Valuation - Comparable Method Flashcards
Under VPS 5 of the Red Book, the comparable method falls under which approach?
Market Approach
Why is the comparable method used?
Direct and simple approach comparing like for like
What RICS guidance is there for the comparable method?
RICS Guidance Note Comparable Evidence in real estate valuation 1st edition 2019
What is a comparable?
Item of information used during the valuation process as evidence to support the valuation of another similar item
What is the economic principle behind the comparable method?
Substitution - the buyer of an item would not pay more for it that the cost acquiring a satisfactory substitute
What should a comparable be?
- Comprehensive
- Very similar
- Recent
- Result of an arms length transaction
- Verifiable
- Consistent with local market practices
How many comparables do you need?
More than one, as many as are relevant and recent
What are the RICS 3 categories of comparables?
Category A - Direct transactional evidence
Category B - general market data providing guidance rather than a direct indication of value, such evidence from published sources, commercial databases, indices, historic data supply/demand data.
Category C - other sources, such as transactional evidence from other property types and locations and other relevant background data
Why can the comparable method be challenging?
Unique nature of property make it hard to find comps
Rapidly moving market -out of date data
Limited evidence due to market conditions
Poor quality comparables
Unverified comparables
Outline the Hierarchy of rental evidence?
- New letting
- Lease renewal
- Rent review
- Independent expert
- Opinion
- Arbitration / court decision
- Asking rents
When is the market approach (market sales comparison approach) used?
Straightforward residential assets
Straightforward commercial assets
Straightforward rural assets
Could you apply comparable methods to other valuation approaches?
Investment - for net rental income & yield
Profits (income approach) asses Fair Maintainable Trade
DCF (income approach) to derive key inputs
DRC (cost approach) land and building values
RLV (cost approach) find GDV and development value
Where can you source comparables from?
Direct transactional evidence Publicly available information Databases Press Asking prices Sale prices Historic evidence
What must you do when researching evidence?
Verify it with the parties involved
What evidence gives the highest weight as comparable evidence?
Recently completed transactions of other similar property for which full and accurate information is available