Valuation Flashcards
What are the first steps you should take at the start of any valuation?
- Are you competent?
—> SUK
—> Skill, Knowledge, Understanding - Conflict checked
- Terms of engagement
What are some examples of due diligence necessary for any valuation?
Asbestos Contamination Environmental matters EPC Flooding Title Tenure Planning history Public rights of way Fire safety Rates and council tax
What are the main methods of valuation?
- Comparison
- Investment
- Residual
- Profits
- Costs
Please describe how you would use the comparison method to value a property.
- Source comparables
- Verify and analyse to get a net effective rent
- Create schedule of comps
- Adjust comps to subject using hierarchy of evidence
- Form opinion of value (MR or MV)
- Report and save file note
When using the comparison method, is there any specific guidance you might adhere to?
RICS GN ‘Comparable Evidence in Real Estate Valuation’ 2019.
Please outline why ‘Comparable Evidence in Real Estate Valuation, 2019’ is important?
It set out the hierarchy of evidence. This is important for all valuation, but most important to the comparison method.
Cat A = Direct comparable
- completed transactions near identical
- completed transaction similar
- under offer similar
- asking prices
Cat B = General market data
- databases
- historic evidence
- supply / demand
Cat C = other sources
- interest rates etc.
What makes a good comparable?
The best comparable will be an almost identical property, next door to the subject property which transacted yesterday and you have fully information on the deal. Think:
- recency
- location
- similarity
- transparency
- arms length
How would you find comparable evidence?
- Inspection (GOAD and boards)
- CoStar
- Agents
- Auctions
What would you do when there is a lack of comparable evidence?
Have to rely on older data and asking prices. Also consider Cat B evidence like demand and supply data. Always consider market sentiment.
Could also look at using an alternative valuation method which is less based on comparable evidence. Seek prof. advice as not competent.
Also consider VPGA 10 due to the market uncertainty.
When would you use the investment method?
When you have an income producing asset and a decent pool of similar comparable evidence to rely upon.
Please outline the basics of the investment method.
The capitalisation of a properties current and future income streams at an appropriate capitalisation rate to produce a value.
When would you use the term and reversion method?
I would use the term and reversion when the properties passing rent is below the market level. I would capitalise the passing rent until the reversion in annuity, and then capitalise the market rent at a higher yield in perpetuity, discounting the uplift to account for its delayed start, an the time value of money.
Please describe how and when you would use the layer and hardcore method.
I would use the layer and hardcore method when the property is over rented. I would capitalise the core in perpetuity at a lower yield, as it is guaranteed. I would then capitalise the layer at a higher yield, to reflect its higher risk, in annuity, until the point where it could fall eg. LR / Break.
If you had a rack rented property, how would you value the property?
I would value the property in perpetuity. I would calculate the years purchase using my assumed all risks yield. This is done by multiplying the yield’s YP with the rental income to come to a capital value.
What is the purpose of a yield?
It reflects the annual return on an investment, expressed as a percentage. In property, it represents the rental income in proportion to the capital value of the property.
What are current prime yields in:
- Office
- Retail
- Industrial
Prime
- 3.25%
- 6.00% (high street)
- 3.50%
What is an all risks yield?
Used on a fully let property at market rent. Growth and risk implicit and used to YP an income stream to get a capital value.
What is an initial yield?
The yield initially achieved when purchasing a property. This will be the passing rent over the price paid for the property. Growth implicit all risks yield.
What is a reversionary yield?
The yield you will receive on reversion. This is the market rent over the CAPITAL VALUE of a property.
What is an equivalent yield?
The weighted average yield between the initial and the reversionary yield.
If you had to calculate investment value under the investment method, how would you do it? Please also describe the process.
DCF
- Estimate cash flow
- Estimate exit value
- Select discount rate
- Discount CF
- Sum of discounted CF is NPV
What is the NPV?
It shows the investment will likely give a positive return at the investors target rate of return.
What is the IRR?
An IRR is the discount rate at which the NPV of all income streams will equal zero. Used to assess investment quality.
Please outline when you would use the profits method.
The profits method is used to value the profitability of a business trading from a specific unit. It is often used for assets which rarely transact and have limited comparable evidence e.g. pubs, pharmacies etc.
Please outline the basic process of the profits method.
- Get three years audited accounts for the business
- Calculate a fair maintainable operating profit
- Capitalise at yield to calculate MV
What is the purpose of the residual method?
A tool to financially assess either:
- Viability of development (development appraisal); or
- Establish suitable site value (residual site valuation)
Please outline the general method of a residual valuation.
- Calculate value of completed development
- Deduct costs of construction
- Deduct developers profits
- Deduct cost of finance
- Remainder is residual site value
What are the limitations of the residual method?
- Reliant on accurate inputs
- Small adjustment can mean big change
- Doesn’t consider the timing of payments
- Deals with finance in basic manner
What guidance is available with regards to the residual method?
RICS GN ‘Valuation of Development Property’ 2019:
- cross check with other vals
- sensitivity analysis
- DCF for complex schemes
What is the DRC method used for?
DRC is used when a unique asset that does produce an income, or an attributable income, is to be valued.
What is the general method of the DRC?
- Value land, assuming planning is granted.
2. Deduct costs of rebuilding the building on the site, depreciating it afterwards.
What are the sections of the RICS global standards?
- Intro
- Glossary
- Professional standards (PS)
- Valuation technical & performance standards (VPS)
- Valuation applications (VPGAs)
- International Valuations standards (IVS)
What role does IVS play in the formation of the red book?
They are the global standard setter for professional valuation. Therefore, there policy on best practice is implemented into the real estate valuation profession via the Red Book. We can see IVS 101-105 as reflected in VPS 1-5 for example.
What is the benefit of IVS’ involvement in the formation of the red book?
Transparency
Consistency
Confidence
When was the latest version of the red book effective from? What were the changes?
January 2020
- PS1 where written can now mean AVM
- PS2 where “professional scepticism” now mandatory
- VPS3 reinforcing that reports must state valuation approach, rational and a new focus on sustainability
What is PS1?
Compliance with standards where a written valuation is provided.
- basically, when is a valuation a red book valuation?
When is a valuation a red book valuation?
All valuations are red book valuations apart from the following:
- Negotiation / litigations
- Statutory function
- Internal purposes
- Agency
- Expert witness
What is PS2?
Ethics, competency, objectivity, disclosure.
- must comply with 5 global ethical standards and rules of conduct
- must remain objective, implement conflict check and use “prof. Scepticism”
- terms of engagement should understand requirements, comply w/ VPS1 and show competence