Argument & Scholarship Flashcards
Plato Aristotele Socrates
- Socrates (470-399 bce)
- Plato (428/7 - 348/7 bce)
- Aristotle (384-322 bce)
Plato
• Wrote a lot
• Wrote dialogues btwn Socrates and others
• Earlier dialogues = Socrates as Socrates
Later dialogues = Socrates as Platos Mouthpiece
Aristotele
• Less finished work than Plato
Mainly notes from his students
Sophists vs Socrates
• Sophists Taught how to win arguments, regardless of truth
• Socrates sees argument as a way to truth
Socrates stands for
Belief that there is a truth to be found and reasoned argument is a good route to find it
Platonic Picture of a good leader
Someone who seeks truth in order to lead well
Socratic Argument today
- Legal systems
- Parliamentary discussion
- Competitive debating
- The peer-review system in academia
- The notion of a marketplace of ideas
- Any form of constructive, critical discussion
Deductive Logic
Start with certain number of premises and apply valid logical rules to pull out implications of the premises
Inductive Logic
Observe small number of samples, notice pattern and generalize this pattern holds in all cases. Some=All
Abductive Logic
Special form of induction, deciding what the best explanation for a situation would be
Cannot be sure of this explanation
Valid Argument
Applies good logic
Invalid Argument
Makes logical mistake
Sound Argument
Combines valid argument with true premises
** Valid deductive logic produces a guaranteed true conclusion
Unsound Argument
Either false premises or makes logical mistake
Syllogism
Minor premise —> Major premise —> Conclusion
Fallacy
Logical mistake
Modern Logic
If-Then statement
Conditional Statement
If X, then Y
Exclusive-or vs Inclusive-or
• Exlusive-or —> Either X or Y
•Inclusive-or —> Either X, or Y, or Both
IMRaD
Introduction
Methods
Results
and
Discussion