1.2 Social Psychology Evaluation Points Flashcards
Strength of authoritian personality for obedience
Elms and milgrim
Strength and weakness for locus of control obedience
Oliner oliner
Schurz
Strength and weakness for prejudice social norms
Filindra
Wetheral
Strength and weakness of individualism and collectivism
Prejudice
Wetherell
Sherif
Strength and weakness for authoritarian personality prejudice
Cohrs et el
Sherif
Strength and weakness of gender obedience
Giligan
Burger
Strength and weakness of situational factors obedience
Variation 7
Hofling et al
Strength of power distance
Obedience
Kilham
dolinski
Weakness of individualism and collectivism Obedience
Blass
Strength and weakness of agency theory
Milgrim milgrim counter point of 35% of ppts not obeying
Strength and weakness of social impact theory
Sedidikes and Jackson
Hofling at el
Strength and weakness of realistic conflict theory
Sherif and tajfel
Strength and weakness of social identity theory
Tajfel and Wetherel
Strength and weakness of milgrim
Burger
Low Mundane realism
Strength and weakness of sherif
High mundane realism
Tyerman and spencer or low populational validity
Strength and weakness of burger
High internal validity
Low mundane realism
Strengh and weakness of milgrim variation 7 10 13
High control
All conditions kept the same as original study =prods given shock machine
Only difference (immediacy etc)
Shows cause effect relationship between less obedient to less immediacy or streng of individual or legitimacy of environment
low Mundane realism
Strength and weakness for collectivism and individualism
Power distance obedience
Kilham dolinski
Blass
Strength and weakness for collectivism and individualism
Power distance obedience ( ex)
Kilham- low power distance Australia- 28% obedience
Dolinki-high power distance dolinki - 90%obedience
Power distance does have an impact on obedience
Blass- 65.94 % obedience across other countries
60.94% obedience in us replications
Suggesting that obedience is universal and cultural factors doesn’t effect it
Strength and weakness of personality - authoritian( obedience)
Elms and milgrim- 20 fully obedient milgrim ppts vs 20 disobedient ppts
Obedient ppts scored higher authoritarian personality on f scale personality does have impact on obedience
However cannot fully claim that it’s due to authoritian persona that is the cause of obedience may also be factors like lower education
Strength and weakness of personality- locus of control - obedience
Oliner oliner - found 406 rescuers who resisted orders > more likely to have higher locus of control than 126 ppl who obeyed
Loc can influence obedience
Schurz - Austrian ppts ordered to give painful ultrasound sound the female students
- ppts that obeyed or disobeyed didn’t significantly differ in terms of there scores on questionnaire measuring Loc
Loc may not have impact
Strength and weakness of gender obedience
Giligan- men care more about justice
Women care more about avoiding harm to other
Suggest : women - less obedient in harming others
Burger found that in both men and women 70% of ppts continued after 150v
Suggest: no difference in obedience in men and women
Strength and weakness of situational factors (obedience)
For proximity
Milgrim variation 7 - found that when the research left the room and gave orders via telephone obedience dropped to 22.5 %
Weakness hofling
When nurses were given orders to give an overdose of medicine to a patient from the doctor via telephone 21/ 22 obeyed
Strength and weakness of social norms ( prejudice)
Filindra
Increase in presence of immigrants correlated harsher immigration policy
Prejudice increase due = economic hardship and competition for jobs and resources justifying prejudice due to perceived threat to social norms
Wetheral- 8 Yr old indigenous Polynesian students in new Zealand where more generous with point allocation than Caucasian peers
Suggest: prejudice is ethnocentric