10.1 - Conservatism Core Ideas Flashcards
What are the three types of Conservatism?
- Traditional Conservatism
- One-Nation Conservatism
- The New Right
Why did Traditional Conservatism emerge?
In large part as a reaction to Enlightenment.
What are the main principles of Traditional Conservatism?
- Pragmatism
- Empiricism
- Tradition
Why did One-Nation Conservatism see a rise in popularity?
To preserve society, there needed to be more state intevention.
What was the main reason for the rise of One-Nation Conservatism?
The French Revolution.
Who was the main proponent of One-nation Conservatism?
Benjamin Disraeli.
Why did the New Right see a rise in popularity?
An argument that one-nation conservatism had sanctioned too many changes to the role of the state and had lost touch with true Conservative values.
Who was the main proponent of the New Right?
- Margaret Thatcher
- Ronald Reagan
Who was a main proponent for Traditional Conservatism?
Thomas Hobbes.
How does traditional Conservatism view human imperfection?
In three categories:
- Morally imperfect (selfish creatures)
- Intellectually imperfect (reality is always beyond rational understanding)
- Psychologically imperfect (humans are security driven and socially dependent)
What did Hobbes argue about human imperfection?
It is unavoidable and unchangeable.
What was the ‘state of nature’ according to Hobbes?
- Human desire for power and material gratification, while being naturally distrustful of others.
- Society prior to the existence of state.
‘perpetual and restless desire for power and power that only ceaseth in death’.
‘a violent anarchy where life would be “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short”’.
What was Hobbes theory on the ‘state of nature’?
- Humans would actively try to escape that state.
- They would form a certain social contract that surrenders some individual autonomy to a centralised monarchy in exchange for humans living collectively and without fear.
What is authority?
Those in higher positions of society who are best positioned to make decisions on society’s behalf. Their legitimacy comes naturally form within the hierarchy, and those below them in the hierarchy are obliged to obey.
What was Hobbes’ main book?
Leviathan.
When was Hobbes alive?
1588 - 1679
What was the premise for Hobbes’ ideas?
The anarchy that ensued due to the English Civil War.
What were Hobbes’ main ideas?
- How he imagined state and society to have formed.
- The imperfection and selfish nature of humanity.
- Humans are just rational enough to seek order.
- Society cannot function effectively without the creation of the state.
Who is Edmund Burke?
‘the Father of Conservatism’
How did Edmund Burke disagree with Hobbes?
Burke did not think that:
- Humans are ruthlessly individualistic but are naturally communal.
- Humans were capable of making mistakes to the same destructive levels.
- Decision making based on rational ideas of abstract thought is ill-advised.
What were Burke’s main ideas?
- The organic society is not static and must be changed to preserve it.
- Burke’s belief in human imperfection led to him rebutting most ideas from Enlightenment thinkers.
- The Jacobins’ quest for the ideal society failed (they sacrificed social order in exchange for the human rights of Rousseau and Paine)
- Burke was sympathetic towards the American Revolution (he thought the colonies had been completely misgoverned by the British government)
What was Burke’s main work?
Reflections on the Revolution in France.
What is empiricism?
The idea that knowledge and experience come from real experience and not abstract theories.
Why did Burke completely oppose the French Revolution, but support the American Revolution?
The French Revolution was built on abstract principles that discarded any empiricism and tradition for idealism that descended into violence and chaos.
Burkes believed the colonies had been completely misgoverned by the British and when they overturned the British, they did not abandon values, culture or tradition of the pre-existing society.
What was Micheal Oakeshott’s main work?
‘On Being Conservative’
What were Oakeshott’s main ideas?
- Conservatism is a much as disposition as it is a set of political ideas.
- Rationalism is beyond the ability of human beings because they are intellectually imperfect.
- Due to rationalism being flawed, humans should put more stock in tradition.
- Government should be grounded in pragmatism and empiricism, and not guided by abstract concepts of what should be.
What type of politics did Oakeshott argue for?
- Politics of faith.
- Politics of scepticism.
Why did Oakeshott argue for the ‘politics of faith’?
- Faith in rationalism is misplaced and those who act on the authority of their own reason will fail.
- The implementation of abstract ideas leads to unforeseen consequences.
- Be wary of making sure the ‘cure is not worse than the disease’.
What changes do the state enact if they subscribe to the idea of empricism?
Their changes are informed by past experience.
What changes do the state enact if the subscribe to the idea of rationalism?
Changes are informed by abstract ideas.
MacMillan’s adoption of state management and Keynesian economics rather than the long-standing tradition of laissez-faire government.
What do Conservatives believe about the evolution of the state?
It happens over time and emerges and grows rather than an instantaneous creation.
What do traditional Conservatives believe about state evolution?
Once the state is established, society then emerges and grows organically into a complex organism of traditions and customs.
Where do traditional Conservative thinkers disagree on the topic of power?
Hobbes believed in an absolute monarchy, but Burke and Oakeshott believed in parliamentary power, which are ironically liberal in origin.