CHAPTER 4 Flashcards
Treaties
Reviewing the
Legal Frameworks
● Terre Nullius
● Papal Bull
● Doctrine of Discovery
● Royal Proclamation of 1763
Treaties
Treaties are a common thread running through the history of the Indigenous–European relationship
treaties demonstrate
an ability of both sides to willingly enter into a purposeful dialogue
Treaties remain symbolic of
political and economic
imbalances that have led to ongoing colonialism
treaties also characterize Canada’s failure to
failure to adhere to
the spirit and intent of sacred covenants
Both sides agree
reconciliation is possible only once we improve our understanding of treaty principles
Indigenous nations developed unique political ideologies to
○ Preserve their cultural autonomy
○Maintain their political sovereignty
○ Safeguard their traditional lands
A North American treaty order emerged
○ Indigenous treaties encouraged regional balance by fostering peaceful relationships
Language barriers existed, making
communications
difficult
Nations thus developed critical diplomatic skills
based
in a common political process
The council was the diplomatic arena for resolving
complex diplomatic issues
Negotiating the treaty was as important as the
outcome because?
○Delegates were interested in the overall tone of discussions and their opponents’ diplomatic skills
○Promises and affirmations that resulted from goodfaith negotiations were considered binding
○Negotiations and final agreements had to be
committed to memory
○Treaty councils ended when gifts and wampum were exchanged
Europeans previously used the doctrine of discovery to acquire
Indigenous lands
Terra nullius
lands (land deemed unoccupied) could
be occupied legally
Eventually Indigenous peoples were recognized as having
imperium (liberty) and dominium (property)
As Aboriginal title existed, the Monarch could
acquire title in one of three ways
○ If the land was later abandoned
○ If a just war was waged on infidels
○ If sanctioned negotiations led to a formalized treaty
acknowledging a land sale
There are four key eras of treaty making
○ First contact to the Royal Proclamation (1763)
○ Post–Royal Proclamation to Confederation (1867)
○ Post-Confederation to the Natural Resources Transfer Agreements (1930)
○Modern treaty period (1975–present)
These have been described as compact
(era 1),
contract (era 2), and covenant (era 3)
They were negotiated during two different periods
○ Treaties 1–7 from 1871–1877
○ Treaties 8–11 from 1899–1921
treaties 1-7
1871–1877
treaties 8-11
1899-1921
The Robinson–Huron and –Superior Treaties of
1850
Royal Proclamation (1763) land-surrender provisions stated that
public negotiations must occur prior to any land sale to a Crown agent
Treaties were desirable for several reasons
○ They were a means to protect Indigenous peoples
○ They extinguished Aboriginal title