4.7 - Green Crime, Globalisation & State Crime Flashcards
Crime & Globalisation (KS)
> Held (Global Criminal Economy)
Castells (GCE, Supply & Demand, GRC)
Beck (GRC)
> Taylor (Marxism, Globalisation & Crime)
LR (Globalisation & Crime)
> Friedrichs (COG)
Cain (COG)
> Hobbs & Dunnigham (Globalisation & Patterns of Criminal Organisation)
Hobbs & Dunnigham (Glocal Organisations)
> Glenny (McMafia & Globalisation of McMafia)
Held (Global Criminal Economy)
> Globalisation of crime, due to + interconnectedness of crime across national borders
> Many causes e.g. New ICT, global mass media, cheap air travel etc
> Now spread of transnational organised crimes
Castells - Global Criminal Economy (GCE)
> Now GCE worth > 1 trillion per annum w/ many forms
> e.g. Arms trafficking, trafficking illegal prostitutes, sex tourism, terroism
> Drugs trade worth 400B, money laundering profits for organised crime worth 1.5T
Castells - Globalisation, Supply & Demand
> Western states have demand for products/services & developing world, feeds demand w/ supply
> e.g. drugs made in Colombia & Peru, as peasants find drug cultivation > profitable > traditional crops
> But are consumed in 1st world countries
Beck - Global Risk Consciousness (GRC)
> Ppl now more conscious of risks of globalisation & eco migrants & asylum seekers fleeing prosecution
> Led to western anxieties on risk of opening borders, media creates MP, so leds to hate crimes vs minorities
> Led to response of tightening control of UK borders
Taylor - Marxism, Globalisation & Crime
> Creates crime @ both ends of social spectrum WC suffer from lack of legit employment opportunities
> Due to outsourcing to cheaper labour pools & lack of welfare so illegal options are more rational e.g. drug trade
> UC benefit as globalisation of money markets led to + insider trading, tax evasion/wide-scale fraud.
General Criticisms of Taylor
Doesn’t explain why not all ppl turn to crime
LR - Globalisation & Crime
> Materialistic culture promoted by global media encourages ppl to see themselves as individual consumers
> Undermining SS & leads to crime
Globalisation & Problems w/ Policing
> Crimes are transnational so needs co-operation w/ diff law enforcement agencies to convict criminals
> Illegalities in 1 state may not be in another & D many be in 1 country & V in another
> So hard to decide jurisdiction
Friedrichs - Crimes of Globalisation (COG)
> IMF & World Bank, do COG, imposing pro-capitalist structural adjustment programmes on poor countries
> So requires them to cut public spending, leading to unemployment
Cain - COG
> IMF are global state w/ actions causing widespread harm & eco conditions for state crimes e.g. Rwandan genocide
Patterns of Criminal Organisation
Globalisation creates new criminal opportunties & give rise to new forms of criminal organization
Hobbs & Dunnigham - Globalisation & Patterns of Criminal Organisation
Involves indvidual acting as a hub, which loose-knit network forms, linking legit & illegitimate opportunities.
Hobbs & Dunnigham - Glocal Organisations
> New organisations w/ crime locally based but w/global connections
> e.g. drug smuggling (global) but depends on local setting e.g. where to sell
> Diff from rigid, hierarchal, mafia-style crim org of past much + fluid, flexible & faster responding to new opportunities.
Evaluation of Hobbs and Dunningham
> Unclear if patterns of organisation are new or old 1’s disappeared, may 2 always co-existed.
> Conclusions are ungeneralisable criminal activities elsewhere.
What is McMafia?
Org’s emerging in Russia & East Europe after fall of communism
Glenny - McMafia
> New Rus Gov deregulated economy, prices of food & rent + commodities e.g. gas/oil kept @ same price (low compared w/ ROW)
> Rich oligarchs brought these cheaply & sold for + prices on world market
> For protection from violence they hired ‘mafias’ who’d begun to arise e.g. former KGB men & ex-convicts.
> Mafias were purely eco organisations based on self-interests
Glenny - Globalisation of McMafia
> Mafia’s became famous for professionalism & efficiency, so began to brand themselves e.g. as Chechen Mafia
> So due to globalisation became franchised around world as protection rackets
> Building links w/ crim orgs in other countries.
Green Crimes
Harms done to environment incl. Animals
Globalisation of Green Crime
> Threats to eco-system have global effects e.g. nuclear accident in 1 country
> Can spread radioactive material, thousands of miles away
Green Crimes (KS)
> Beck (Global Risk Society)
> TC (View on Green Crime)
GC (View on Green Crime)
Marxism (View on GC)
> South (Primary and Secondary Green Crime)
> Wolf (Victims of Green Crime Toxic Waste Dumping & Perpetrators of Green Crime)
Beck (Global Risk Society)
> Natural threats of past are now less dangerous > man-made threats
> Can now give resources for all through tech, so created manufactured risks, dangers not faced b4
> Threatening all of humanity w/out solutions for them e.g. global warming, leads to global risk society - all shares = risks
Views on Green Crime
> Traditional Criminology
> Green Criminology
Traditional Criminology (TC) - View on Green Crime
> e.g. define environmental crime as unauthorised act/omission violating laws of state
> Only concerned w/ whether it breaks any national law
> So won’t see global warming/acid rain as crime as they don’t break any laws.
Criticisms of Traditional Criminology
Accepts official def of environmental crime shaped by large corporations to serve own interests
Green Criminology (GC) - View on Green Crime
> Sees it as any action harming environment, humans & animals etc, even if laws aren’t broken
> Legal def’s can’t give consistent global standard as they vary from state to state
> Worst of environmental harms aren’t illegal, so subject matter of GC wider > TC, incl. new issues
Marxism & GC
> Similar approach challenging powerful groups who can shape law to define in their own interests what’s environmental harm
> So actions aren’t criminalised
Two Views of Harm
> Anthropocentric
> Ecocentric
Anthropocentric
> Human-centred view e.g. we have right to dominate nature for own ends & put eco growth b4 environment.
Ecocentric
See us & environment as interdependent, so environmental harm, hurts us also.
South - Types of Green Crimes
> Primary
> Secondary
South - Primary Green Crime
> Crimes direct result of destruction & degradation of earth’s resources
> e.g. Air pollution, deforestations, animal abuse, water pollution
South - Secondary Green Crimes
> Results from defying rules aimed @ stopping regulating environmental disasters
> e.g. State violence vs environmental groups, hazardous waste & organised crime (toxic waste dumping)