Ch 4-6 Flashcards
Moral Distress:
a type of ethical tension that occurs when a practitioner
knows the right course of action but experiences constraints are barriers that prevent them from acting accordingly and creates discomfort that arises from discord between ethical action and practical limitations.
moral agent
a person who can differentiate between right and wrong
3 broad categories of moral distress:
Institutional ethics (e.g., healthcare environment comma reimbursement
pressure)
Professional practice (e.g., codes of conduct or behavior, professionalism)
Clinical decision making (e.g. Goal setting, discharge planning)
Implications
Negative impact on emotional and physical well-being of the practitioner, the culture of the
workplace, the care of clients, job satisfaction, and staff retention
Leads to burnout:
Practical applications in OT
2 categories to combat moral distress:
(1) prevention & (2) intervention
ALL OTP’s should have moral courage to advocate for what they perceive to be right and
ethical
Moral courage:
the courage to overcome the fear of adverse consequences and act in accordance with ethical standards and values
The six strategies occupational therapy manager should implement to prevent and reduce moral distress
(1) recognizing moral distress
(2) implementing educational strategies
(3) facilitating interdisciplinary research
(4) improving communication
(5) creating healthy organizational work environments
(6) promoting ethical leadership
(1) Recognizing Moral Distress
Identifying and naming the moral distress is a powerful strategy for mitigating the distress.
Recognizing feelings of powerlessness in a situation, allows practitioners
to seek the support or resources they need
2 Implementing Educational
Strategies
Continuing education on ethical matters
By engaging in or creating opportunities for professional growth
3 Facilitating Interdisciplinary
Research
Interdisciplinary moral distress research is essential.
Further research is required to understand moral distress in OT.
Understanding how team dynamic negatively or positively affect moral distress will lead to more effective interventions and elevation of the team
effectiveness.
(4) Improving Communication
Communication continues to be one of the biggest challenges in health care today.
Fostering an environment where ALL individuals feel comfortable
Managers must create a safe space for open dialogue around difficult topics.
Respectful communication
(5) Creating a Healthy Work
Environment
OT managers must emphasize respect for ALL individuals, both clients and staff.
OTP’s need to see themselves as moral agents with moral courage to strengthen the healthcare environment
(6) Promoting Ethical Leadership
Ethics & Leadership are intertwined
A leader cannot be effective without careful consideration of ethics.
In challenging situations an ethical leader will advocate for optimal solutions
A strong ethical leader will set the example
(7) Occupational Therapy Ethics
Rounds
forums that bring together OT
practitioners and create an opportunity to discuss emerging ethical issues
(1) Allow practitioners to practice communication skills
(2) Demonstrate a commitment to education and ethics
(3) Strengthen the ability to recognize an ethical issue
(4) Act as a support system
Rounds may be initiated by managers practitioners and may be held at a specific frequency or on an as-needed
Codes of ethics
along with personal ethics define the range of
appropriate relationships and service delivery within a profession.
MOST codes of ethics in health care have unifying themes based on the
four principles of biomedical ethics
Bioethics
is a multidisciplinary field of study, including research, public health, organizational
and clinical ethics
Biomedical ethics and clinical medical ethics
are interchangeable terms referring to the
application of ethical reasoning to specific clinical situations.
The 4 principles of biomedical ethics:
(1) Autonomy
(2) Nonmaleficence
(3) Beneficence
(4) Justice
Clinical Medical Ethics (CME)
Founded in 1972 by Mark Siegler,
Focus: Ethical decision-making in daily patient care interactions
Key Concept: Practical ethics for health care professionals, beyond theoretical bioethics.
Central to CME: The relationship between provider and patient.
Shared-Decision Making: Evolved through CME, emphasizing patient-provider relationships.
Daily Practice: Interprofessional huddles improve communication and prevent errors.
Utilitarianism
A philosophy that considers the best choice to maximize good for the most people
or minimize harm to the fewest.
Key Principle: The ends justify the means.
Application: Cost-benefit or cost-effectiveness analysis for resource allocation
Utilitarianism examples
- Maximize benefit using cost-effectiveness analysis.
- Every life has equal value, no bias toward specific individuals.
- No preference for actions addressing inequality unless they maximize overall benefit.
Healthcare Example: Mailing free COVID-19 test kits to all households to reduce transmission, without regard to individual circumstances.