ch 3: analyzing arguments Flashcards
crazed rhetoric: contrary to what arguments are meant to be, crazed rhetoric lacks …, …, and … for one’s claims
sufficient evidence; support; credibility
arguments should be a process incorporating … in which … is sought
reason; common ground
arguments are discussions focused on the purpose of …, which lead from a .. to a …
persuading; claim; conclusion
rogerian arguments: emphasizes the significance of … and …., advocates the notion that it is imperative to have a complete understanding of the …
concession; refutation; counterargument
the goal of a rogerian argument is not to … your opponents or to dismantle their viewpoints but rahter to reach a …
destroy; satisfactory conclusion
a claim is the component of an argument that acts as a
thesis statement
the claim should be
debatable
the claim should be a complete
sentence
a strong claim is the result of … as well as deliberation over the information found through the …
extensive, thorough research; research
three types of claims:
claims of fact, claims of value, claims of policy
these claims guide entire arguments, of which there are 3:
arguments of fact, arguments of value, arguments of policy
claims of fact assert that something is
true/not true
arguments of fact are dependent on the information that is considered to be
factual
whenever you are evaluating or writing an argument of fact, it’s important to approach your subject with
healthy skepticism
claims of value: most common type of claim; argues about the … of something
worth
claims of value must be
debatable
claims of value may incorporate
opinions
in order to create an argument based on a claim of value, one must have specific standards, meaning the factors that make the object being discussed have the
value that the author assigns it
the speaker must then demonstrate the manner in which these standards
apply to the subject
claims of policy propose
change
argument of policy begins with a j
claim of fact (identifies problem)
(argument of policy) claim of fact is followed by a
claim of value (explains nature of problem)
(argument of policy) the claim of value is then followed by a
claim of policy (suggests change)
(argument of policy) while an argument of policy usually calls for some direct action to take plce, it may be a recommendation for a change in
attitude or viewpoint
types of thesis statements:
closed theiss, open thesis, counterargument theiss
closed thesis:
main idea + major points
closed theses are more efective for shorter essays in that it limits teh
amount of points that can be made
open theses are more effective for
lengthy essays
open theses don’t list the author’s points, but rather, it imply states the
main idea
counterargument thesis summarizes a counterargument that is followed by the
speaker’s belief
a counterargument thesis instantaneously makes the argument appear
strong and logical
the conterargument thesis allows one to use … and … technique more effectively
concession; refutation
a counterargument thesis does not have to demonstrate complete
support or rejection
rhetorical choices: the …, …, and … of evidence
amount; type; presentation
amount, type and presentation of evidence is dependent on what the … and … is
purpose; audience
one must consider whether …. or .. evidence would be more effective in persuading audience
formal/ informal
relevant evidence: relates tot eh
argument
the relationship beween relevant evidence and argument is typically
expressed
accurate evidence: does not … the information supplied by the evidence being used
misinterpret/misrepresent
to have accurate evidence: utilize …, consider…, consider what type of evidence will …
credible sources; bias; appeal to your audience
sufficient evidence: there should be enough evidence so that the thesis will be
completely supported
logical fallacies: potential … or … in an argument
vulnerabilities; weaknesses
logical fallacies can occur when the relationship between the argument and the evidence is not
adequately explained
occassionally, fallacies are deliberately employed to
manipulate the audience