Attachment Flashcards
what are attachments?
-strong, long-lasting emotional bond to a particular individual
- one or more caregivers
-important for development
what are the characteristics of attachments?
- selective
- involves proximity seeking: physical closeness
- provide comfort and security
- can lead to distress
- involves a primary attachment figure, usually mother, mother/figure
- protect the infant
define reciprocity
when one person provokes a reaction from another eg baby cries
define interactional synchrony
when mother and infant behaviour mirror each other
Meltzoff and Moore
procedure
- 1977
- conducted a controlled experiment into interactional synchrony.
- the adult displayed one of three actions: mouth opening, termination of mouth opening, and tongue protrusion.
- the child’s response was filmed and judged by independent observers
- an association was found between the facial expressions of the mother and the actions of the baby.
- inter-observer reliability was greater than .92 - in a later study they demonstrated the same synchrony with infants 3 days old, thus suggesting this behaviour is innate.
IS + R research
Evaluation
+
- the babies do not know they are being filmed so have no social desirability
- Abravnel and DeYoung 1991 observed infants interacting with two objects and found that children between 5-12 weeks made little response to the objects, supporting the idea they have a social specific repsonse
-
- testing the behaviours of infants is hard because we dont know the behaviour is not just general behaviour as opposed to intimidation.
- Socially senstivie research: based upon Isabella’s findings does this sggest infants will be at a disadvantage if their mothers go back to work?
Isabella et al
- 1989
- observed 30 mothers and infants to assess their synchrony and the quality of the attachment between the mother and the infant.
- it was found a higher the level of synchrony was associated with a better quality of mother-infant attachments.
Schaffer and Emerson
Method
- 1964
- sample of 60 babies - 31 male and 29 female from Glasgow
- the majority were from skilled working-class families
- during the 1st year the babies were visited by the researchers every month
- they were again visited at 18 months.
- mothers were asked how the baby protested in 7 everyday situations
- stranger anxiety was also tested
- the mother was asked to rate on a 4-point scale the intensity of the protest and who the protest was aimed at
Schaffer and Emerson
Findings
25-32 weeks: 50% of babies showed separation anxiety towards a particular adult
- attachment tended to be towards the person who interacted the most with them, not necessarily they spent the most time with.
- 40 weeks: 80% of babies had a specific attachment and 30% displayed multiple attachments.
Stage 1 of attachment:
Indiscrimate Attachments
- Birth - 8 weeks: the infants’ response is the same to animate or inanimate objects.
- towards the end of this stage, infants show a preference for social stimuli and are more content being with people.
Stage 2 of attachments
The Beginnnings of Attachment
- 4 months: infants become more social, preferring human company to inamimate objects
- do not show stranger anxiety
Stage 3 of attachment
Discrimate Attachments
- 7 months
- they show protest to being put down (separation anxiety)
- believed to have formed a specific attachment to one person, their primary attachment figure.
- display stranger anxiety
Stage 4 of attachment
Multiple Attachments
within 1 month of becoming attached, Schaffer and Emerson found that 29% of the infants had multiple attachments with someone else. these are secondary attachments and infants will display secondary attachments and infants will display separation anxiety.
- by 6 months, this was 78% of infants
by 1 year old, 1/3 of infants will have 5 or more secondary attachments.
- by 18 months, 75% of infants have attached with their father.
Schaffer and Emerson
Evaluation
- staging attachments can be problematic as it leads to labelling people as abnormal if they do not fit in the stages. it assumes development has to follow a certain pattern and is inflexible when the reality may be different.
-Sample bias: working class families in Glasgow, can the findings be applied to other classes and places? it was conducted in 1960s and families have changed, more working mothers and stay at home fathers.
-Multiple attachments: are these all equal? some psychologists dont agree, such as Bowlby argues that the primary attachment is crucial for development, Rutter argues that all attachments influence development.
why are fathers less likely to be the primary attachment?
- mothers breastfeed
- men lack emotional sensitivity
- spend less time with the infant - maternity leave
Role of the father:
Field
- 1978
- Believes the key to attachment was the responsiveness of the parent. those that luagh, smile, and hold the infant are much more likely to be attached to.
Role of the father:
Grossman
- 2002
- Longitudinal study looking at parents behaviour and quality of attachment
Role of the father
Schaffer and Emerson
they found that the most interactive care-giver was attached to
Role of the father
Role of Oestogen
Oestrogen is linked to caring behaviour, which is a hormone women produce.
Role of the father
Evaluation
- Each family is different (single, same-sex), so attachments may differ: individual differences.
- Men may feel pressured: they aren’t as responsible as women.
- Mens’ lack of sensitivity promotes risk-taking, they are not worried if the infant hurts themselves. it also promotes creativity
-
Harry Harlow
Procedure
- two wire monkeys with different heads
- one of the wire monkeys was wrapped in cloth
- 8 infant Rhesus monkeys were studied for 165 days
- 4 monkeys the cloth monkey had a milk bottle
- the remaining 4 the wire monkey had the milk bottle
- how long the monkeys spent with each monkey was measured
- what the infants did when scared was also monitored.
Harry Harlow
Findings
- the cloth monkey was the most popular whether it had a feeding bottle or not
- the infants only spent a short amount of time feeding from the wire monkeys before returning to the cloth monkey (contact comfort)
- when frightened all monkeys all monkeys clung to the cloth monkey (proximity-seeking behaviour)
- when playing with a new toy, they would keep one foot on the cloth monkey for reassurance (secure base)
Harry Harlow
variations of the study
- rape rack
- pit of despair
- spikes on the cloth/wire monkey
Harry Harlow
Ethical issues
- females made to mate with male against their will
- purposefully hurt the monkeys (metal spikes, harsh air)
- Pit of despair - isolating the monkeys for 1 year
Harry Harlow
Long- lasting effects on the monkeys
- never learned to socialize
- Were not interested in reproduction
- couldn’t form relationships
- not good offspring - kill offspring. Due to a lack of an internal working model
Harry Harlow
Evaluation
-
- Long-lasting detrimental effects for the monkeys
- Extrapolation
- Variables: the monkeys had 2 different heads so the monkeys could have preferred the monkey with the most realistic face - compound results