Bernard Harcourt (broken window "opponent") Flashcards
Empirical and Theoretical problems with broken windows
true
Empirical: only small sliver of population; was that one problem with their sample data? true or false
true
In broken window the sample population was only 60-70%
Broken windows is not representative of the population. true or false?
true
It wasn’t representative of the populous.
true
Harcourt found that robbery connection to disorder, only in?
bad neighborhoods
Do you need two witnesses in Newark for murder?
yes
Broken window theory used data from bad neighborhoods. Theories need to be true in all neighborhoods, not just bad neighborhoods. true or false?
true
Broken windows theory was falsely credited for New York’s reduction of crime. true or false
true
Yet, a reduction of crime in New York was declining, regardless of the broken window theory. true or false
true
In Los Angeles, the crime rate was declining before Bratton arrived with his broken window theory. true or false
true
Theoretical Problems is that it. . . ?
Segregates people into Orderly and Disorderly
forces cops to look at people as orderly vs disorderly
true or false?
true
how do they identify orderly people
smile at cops, go to police meetings, ride-alongs; familiar
How do they identify disorderly.
don’t smile at cops, do not relate to cops: unfamiliar
2 Jungle trop
Police who don’t know any hood culture are patrolling the streets of hoods. Automatically believe hoods are full of criminals - working class neighborhoods are inhospitable and its a frightening jungle. People who didn’t grow up in the hood (jungle trope)
Is there a connection between rape and disorder?
no
Does assault and burglary have a connection with societal disorder?
no
Is poverty related to assault and burglary?
yes
does robbery does have a connection to murder and disorder? Only in five highest murderous societies.
yes, but only in statistical outlier- only true in certain neighborhoods (cherry picking).
what is broken window major claim?
petty crime leads to major crimes.