which only belongs to God
- This would lead to false worship of the bible
- Gods word of revelation has worked through different writers, therefore they are witnesses of the word but not the Word itself
- Bible itself is not the Christian truth but rather a a source of inspiration
Contradictory passages in the OT and NT posing a challenge to Theonomous Christians
- OT permits war and retributive justice ‘an eye for an eye’ in Exodus
- OT allows capital punishment as a part of Gods judgement on those who blaspheme by destroying human life
- NT retribution is replaced by reconciliation, love of ones enemy (Matthew)
- Therefore some may argue that Jesus is attempting to instate the perfect Kingdom of God but the problem of contradiction remains
Heteronomous Christian Ethics
- The view that ethics are governed by several sources of authority or law
- Christian ethics must consider a combination of biblical teaching, Church teaching and human reason
RC Natural Law as Heteronomous Christian Ethics
- Theological Notion that as God is the creator of the world then all things have a good or natural purpose
= Gods Eternal Law, being which achieve their purpose are in a state of flourishing - Thomas Aquinas’ notion of God given reason allows us to reason what is the correct thing to do and on the self-evident principle that we must do good and avoid evil (synderesis)
Four Tiers of Law
Eternal Law; underlying principles of the universe that God knows
Divine Law; Gods law revealed in the bible
Natural Law; Primary precepts, belong to humans and all beings, Secondary precepts, human and animal goal of reproduction, Third precept, human only and is reason, to worship God and live in an orderly society
Human Law; Detailed rules deduced from the primary precepts, acting as secondary precepts, can change due to circumstance
The role of The Magesterium for Heteronymous Christians and the role of ‘Veratitis Splendor’?
- Magesterium is the official church teaching and is revealed in encyclicals
- Veritatis Splendor by St John Paul II
- Argues moral law is knowable to all people, we all have a sense of good and evil
- This is known through NL and through conscience, making us aware of divine law
- We cannot rely on this alone as we are weak and sinful so the Church’s role is to guide individuals moral decisions
Liberation Theology as support for Heteronymous Christian Ethics
- Places the Bible at the centre of its ethics and is suspicious of the ‘top-down’ Church teaching
- Liberation theologians are inspired by the biblical theme of liberation from Moses’ escape from Egypt to Jesus’ role as liberator and liberative ethics is ‘ethics from below’
- They also use Marx to question who has power and how they are benefitting financially, but as it is atheist it is criticised heavily by the Magesterium
Protestant ethical heteronomy - natural law theologians
- Protestant NL theologians, e.g Richard Hooker and Hugo Grotius
- Idea that the bible did not appear as a single document but rather developed out of reflection and needs of communities
- Ethics should continue to develop in the worshipping community and be guided by reason, conscience and Church tradition
- Similar to RC without the Magesterium