Changing Places Case Studies Flashcards
Name the case studies for concept of place
Glastonbury, Somerset.
Uluru, Australia.
What is the location of Glastonbury?
Somerset.
23 miles south of Bristol.
Give examples of what make the ‘locale’ of Glastonbury?
Glastonbury Abbey.
Glastonbury Tor.
Music festival.
What is Glastonbury Tor?
A hill near Glastonbury.
It is topped by the roofless St Michael’s Tower - a Grade 1 listed building.
The whole site is managed by the National Trust, and has been designated a scheduled monument.
Give ideas of the sense of place associated with Glastonbury
Religious (Abbey).
Heritage (Tor).
Fun, exciting, worry-free (festival).
Explain how people have might have a different concept of place about Uluru
Aboriginals -> insiders -> sacred rock -> religious -> heritage.
Tourists -> outsiders -> scenic rock -> may disrespect it -> no personal importance.
Why would people have different perceptions of Ground Zero, New York?
Different experiences…
• If they lost a relative in 9/11 attack.
• If they were a rescuer in 9/11 arrack.
• Tourist.
If they visited Ground Zero at different times…
• On anniversary of 9/11.
• Soon after the 9/11 attack.
Suggest how a grieving mother of a 9/11 victim might feel about Ground Zero
Dark, depressing place.
Not comforting.
The gift shop is disrespectful and unnecessary.
Suggest how a tourist might feel about Ground Zero
Breathtaking, beautiful, moving.
Amazing museum.
Makes an fantastic day trip.
Name the place that can be related to the social constructionist approach. How does they link?
Trafalgar Square.
Built to commemorate a British naval victory in 1800s.
Using social constructionist approach -> understood as a place of empire / colonialism.
Give an example of a place where there are insiders and outsiders. Who might the insiders and outsiders be?
Canary Wharfe, London.
Insiders = business men -> reason to be there (job), wealthy.
Outsiders = homeless person -> nothing in common, there are anti-homeless spikes to stop rough sleepers.
Give an example of a known person that has been both an insider and an outsider to their place of living. Which places?
Mo Farah -> U.K. / USA
When did Mo Farah feel like an insider in the U.K.?
- When he was accepted as a Somalian refugee at 8 years old.
* When he was knighted.
When did Mo Farah feel like an outsider in the U.K.?
When he first arrived from Somalia and didn’t know anyone / the culture.
When did Mo Farah feel like an insider in the USA?
He has been a citizen there for past 6 years.
When did Mo Farah feel like an outsider in the USA?
President Trump may not have allowed him to return to US due to immigration policies -> felt unwelcome.
Why might minority groups in England feel excluded / outsiders in rural areas?
- Historically, immigrants moved into urban areas -> little connection to rural places.
- Less than 1% of visitors to National Parks were of black / ethnic minorities in 2001.
Give examples of projects that aim to reduce the feeling that ethnic minorities are excluded from rural England
• ‘Mosaic’
= national project -> aims to create links between black / ethnic minorities and organisations eg National Parks, Youth Hostel Association.
• YHA
-> actively encourages young people from black/ minority groups to volunteer in the countryside -> to feel more connected.
Name the case study to use for places represented in the media
Hebden Bridge / Happy Valley
How does the TV show Happy Vallet portray Hebden Bridge?
Negatively…
• High crime rate -> prostitution, petty theft, drug dealing, murder.
• Run-down area.
What is Hebden Bridge like in reality?
- Small town of about 4,500 residents.
- Friendly.
- Scenic -> tourist attraction.
- Low crime rate.
Why aren’t residents of Hebden Bridge happy about its portrayal in Happy Valley?
Happy Valley portrays it in a negative light -> may put off tourists.
Makes them look bad -> outsiders may think all residents are criminals.
Name the case study to use for when a place changes
Ground Zero, World Trade Centre, New York.
Does the portrayal of Hebden Bridge in Happy Valley have a positive effect or negative effect on the area?
Positives:
• Tourist income -> viewers likely realise that TV drama isn’t a true representation of the place.
• Makes the place known.
• May encourage money to be spent improving infrastructure.
Negatives:
• Upset locals.
• Could put off some tourists -> BBC programme so well trusted channel -> some viewers may believe that it reflects the real place.
Name the case study to be used for clone towns
Costa Coffee -> Totnes, South Devon.
What is the population of Totnes, South Devon?
8,500 residents
Which chain store wanted to open a branch in Totnes? In what year?
Costa Coffee.
2012
Were residents pleased with the proposed plans to open a costa coffee in Totnes? Why?
They were not happy.
• Didn’t want to become a clone town -> keep independent shops + traditions.
• Already 42 coffee shops in Totnes.
• Costa would damage local economy + compromise tourist charms -> want to support local businesses.
How many locals signed a petition against the opening of Costa coffee in Totnes? How many wrote to the council to object?
6000 signed petition.
300 write to the council.
Is Totnes a clone town?
No.
Majority of shops there are independent.
Has a Superdrug and WHSmith.
What did Costa argue would be the benefits of opening a store in Totnes?
- Costa wouldn’t threaten existing coffee shops.
- Add to the vibrancy of the town.
- A place where people could come together.
Name a case study area in which a chain store has recently opened a branch. Which chain store?
Otley.
Costa coffee
In a survey, what percentage of Otley residents said that they would use Costa if it opened?
42%
In a survey, what percentage of Otley residents said that they would stick to local shops if a Costa branch opened?
49%