Wall Street Prep RE Qs + CRE Flashcards
What is the investment strategy of the firm?
What types of properties does the firm invest in?
What is the structure of the firm’s investments? (i.e. equity or debt)
“What are the investment criteria of the firm?” (e.g. geographical focus, transaction size, risk/return profile, etc.)
Explain one past transaction completed by the firm, and why you found it interesting?
What is a Real Estate Private Equity (REPE)
REPE firms raise capital from investors – i.e. the fund’s limited partners (LPs) – to deploy their capital contributions into real estate investments.
The strategy of REPE firms is oriented around the acquisition and development of commercial properties like buildings, managing the properties, and selling the improved properties to realize a profit.
The limited partners (LPs) of REPE firms include pension funds, university endowments, fund of funds (FOF), and insurance companies.
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)
REITs are companies with ownership of a portfolio of income-generating real estate assets over a wide range of property sectors.
If compliant with the relevant regulatory requirements, these investment vehicles are exempt from income taxes at the corporate level.
However, the drawback to REITs is the obligation to issue 90% of their taxable income to shareholders (or unit-holders) as dividends.
In effect, REITs rarely have cash on hand because of the dividend payments and tend to fund their operations by raising debt and equity financing in public markets.
Most REITs are publicly traded entities and are subject to strict requirements on public filing disclosures.
Real Estate Development Firm
Real estate development firms, or “property developers”, construct properties from scratch.
In contrast, most other investment firms acquire existing properties, such as office buildings.
Therefore, development firms purchase land and build properties, while other firms participate in acquisitions.
The life-cycle of development projects is substantially longer than acquisitions, as one might reasonably expect.
Real Estate Investment Management
Real estate investment management firms raise funding from limited partners (LPs) to acquire, develop, and manage commercial properties to later sell them at a profit.
REPE firms are distinct from real estate investment firms because REPE firms are generally structured as closed-end funds (i.e. stated end date in fund life), while real estate investment management firms are most often open-end funds (i.e. with no end date in fund life).
Real Estate Operating Companies (REOCs)
Real estate operating companies (REOCs) purchase and manage real estate.
Unlike REITs, REOCs are permitted to reinvest their earnings, rather than the mandatory obligation to distribute a significant portion of their earnings to shareholders.
The drawback, however, is that REOCs face double taxation, i.e. taxed at the entity level and then the shareholder level.
Real Estate Brokerage Firms
Real estate brokerage firms serve as intermediaries in the real estate industry to facilitate transactions.
A commercial broker is hired to protect their client’s interest in a purchase, sale, or lease transaction.
Commercial real estate brokerage firms can help clients identify a new property to purchase, market, or sell a property on behalf of the client, as well as negotiate the terms of a lease as a formal “tenant representative”.
What are the Different Property Classes in Real Estate Investing?
Class A → “premium” properties, pose the lowest risk to investors, and lower risk corresponds with lower yields.
Class B → Class B properties tend to be more outdated (i.e. older), yet are still built with high-quality construction and well-maintained
Class C → Class C properties are even more outdated and less modernized compared to Class B properties and located in far less desirable locations relative to the prior two property classifications.
Class D → Class D properties are the bottom-tier classification and consist of properties in poor condition, while located in areas with limited market demand.
What are the 4 Main Real Estate Investment Strategies?
- Core - Core investments are recognized as the least risky strategy and involve modern properties priority with core investments is stability in performance .and limiting downside risk.
- Core Plus - marginally riskier than the core strategy aside from necessitating some capital improvements.
- Value-Add: More risk because the properties need considerable capital improvements. Real estate investors implement significant improvements resulting in higher pricing and more market demand.
- Opportunistic
riskiest strategy entails new development; time-consuming but also require substantial spending on resources.
What is NOI in Real Estate?
Net Operating Income (NOI) = (Rental Income + Ancillary Income) – Direct Operating Expenses
NOI formula neglects non-operating items such as capital expenditures, depreciation, financing costs, income taxes, and corporate-level SG&A expenses.
industry-standard measure of profitability to analyze property investments, particularly for comparability purposes.
What is the Difference Between NOI and EBITDA?
distinction between NOI and EBITDA boils down to industry classification because the factors that constitute “operating” and “non-operating” items are contingent on the industry at hand.
Operating Items → NOI neglects non-operating items like EBITDA, however, from the perspective of a real estate property, not a corporation.
Industry-Usage → NOI is seldom recognized outside the real estate industry
Therefore, NOI measures the profit potential of a property, whereas EBITDA reflects the operating profitability of an entire corporation.
Depreciation Concept Nuance | Real Estate vs. Corporations
The depreciation concept is nuanced in real estate because unlike standard circumstances, properties such as homes can be priced and sold on the market at a premium to the original purchase price.
The recognition of depreciation in the real estate industry is more related to tax deductions, while depreciation is intended to match the purchase of a fixed asset (PP&E) with the timing of its economic utility for corporations.
How is the Cap Rate Calculated?
Cap Rate (%) = Net Operating Income (NOI) ÷ Property Value
Explain the Relationship Between the Cap Rate and Risk.
higher cap rates coincide with higher risk, while lower cap rates correspond with lower risk.
Higher Cap Rates → Higher cap rates suggest property prices are low relative to the income generated.
Lower Cap Rates → Properties with lower cap rates carry less risk and are more secure – resulting in reduced returns – which certain risk-averse investors are open to in exchange for mitigating potential capital losses.
What Does Funds from Operations (FFO) Measure?
FFO used to analyse REIT; estimate the capacity of a REIT to generate enough cash.
Funds from Operations (FFO) = Net Income to Common + Depreciation – Gain on Sale, net
What is the Difference Between FFO and AFFO?
normalising FFO for items like non-cash rent and subtracting the recurring maintenance capital expenditures
Adjusted Funds from Operations (AFFO) = Funds from Operations (FFO) + Non-Recurring Items – Maintenance Capital Expenditures (Capex)
What are the 3 Methods of Appraising a Property?
Income Approach
property value = net operating income (NOI) / the market cap rate.
Sales Comparison Approach
Comparable properties to estimate the valuation of a property.
Cost Approach
“replacement cost”, the property value is estimated based on the total cost of replacing the property.
Walk Me Through the Income Approach (or Direct Capitalization Method).
estimates the value of a property based on the income expected to be generated in a one-year time horizon.
Estimated Property Value = Forward NOI ÷ Market Cap Rate
What is the Intuition Behind the Cost Approach?
no rational investor would pay more for a property than the cost of constructing an equivalent substitute with similar utilities and amenities.
Estimated Property Value = Land Value + (Cost New – Accumulated Depreciation)
What Does the Cash on Cash Return Measure?
Cash on Cash Return (%) = Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow ÷ Invested Equity
Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow → metric is post-financing therefore is a “levered” metric.
Invested Equity → The original equity contribution on the date of property purchase, i.e. the initial cash outlay.
What are Vacancy and Credit Losses in Real Estate?
downward adjustment applied to the potential gross income (PGI) of a property to arrive at the effective gross income (EGI)
Vacancy Loss → estimated losses incurred by rental properties left vacant. Usually projected as a percentage of the (PGI)
Credit Loss → losses incurred from a tenant who is unable to fulfill their rent payment obligations on time.
What is the Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM)?
ratio between the market value of a property and the property’s expected gross annual rental income. Reflects the estimated number of years needed by a particular property’s gross rental income to pay for itself.
Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM) = Market Value of Property ÷ Annual Gross Income
How is the Yield on Cost (YoC) Calculated?
Yield on Cost (%) = Stabilized Net Operating Income (NOI) ÷ Total Project Cost
What is the Difference Between Effective Gross Income (EGI) and Net Operating Income (NOI)?
EGI = PGI + Ancilliary Income - Vacancy and Credit Losses
NOI = EGI - OpEx
What is the Loan-to-Value Ratio (LTV)?
Loan-to-Value Ratio (LTV) = Loan Amount ÷ Appraised Property Fair Value
What Does the Loan-to-Cost Ratio (LTC) Measure?
Loan to Cost Ratio (LTC) = Total Loan Amount ÷ Total Development Project Cost
Total Dev. Costs:
Hard Costs, Soft Costs, Property Purchase (or Acquisition Cost), Operating Expenses (Opex)
How is the Debt Yield Calculated?
Debt Yield (%) = Net Operating Income (NOI) ÷ Total Loan Amount
measures the risk associated with a real estate loan based on the estimated return received by the lender and the ability to recoup the original financing in the event of default. debt yield is an unlevered, pre-tax metric (and is capital structure neutral).
What is the Operating Expense Ratio (OER)?
measures the percentage of a property investment’s gross income allocated to pay off its operating expenses.
Operating Expense Ratio (OER) = Total Operating Expenses ÷ Gross Operating Income (GOI)
What is the Difference Between a Capital Lease and an Operating Lease?
Capital Lease → In a capital lease (or “finance lease”), the lease contract allows the lessee to acquire ownership of the leased asset. GAAP accounting standards mandate the recognition of the lease as an asset. On the other hand, a corresponding liability must be recorded on the balance sheet, and the interest expense tied to the lease is recognized on the income statement.
Operating Lease → In contrast, an operating lease is an agreement in which the ownership of the assets remains with the lessor. The lessor, rather than the lessee, is responsible for any asset-related costs, such as maintenance needs. Unlike a capital lease, an operating lease does not require the lessee to recognize the leased asset on the balance sheet.
What is the Equity Multiple?
Equity Multiple = Total Cash Distributions ÷ Total Equity Contribution
Total Cash Distribution → The cash “inflows” earned by the investor across the holding period of the property.
Total Equity Contribution → The cash “outflows” incurred by the real estate investor across the investment horizon, such as the land or property purchase price.
What is a rental yield
rental yield in real estate compares the rental income produced by a real estate property to its market value as of the present date, expressed in percentage form.
To calculate a property’s rental yield, a real estate investor must determine the property’s rental income, operating expenses, and appraised property value.
What is the Difference Between the Gross and Net Rental Yield?
Gross Rental Yield → The gross rental yield is the rental income of a property relative to its property value, without consideration toward operating expenses
Gross Rental Yield (%) = Annual Rental Income ÷ Property Market Value
Net Rental Yield → identical to the gross rental yield, except for accounting for the property expenses incurred in the day-to-day operations.
Net Rental Yield (%) = (Annual Rental Income – Operating Expenses) ÷ Property Market Value
What are Examples of Questions to Ask the Interviewer?
Q. “Could you tell me more about your career path?”
Q. “How has your time working in the real estate industry and this firm been to date?”
Q. “Which specific tasks or responsibilities of your job do you enjoy the most?”
Q. “If you don’t mind sharing, what are some of the near-term and long-term goals you hope to achieve?”
Q. “For which reasons did this firm and strategy appeal to you when recruiting?”
Q. “Which specific trends in the real estate industry are you most optimistic about?”
Q. “Do you have any contrarian predictions on the outlook of the real estate industry?”
Q. “Hypothetically, if you could go back to when you were still getting your undergraduate degree, which advice would you give yourself?”
Q. “Since joining the firm, what are some of the most valuable lessons you’ve learned since joining this firm?”
Q. “What do you credit your past achievements to?”
Q. “Given my past experiences, which areas would you recommend I spend more time on improving upon?”
What is the RE Capital Stack
- Common Equity - riskiest but uncapped upside
- Preferred Equity - hybrid. Option to include fixed interest and participate in equity upside
- Mezzanine Debt: Higher interest rate but lower priority
- Senior Debt: Lowest interest, most significant, first priority
What are the four phases of the real estate cycle?
What factors influence the real estate cycle?
- Recovery → Declining Vacancy Rates + No New Construction
- Expansion → Declining Vacancy Rates + New Construction
- Hyper-Supply → Increasing Vacancy Rates + New Construction
- Recession → Continued Increasing Vacancy Rates + Excessive Supply in Market
How is the vacancy rate of a commercial property determined?
High Vacancy Rate → Low Market Demand + High Attrition Rate in Existing Tenants
Low Vacancy Rate → High Market Demand + Low Attrition Rate in Existing Tenants
Why is the cap rate the inverse of a multiple?
Cap rate is the inverse of a multiple because the net income multiplier (NIM) is the reciprocal of the cap rate.
Compare the cap rates for the main property types
Explain the relationship between the cap rate and risk
High Cap Rate:
- Riskier, potential, lower price, positive NOI growth
Lower Cap Rate:
- Lower risk, unfavourable market conditions, more secure, lower return
What is the difference between the cap rate and cash-on-cash return?
Cap Rate: unlevered cash-on-cash return as of the original date of the acquisition. neglects the effects of financing.
Cash on Cash: levered metric as pre-tax cash flow affected by debt service as well as equity contribution
How are property values and NOI multiples affected if the market cap rate rises?
Higher cap rates coincide with lower property values
Higher Cap Rate → Lower Property Value + Lower NOI Multiple
Lower Cap Rate → Higher Property Value + Higher NOI Multiple
What are the 3 forms of depreciaiton recognised in RE appraisals
- Physical Deterioration: Tangible wear and tear value loss
- Functional Obsoelence: loss in value due to market shifts
- Economic Obsolesence: loss in value due to external factors such as the local economy
What GRM is a good value and how can you use it to calculate property value
most real estate investors target a gross rent multiplier (GRM) around 4.0x to 7.0x.
Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM) approach estimates the value of a property by multiplying the annualized rental income of a property by the GRM ratio.
What is the difference between the yield on cost (YoC) and cap rate?
Yield on cost (YoC) is the forward-looking cap rate on property investments since the
computation divides the stabilized, “potential” NOI by the total project cost.
Stabilized NOI of a property is the pro forma NOI on an annualized basis after the new construction and property
development work is completed
How does the composition of the total project cost vary by type
The composition of the total project cost varies by the project type:
Development Projects → predominately the purchase price and the developmental costs
Acquisition Projects → On the other hand, the spending on acquisitions is mostly maintenance, fixtures, renovations, and discretionary upgrades since acquired properties can start operating and generating income relatively quickly
What are the common direct operating expenses deducted from the EGI
Property Management Fees
Property Taxes
Property Insurance
Maintenance Costs
Repairs
Utilities
What are the main costs that NOI neglects
financing costs, federal income taxes, and capital
expenditures (Capex
Difference between LTC and LTV
LTV compares to the property value
LTC compares to the total development cost
LTC typically preferred method for investing, LTV for acquisitions
From the perspective of a lender, is a higher or lower debt yield preferred?
Lower Debt Yield → If the debt yield is on the lower end, the implied risk to the lender is higher because the property’s
operating cash flows might not meet the mandatory debt service.
Higher Debt Yield → In contrast, the higher the debt yield, the less risk the financing poses due to the reduced likelihood of
the borrower defaulting on the obligation.
What does a higher or lower OER indicate
Lower Operating Expense Ratio (OER) → Higher Operating Profitability
Higher Operating Expense Ratio (OER) → Lower Operating Profitability
What is a capital lease
- Allows lessee to obtain full ownership of the leased assets
- PV of lease payments capitalised as a fixed asset
- Corresponding liability recording interest on the lease on the income statement
What is an Operating Lease
- Asset Ownership in lessor –> leased asset not on lessee’s balanced sheet
- Lessor responsiblt for asset-related costs, lease recognised as a liability on the lessor’s balance sheet
- Income statement recognises rental expense each period over the lease term
Common non-operating expenses in Real Estate
What is the IRR in RE investing?
Return that sets the NPV of Assets to 0, such that the PV of the intial investment is = the PV of the cash outflows
Main Sources are NOI Growth and Capital Appreciation
How is the IRR function actually calculated
In Excel, the IRR can be determined via the “XIRR” function, which is composed of two arrays:
- Range of Cash Flow → The net difference between the cash “inflows” and cash “outflows” per period.
- Range of Dates → The specific timing of each cash flow, formatted as a date
Difference between Levered and Unlevered IRR
levered IRR exceeds the unlevered IRR in practically all scenarios.
Greater the spread between the implied levered and unlevered IRR, the more reliant the returns are on debt to reach the target return.
What is the difference between the going-in and terminal cap rate?
Going In: expected return on date of property stabilisation
Terminal: estimated return based on projected NOI and sale in the exit year
exit cap rate uses far reaching assumptions
Ideal and conservative scenarios for the going in and terminal cap rates
Ideal: going in cap rate>terminal cap rate
Conservative: Terminal cap rate> going in cap rate
How does cap rate compression impact property valuation?
Cap Rate Compression → Increase in Property Value (Higher Purchase Price)
Cap Rate Expansion → Decrease in Property Value (Lower Purchase Price)
lower cap rate can signifiy lower risk, but increaess risk of overpayng.
Ideal scenario: cap rate compression + NOI growth
How does the interest rate environment impact property values?
Higher IR:
Higher cost of borrowing, reduction in demand, lower valuation –> cap rate expansion
one caveat would be if the supply remains insufficient to meet the current market demand, causing property prices to continue climbing upward even amid rising cap rates and in the face of rising interest rates.
What are the three common commercial lease structures?
Triple Net (NNN), Full Service Lease (FS), Modified Gross Lease (MG)
Describe the Triple Net (NNN)
- Tenant responsible for all prop. OpEx on top of base rent (incl. property taxes, insurance, maintenance and utilities)
- Rent is lowest
- Most common
What is the full service lease (FS)
- Landlord responsible for all OpEx
- Rent is fixed and all inclusive
- More expensive
What is the Modified Gross Lease (MG)
- Base rent has a prop. of OpEx while other relevant parties billed separately
- Limited standardisation
What does the term “stabilization” refer to in property development?
Meets following criteria:
1. Occupancy Rate → The property (or units) are fully leased or leased near market occupancy.
2. Rent Pricing → The property rent prices charged to tenants are around the market rate.
Most work complete or close to completion, minimial cap ex.
What is a good debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) in commercial real estate?
Therefore, real estate lenders often set a minimum DSCR covenant of around 1.2x to ensure the borrower is sufficient to service the debt burden, including a “cushion” to endure periods of underperformance.
The optimal debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) is widely recognized as 1.25x among industry practitioners.
The optimal DSCR ratio of 1.25x implies the property’s net operating income (NOI) is 125% of the total debt service.
What is the net absorption rate?
measures the current supply and demand in the commercial real estate market (CRE).
The difference between the total amount of leased space, the amount of vacated space, and the amount of net space in a period is the net absorption rate.
Net Absorption = Total Space Leased – Vacated Space – New Space
Positive Net Absorption → more real estate was leased relative to the amount available on the market.
Negative Net Absorption → more real estate became vacant or was placed on the market relative to the amount leased.
How does loan sizing work?
Determining appropiate debt burden supported by NOI. 3 ratios:
LTV, DSCR, Debt Yield
LTV Ratio → 70.0%
DSCR → 1.25x
Debt Yield → 10.0%
What is the development spread used to determine?
compare the yield obtained from undertaking a real estate development
project to the yield earned on an acquisition of an existing property to determine if the development project is worth committing to from a monetary and time perspective
The greater the development spread, the more economically viable a proposed development project likely is
While there is no set industry benchmark for a “good” development spread, most property developers aim for a target development spread of 1.5% to 2.5% (or ~200 bps).
What is breakeven occupancy in commercial real estate?
property’s minimum occupancy rate threshold to meet its Opex and DSCR, expressed as a percentage of occupied units.
occupancy rate at which a commercial property changes from an operating deficit to an operating surplus, i.e., the “inflection point.”