why is the use of vocal rest as a treatment strategy is controversial?
when to implement vocal rest
implementing vocal rest following the various forms of laryngeal surgery
implementing vocal rest as the initial treatment of some lesions of the larynx
program of modified vocal rest
speaking when only absolutely essential and using healthy vocal strategies
how to address advantages and disadvantages of vocal rest
use a criteria of looking to see if the advantages outweigh the disadvantages
advantages of vocal rest
usually see a rapid reduction in the size and severity of the laryngeal lesion
frequently accompanied by a decrease in the severity of the associated dysphonia
it allows the individual the opportunity to identify those situations that promote
identification of situation-specific vocal behavior is the first step in enabling the patient to modify the situations that promote vocal misuse
allows the therapist to determine the individual’s commitment to the process of voice improvement
if the patient is unable to adhere to the program you might want to internally question whether they are committed to making a change
disadvantages of vocal rest
extremely difficult task for the average person to adhere to and is even more difficult for those who misuse their voice (talky)
might be more beneficial to instruct the patient to reduce talking slightly while using a manner of voice production that does not harm the vocal mechanism
some patients become depressed with continued vocal rest
this is because some forms of abuse are related to emotional or personality factors, the addition of a program of vocal rest might serve to further compromise their mental state
duration of vocal rest program
types of vocal rest programs
complete vocal rest
elimination of all activities that either adduct the vocal folds into forced approximation with each other or cause the vocal folds to vibrate and result in the production of sound
behaviors to avoid during complete vocal rest
modified vocal rest definition
the use of voice is significantly reduced but not completely eliminated
modified vocal rest
conditions when vocalization is permitted during modified vocal rest
vocal rest program for children
implementing a program of vocal rest is especially difficult with children (think how tough it is for adults) as they find it especially difficult to refrain from talking
which type of vocal rest programs are more suitable for children?
modified vocal rest because the primary goal is to reduce talking time by one-half or more
a vocal rest program can only be used with children who
understand what has caused the laryngeal lesion
the child must be made to understand that
he/she is directly responsible for changing his/her vocal behavior and not anyone else