Chapter 1 - The Role of the Judge at Trial/ Burden of Proof at Trial (Evidence Book p. 35-36) Flashcards
Judges, especially _______ judges have a good deal of control and discretion in administering their courtrooms and getting involved at trial.
federalW
What rule gives courts broad control to set the mode and order of witnesses and question them as well.
Rule 611
Although judges may generally comment on the evidence produced at trial, they must do so in such a manner that they appear to be neutral, especially when it comes to a credibility determination of a witness. True or False.
True
United States v. Yates deals with what?
Commenting on Evidence
Although judges may generally comment on the evidence produced at trial, they must do so in such a manner that they appear to be ________, especially when it comes to a ___________ determination of a _______.
neutral
credibility
witness
Crandell v. United States deals with what?
Questioning Witnesses
Although judges may pose questions to witnesses, they must do so in a way that they appear to be neutral; therefore, hostile, leading, or rhetorical questions, especially if asked in a doubting or challenging tone, should be avoided. Questions should be impartial. True or False.
True
The burden of proof is generally on the ____________________.
plaintiff/ prosecution
The burden of proof is generally on the plaintiff/ prosecution, as they are the ones asking to change the status quo (however, the burden can switch to the defendant if he poses an __________ ___________, or in other circumstances.
affirmative defense
The burden of proof has two parts:
- The burden of Production
- Burden of Persuasion
This is a requirement to produce some actual evidence supporting a legal claim or allegation, much like the summary judgment/ directed verdict standard in Civil Procedure (where the judge decides, as a matter of law, whether there is sufficient evidence for the jury to weigh at trial.)
Burden of Production
This is a requirement to convince the jury to weigh the evidence produced at trial in the favor of the party with the burden, according to the applicable standard of proof.
Burden of Persuasion
The amount of proof necessary to find in a party’s favor.
Standards of Proof
What are the 3 standards of proof?
Preponderance of the Evidence
Clear and Convincing
Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
This is the “more likely than not” standard. The balance only needs to be slightly tipped in favor of the party with the burden (greater than 50%).
Preponderance of the Evidence