4.3 - Realist Theories on Crime Flashcards
General RR view on Crime
Share NR views & 0 tolerance on crime, threatens SS & work ethic
General LR view on Crime
Reformists & want =
RR - Attiudes to Other Theories
Failed to solve problem of crime to sympathetic to criminal & hostile of police & courts
RR - Practical Solutions
> Control & punishment
> Not rehabilitation or fixing poverty
RR - View on Causes of Crime
> Not due to poverty or eco factors
> But due to biological diff, poor socialisation & underclass, rational choice
RR view on Crime - (KS)
> Wilson & Hernstein (Biological Differences)
> Murray (Underclass)
> Clarke (Rational Choice Theory)
> Felson (Routine Activity Theory)
> Wilson & Kelling (0 Tolerance - Solutions to Crime)
Wilson & Hernstein - Biological Differences (RR)
> Some are innately predetermined to do crime in their DNA
> Programmed to be very aggressive & dumb - + likely to do crime
Lilly - Criticisms of Wilson & Herrnstein
Intelligence diff account for only 3% of diff in offending
Underclass - Murray (RR)
> NF undermined by welfare state, leading to + of LPF underclass w/ inadequate socialisation
> Lack M role models & discipline, key values not taught
> Boys join gangs to get status through crime > supporting families
Rational Choice Theory - Clarke (RR)
> Have FW & choice 2 do crime, if + of doing crime > - + likely to offend
> Current costs of crime are -, so crime has +
> Need for 0 tolerance approach
General Criticisms of Clarke
> How can criminals be rational actors, but behaviour due to biology & socialisation
> Overexaggerates extent criminals make +/- calculations
Felson - Routine Activity Theory (RR)
> Crime caused by motivated offender, suitable target & absence of police & neighbour
> D’s act rationally so P&N likely to deter them
General Criticisms of RR
> Short-sighted ignores wider structural causes e.g. poverty
> Doesn’t explain violent or impulsive crimes
Wilson & Kelling - 0 Tolerance - Solutions to Crime (RR)
> Keep areas orderly so crime don’t take over, graffiti & vandalism needs immediate action
> Police control streets stop drunks & beggars, so law-abiding ppl feel safe
>
- of fines & prison sentences as deterrent.
General Criticisms of 0 Tolerance
> Allow police to discriminate vs EM, youth & homeless
> Ignores CC & leads to displacement of crime in other areas
Young - 0 Tolerance as Urban Myth (RR)
> Crime already - from 1985 0 correlation vs 0 tol & -of crime
> Police use arrests to justify existence, artificially + NO of arrests for minor things
How is LR similar to Marxism?
Unequal society root of crime