Week 7: Negligence, Criminal Law, Coronial Jurisdiction Flashcards
Define:
Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Company
A landmark 1856 case that defined the concept of negligence. It involved Birmingham Waterworks and Mr. Blyth, where the court ruled that negligence could only be established if the company failed to act reasonably under unforeseen circumstances (such as a severe frost).
What is…
A legal concept that assesses whether the harm suffered was a foreseeable result of the negligent act. If the harm was too remote or unexpected, the claim may fail.
Remoteness of Damage
Define:
Mens Rea
The mental intention or knowledge of wrongdoing that constitutes part of a crime.
What is…
Laws formally enacted by parliaments or governing bodies.
Legislation
What is…
An institute that provides expert forensic medical services, including conducting autopsies for the Coroner’s Court.
Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine
Define:
Infanticide
The act of a mother causing the death of her child under specific conditions, such as post-birth mental disorders, treated differently from murder.
What is…
A principle from medical law stating that a professional is not considered negligent if their actions align with accepted practices among peers, unless those practices are proven inadequate.
Bolam Principle
What is…
A piece of legislation in Victoria that governs actions for negligence. Amended in 2003, it includes provisions on contributory negligence, mental harm, and liability, among others.
Wrongs Act 1958
What is…
A retired judge who led a review of negligence laws in the late 1990s following issues in the insurance industry, including the collapse of HIH insurance.
Justice Ipp
Define:
Civil Law
The branch of law dealing with disputes between private parties, such as individuals or corporations, usually involving compensation rather than punishment.
What is…
A threshold for awarding damages for non-economic losses, such as pain and suffering, where the injury must involve significant impairment (more than 5%) or psychiatric impairment (more than 10%).
Whole Person Impairment
Define:
Justice Ipp
A retired judge who led a review of negligence laws in the late 1990s following issues in the insurance industry, including the collapse of HIH insurance.
What is…
In this context, monetary compensation awarded to a person who sues for negligence, rather than referring to physical or emotional harm.
Damages
What is…
A specialized court that investigates deaths that are unexpected, unnatural, accidental, or violent to determine how and why the death occurred.
Coroner’s Court
Define:
Inquisitorial System
A legal process, particularly used in the Coroner’s Court, where the court itself seeks out evidence and facts rather than relying solely on the arguments of opposing parties.
What is…
Inquiries conducted by the coroner into medical cases, often involving evidence from healthcare professionals, to determine if a death was preventable.
Medical-Legal Investigations
Define:
Legislation
Laws formally enacted by parliaments or governing bodies.
What is…
The killing of a human being, which can be classified as murder or manslaughter based on intent and circumstances.
Homicide
What is…
A criminal offense under the Crimes Act involving the non-medical cutting or alteration of female genitalia, recognized as a form of abuse.
Female Genital Mutilation (FGM)
What is…
A form of homicide where the death is caused by negligence, recklessness, or lack of direct intent to kill.
Manslaughter
What is…
The termination of pregnancy, which is legal up to 24 weeks under Victorian law, with later abortions requiring medical certification by two doctors.
Abortion
What is…
A legal obligation where a person or entity must act with a certain standard of care to avoid causing harm to others.
Duty of Care
What is…
A legal system where two parties present their arguments to a judge or jury, who remains impartial and ensures fairness.
Adversarial System
Although not a legal term, refers to the act of intentionally ending a person’s life to relieve suffering, with discussions focusing on active versus passive forms within healthcare.
Euthanasia
What is…
A form of alternative dispute resolution where a neutral third party assists the disputing parties in reaching a mutually agreeable solution outside of court.
Mediation
What is…
No longer considered a crime under Victorian law, but inciting someone to commit suicide remains a criminal offense.
Suicide
What is…
The legal representative of the state in criminal cases, responsible for presenting the case against the accused.
Crown Prosecutor
Define:
Civil Negligence
Negligence that is tried in civil court and typically involves a failure to exercise reasonable care, as opposed to criminal negligence, which involves intentional harm.
Define:
Remoteness of Damage
A legal concept that assesses whether the harm suffered was a foreseeable result of the negligent act. If the harm was too remote or unexpected, the claim may fail.
Define:
Coronial Investigation
The process undertaken by the coroner to gather evidence, including autopsies and examinations, to determine the cause and circumstances of death.
Define:
Actus Reus
The physical act or omission that constitutes a criminal offense, which must be voluntary and intentional.
What is…
The level of certainty required to prove a case in court. In criminal cases, this is “beyond reasonable doubt,” and in civil cases, it is “on the balance of probabilities.”
Standard of Proof
What is…
The official written conclusions of a coronial investigation, including the identity of the deceased, the cause of death, and any recommendations for preventing similar deaths.
Coroner’s Findings
Define:
Wrongs Act 1958
A piece of legislation in Victoria that governs actions for negligence. Amended in 2003, it includes provisions on contributory negligence, mental harm, and liability, among others.
Define:
Female Genital Mutilation (FGM)
A criminal offense under the Crimes Act involving the non-medical cutting or alteration of female genitalia, recognized as a form of abuse.
Define:
Coroner’s Findings
The official written conclusions of a coronial investigation, including the identity of the deceased, the cause of death, and any recommendations for preventing similar deaths.
Define:
Coroner’s Court
A specialized court that investigates deaths that are unexpected, unnatural, accidental, or violent to determine how and why the death occurred.
Define:
Standard of Care
The level of care that a reasonably competent professional in the same field would provide under similar circumstances. A failure to meet this standard can lead to a finding of negligence.
What is…
A legal principle ensuring fairness and impartiality in legal proceedings, including the right to be heard and the presumption of innocence.
Natural Justice
What is…
The person or party who initiates a civil lawsuit against a defendant.
Plaintiff
What is…
The failure to take reasonable care to avoid causing injury or loss to another person. In legal terms, it refers to the omission of doing something a reasonable person would do, or doing something a prudent person would not do.
Negligence
What is…
The level of care that a reasonably competent professional in the same field would provide under similar circumstances. A failure to meet this standard can lead to a finding of negligence.
Standard of Care
Define:
Pathologist
A medical professional who conducts autopsies and provides expert opinions on the cause of death during coronial investigations.
Define:
Breach of Duty
Occurs when a person or entity fails to meet the expected standard of care, potentially leading to a negligence claim.
Define:
Common Law
Law developed through judicial decisions rather than through legislative statutes.
Define:
Euthanasia
Although not a legal term, refers to the act of intentionally ending a person’s life to relieve suffering, with discussions focusing on active versus passive forms within healthcare.
What is…
The requirement that the breach of duty directly caused the harm suffered by the plaintiff in a negligence case.
Causation
Define:
Reportable Death
A death that meets certain criteria, such as being unexpected, unnatural, or occurring in custody, which must be reported to the coroner for investigation.
Define:
Crown Prosecutor
The legal representative of the state in criminal cases, responsible for presenting the case against the accused.
Define:
Manslaughter
A form of homicide where the death is caused by negligence, recklessness, or lack of direct intent to kill.
What is…
Occurs when a person or entity fails to meet the expected standard of care, potentially leading to a negligence claim.
Breach of Duty
Define:
Abortion
The termination of pregnancy, which is legal up to 24 weeks under Victorian law, with later abortions requiring medical certification by two doctors.
What is…
The individual or entity being accused or sued in a legal proceeding.
Defendant
Define:
Criminal Negligence
A severe form of negligence where there is intent to cause harm, requiring proof beyond a reasonable doubt. For example, in cases where healthcare workers cause intentional harm to patients.
Define:
Criminal Law
The body of law pertaining to offenses that harm individuals or the state, with actions initiated by the state through entities like the police.
What is…
A legal process, particularly used in the Coroner’s Court, where the court itself seeks out evidence and facts rather than relying solely on the arguments of opposing parties.
Inquisitorial System
Define:
Balance of Probabilities
The standard of proof in civil cases, where the plaintiff must prove that their claims are more likely than not to be true.
What is…
The death of a child where it is the second or subsequent death of the parents’ children, or it meets other criteria for review by the coroner.
Reviewable Death
What is…
The standard of proof in civil cases, where the plaintiff must prove that their claims are more likely than not to be true.
Balance of Probabilities
Define:
Adversarial System
A legal system where two parties present their arguments to a judge or jury, who remains impartial and ensures fairness.
What is…
The body of law pertaining to offenses that harm individuals or the state, with actions initiated by the state through entities like the police.
Criminal Law
What is…
The physical act or omission that constitutes a criminal offense, which must be voluntary and intentional.
Actus Reus
What is…
A summary offense where someone attempts to hide the birth of a child, punishable by imprisonment.
Concealment of Birth
What is…
A public court hearing led by the coroner to investigate the causes of one or more deaths or fires, focused on uncovering facts rather than assigning blame.
Inquest
Define:
Good Samaritan
A person who voluntarily offers help in an emergency situation. Under the Wrongs Act, Good Samaritans are protected from liability for negligence when providing assistance, provided they act in good faith.
What is…
A death that meets certain criteria, such as being unexpected, unnatural, or occurring in custody, which must be reported to the coroner for investigation.
Reportable Death
Define:
Autopsy
A postmortem examination conducted by a pathologist to determine the cause of death, including both internal and external analysis of the body.
Define:
Medical-Legal Investigations
Inquiries conducted by the coroner into medical cases, often involving evidence from healthcare professionals, to determine if a death was preventable.
What is…
The act of intentional sexual penetration without consent, including the introduction of objects into the body.
Rape
What is…
A legal standard used to determine if a party acted with reasonable care. It refers to what an average person with ordinary prudence would have done in similar circumstances.
Reasonable Person
What is…
The branch of law dealing with disputes between private parties, such as individuals or corporations, usually involving compensation rather than punishment.
Civil Law
What is…
Legislation that governs the responsibilities and powers of the Coroner’s Court, including the investigation of deaths and fires.
Coroners Act
Define:
Concealment of Birth
A summary offense where someone attempts to hide the birth of a child, punishable by imprisonment.
What is…
A legal concept where the plaintiff’s own negligence contributed to the harm suffered, potentially reducing the damages awarded.
Contributory Negligence
Define:
Inquest
A public court hearing led by the coroner to investigate the causes of one or more deaths or fires, focused on uncovering facts rather than assigning blame.
What is…
The process undertaken by the coroner to gather evidence, including autopsies and examinations, to determine the cause and circumstances of death.
Coronial Investigation
Define:
Reviewable Death
The death of a child where it is the second or subsequent death of the parents’ children, or it meets other criteria for review by the coroner.
What is…
Negligence that is tried in civil court and typically involves a failure to exercise reasonable care, as opposed to criminal negligence, which involves intentional harm.
Civil Negligence
What is…
The mental intention or knowledge of wrongdoing that constitutes part of a crime.
Mens Rea