Week 5: Problem Solving & Reasoning Flashcards
What is problem solving:
What does Dunker (1926) think problem solving is?
- Solving a problem doesnt come from memory
- Solving a problem comes from goal-directed behaviour
What is goal-directed behaviour?
Behaviour that is focused toward attaining a particular goal
What is problem solving:
What does Mayer (1992) think problem solving is?
- Solving a problem comes from behaviour due to cognitive processes
What methods are used to study how people problem solve?
- Protocol Analysis
- Computer stimulations
What is protocol analysis?
- This is where you ask people how they solve a problem
- Ask people to talk aloud when they are solving a problem
- Use this method mainly to explore why people did something
What are the types of problem solving?
- Well-defined
- Ill-defined
What does well-defined problem solving mean?
Problems that are precise, and well-structured.
They contain a clear specification of three elements:
- Clear start state
- Goal state
- Operators
Any problem in which the starting position, the allowable positions and the goal state are clearly specified, and a unique solution can be shown to exist.
Example : A maths soultion
3x = 6
What does ill-defined problem solving mean?
Ill-defined problems are those that DO NOT have clear goals, solution paths or expected solution
- More like real life problems
- Less-logical, no clear options to follow
Strategies for solving well-defined problems:
What is prune the state space strategy?
- This means we want the fewest possible stages to get to the end goal
- Apply heuristics = rely on less info, allows for faster decision-making that require more info
Strategies for solving well-defined problems:
What is Exploratory strategies?
- Exploratory activities are independent, unstructured activities that provide opportunities to explore ways of interacting with the material provided.
- Weak heuristics
Strategies for solving well-defined problems:
What is hill climbing?
- Pick a move that takes you closer to a goal
Strategies for solving well-defined problems:
What is means-ends analysis?
Most important strategy
- To solve a well-defined problem give yourself SUBGOALS :
- Evaluate task: How do start & goal differ?
- Apply operator to reduce difference
- If obstacle prevents this : re-evaluate
- Create subgoal: remove obstacle
- Solve subgoal
- Set/solve next subgoal if necessary
Evidence for this strategy:
- People identify subgoals – people do use this
- Humans may use this strategy BUT not all problems have clear sub-goals
What are isomorphic problems?
Problems that are presented differently but are the same.
- Surface details (how things are presented) can affect difficulty.
E.g.: a & b are the same problem, a is presented differently to b, however people have difficulty solving problem b because it is presented in a trickier way, even though it requires the same steps as problem a.
Strategies for solving ill-defined problems:
What is analogical reasoning?
Mayer states that to solve ill-defined problems we should use a previous problem to help solve a current problem
- If the specific details in the previous and current problem are similar then a good strategy may be figured out.
What does Analogy mean?
Analogy (comparison between one thing and another) is only useful if relevant features are identified in previous problems.