CHOP 6: Conformity and Obedience Flashcards
Define Conformity
a change in behavior OR belief due to real or imagined group pressure
acting diff bc of others, acting diff than you would have done along, changing beliefs because of others
What are the two types of conformity
- acceptance
- Compliance (obedience is type of this)
Define acceptance
conformity that involves both acting and believing in accord with social pressure
act/believe accordingly because you ACTUALLY believe so
you stop at red lights bc its safe
genuinely believe in group and what they have persuaded you.
Define Compliance
involves acting/believing publicy in accord with group but you PRIVATELY disagree
behaving/believing in a way you disagree
dont believe what you are doing but do it anyway
acts of compliance either have rewards or punishments
Define Obedience
type of COMPLIANCE
acting/believing in a way because you are told to do so (direct order/command)
doing something you wouldnt do otherwise, but since you are COMMANDED you do it
What is one of the three big studies
Sherif study of Norm Formation
wondered if it was possible for a social norm to form in lab
people were seated in a dark room, and 15ft away a light appeared, they were asked to guess how far away the light was in inches from original point (after it moves all over the place) this study then repeats in a group setting and they went through the same thing and then each day they found their estimates became similar
Define Suggestability
level of being inclined to accept/act on suggestions/influence of others
basically synonymous with mimicry
Define Mass Hysteria
Suggestibility to problems that spreads through a large group of people
katie bratwurst woke up violently twitching and it started to happen to 18 other girls in her school, parents thought there was a containment at school causing it neurologist said that they experienced mass hysteria and had a conversion disorder
What are the 3 big studies
Soloman Asch Experiment on group pressure
line experiement
experimenter tells you that you are apart of a perceptual judgement study
asks you to match the length of the line to 3 other lines. You are in a group and it goes smoothly until some people in the group start saying the wrong answer
results show conformity despite there being any real reason to conform, besides the increased arousal from standing out.
lacked mundane realism but had a lot of experimental realism
MILGRAM OBEDIENCE STUDY
demands of authority vs demands of conscience
two men came to yale to participate in a learning/memory study
experimenter comes in and tells teacher to read a list of words and its pairs and to punish any errors with SHOCKS (with increasing levels with each wrong answer)
they pulled their roles out of a hat, teacher and learner and the volts went from 15-450
the learner is heard grunting and screaming in pain and the experimenter prompted the teacher to go on no matter what
nearly all stopped to show concern, but no body thought they would go past 300 volts BUT 56% did
What are the 4 ways the design of Milgram Study showed that he demonstrated pyschological effects
- throught the slippery slope of small requests that escalated into larger ones
- framing shock giving as a social norm for the situation
- the opportunity to deny responsibility
- limited time to reflect on decision
Jerry Burger tried to replicate in 2009 BUT 70% of 2000 still obeyed so culture around obedience changed
What were some ways that Milgrims Study was UNETHICAL?
- stressed the teachers against their own will (pyschological distress)
- participants were deceived about their purpose and never given chance at informed consent
- argue that the self concepts of participants were altered
According to the milgram studies what BREEDS obedience?
- The Vicitms Distance (distance and emotional distance)
- Closeness and Legitmacy of the Authority (physically close and actual authority)
- Institutional Authority (prestige)
- The liberating effects of group influence (conformity can be constructive)
What are some of the reflections on the Big three studies?
-
the similar experiences in the asch and milgram studies - how compliance takes over moral precedence
behavior and attitudes - external influences override internal convictions - the power of social norms* - we realize how strong they are when trying to break them
- Use of labs - differ from real life situatios, need to be careful in generating simplicity
What is a real life example of Sherif’s norm formation study
interpreting the events of a story differently after hearing it from others