Chapter 12 Flashcards
In a randomized controlled trial . . .
participants are randomly assigned to one of two or more treatment conditions.
In 1952, Hans Eysenck published a review from which he concluded that rates of improvement among clients receiving psychodynamic or eclectic psychotherapy were . . .
comparable to rates of remission of symptoms among untreated clients.
Prior to Hans Eysenck’s controversial 1952 article challenging the efficacy of psychotherapy, . . .
proponents of various forms of psychotherapy based their claims on clinical experience and expert consensus.
The huge growth in empirical attention toward the effects of psychotherapy has been attributed to:
Hans Eysenck
What made it difficult to compare research conducted by behavioural therapists and traditional therapists in the mid-1900s?
- Each research group used different criteria for including studies in their review.
- Different criteria were used to evaluate whether therapy worked.
- Interpretation of results was influenced by each group’s biases
Mary Smith and Gene Glass are the authors of the first:
meta-analysis of the adult psychotherapy literature.
Meta analysis is a method for . . .
quantitatively reviewing research studies.
In order to integrate the results from multiple studies meta-analyses involve the calculation of:
effect sizes.
An effect size of d = .66 means that:
there is a difference of two-thirds of a standard deviation between groups.
Smith and Glass’s (1977) initial meta-analysis of the effect of psychotherapy suggested that:
psychotherapy can have a substantially positive impact.
Three years after their initial publication, Smith, Glass, and Miller (1980) published a more extensive and sophisticated meta-analysis on the effect of psychotherapy. Results were:
even more positive than the original meta-analysis.
Smith, Glass, and Miller (1980) compared the efficacy of various types of treatment and found that the treatments with the largest to smallest effect sizes were, respectively:
Cognitive-Behavioural, behavioural, psychodynamic, humanistic
Smith, Glass, and Miller (1980) compared the effects of psychotherapy across different disorders and found that the largest effect sizes were found in the treatment of . . .
mood and anxiety problems.
Unpublished research is also known “grey literature” research, and can include . . .
unpublished studies provided by researchers
Clinical practice guidelines
provide recommendations based on best available evidence.
The first initiative to introduce clinical practice guidelines to the field of clinical psychology occurred in the early
1990s.
Motivation to develop clinical practice guidelines in clinical psychology came from
increasing demands for health care practices to be demonstrably effective and cost-effective.
The APA Society of Clinical Psychology 1995 task force required which of the following conditions be met for a treatment to be designated as an empirically supported treatment?
- Evidence of symptom reduction.
- Improved functioning among participants.
- Data were derived from at least two independently conducted RCTs or from a large series of single-case studies.
Evidence-based treatments vary in the extent and nature of their supporting data—so a treatment could have a modest evidence base but, because no independent RCTs have been conducted on the treatment, it would not meet the original criteria to be an EST. Therefore, the term evidence-based is ________________ the term EST.
broader and more inclusive than
A treatment study in which no control group is used and, typically, few participant exclusion criteria are applied is known as a(n) . . .
open trial.
There are evidence-based psychological treatment for
the most commonly diagnosed mental disorders.
The Canadian Psychological Association task force on evidence-based psychological services recommended that psychologists give the strongest weight to:
syntheses of studies that balance internal and external validity.
The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) stepped care model for the management of depression includes the following possible treatments except:
transcranial magnetic stimulation.
In cognitive-behavioural treatment of depression, behavioural activation tasks could include
making a special meal.